Amazon Kindle or Barnes & Noble NOOK

Albuquerque, NM(Zone 7a)

I've been an avid reader all my life but now find that books are taking
over so much space in our home. Many are scholastic or research books
or books that I want to keep but for light reading I'd love to save room
and use a reader. I've researched both but wonder if anyone here
uses either of them and what the opinions are. I'm leaning towards the
Kindle.

(Sheryl) Gainesboro, TN(Zone 6b)

June, did you make up your mind yet? We have the Kindle, an iTouch and one of the Sony's in this house....

Albuquerque, NM(Zone 7a)

No decision yet but I'm leaning towards the Kindle. I definitely don't want
the ITouch but will take a look at the Sony. I haven't heard anything about
that one. My birthday comes up in June and my DH loves to buy electronics
for me so this would possibly be a "hint hint" to him before then!

(Sheryl) Gainesboro, TN(Zone 6b)

The Kindle is a great machine - and I like Amazon as a service. But with the Kindle, it's the only service, whereas the others aren't dedicated to one place.

The one big advantage to the iTouch is that I can read in bed when DH has turned out the lights, as well as the other applications that I can add on it - it can be used as a small browser, and my weight loss program is on it. DH had a whole plethora of junk on his before he traded it.

But a lot of people prefer the size of the page on the Kindle.

Aren't we lucky to have geeks for DHs?

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

Just saw this thread; I hinted for a Kindle for Mother's Day and am enjoying it. I didn't like the idea of an electronic reader instead of a paper book, but I ended up wanting one for the same reason that June mentioned; I am just out of house room for books. They're piled all over the place and in double rows on shelves in most of our rooms, and when I get back from Border's with another stack I have no idea where to put them! I'll still need to buy regular books because not everything I want to read is on Kindle, but I think this will help.

(Sheryl) Gainesboro, TN(Zone 6b)

I'm having an issue right now - I'm reading "Wolf Hall" - a pretty good sized book, and it's not possible to turn back in order to reference names or events. Annoying. I'm guessing there's probably a search feature that I haven't learned about yet....

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

Sheryl, if I think I want to reference something I can make a note of it. But you're right, I would find that very frustrating. I have "Lunch in Paris" and it has recipes; I made notes of them but it's still not very convenient.

Also, if you turn the Kindle off completely it seems to then disable the back button. I called them and they said they were aware of the problem and were working on a software update for it, which they will send to people's Kindles once it's available.

Albuquerque, NM(Zone 7a)

Your comments are enlightening; things I hadn't thought of.

Not being able to turn back to reference is a biggie. I use
little Post-It markers on pertinent pages as I read because
notes seem to get sucked into some vortex where such things
disappear. I'll have to keep thinking about this because my
birthday is in a few weeks and DH is pressuring for ideas.

I did get two new book suggestions though - "Lunch in Paris" and
"Wolf Hall". ;-) Just what I need -- more books!

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

"Lunch in Paris" is very good if you like French cuisine and books about Americans (or Brits) in Paris. I also just finished Fernanda Eberstadt's "Rat," which is about a young girl living a marginalized life near Collioure, on the Mediterranean, and I really enjoyed it. It was available on Kindle before it was issued in paperback, another good thing about that format.

Albuquerque, NM(Zone 7a)

Ah, I just saw a CNET article that a slimmer Kindle is coming out in August.
http://is.gd/cuXeh

My birthday is in June so I may ask for a rain check on my birthday present
so I can check that one out.

(Sheryl) Gainesboro, TN(Zone 6b)

Yeah, unfortunately I never mark anything for the future 'cause I never know what I'm not going to remember, lol....

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

If I were reading a book with a complex set of characters, or especially if they had foreign names that made them hard to remember, I would really have difficulty with the Kindle because it would be too hard to check back to see where they were first introduced. On the other hand, I do enjoy it for most of the books I've ordered for it.

(Sheryl) Gainesboro, TN(Zone 6b)

*Exactly*. I will say, however, that this is only the second time I've really run into it ....

My DH is using his new iPad as a reader - it's very nice as far as size is concerned.

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

I was considering an iPad instead, and that's what my kids planned to get for me, but from the reviews it sounded as though if what you really wanted was just an e-reader, the Kindle had the most options in terms of titles, and was also smaller and easier to bring with you.

I already have an iPod Touch, which I love, and if Verizon ever gets iPhones I'll switch to that.

(Sheryl) Gainesboro, TN(Zone 6b)

I completely agree - it would be way overdone if a reader is specifically what you wanted. The iPad is somewhere between a mega-iTouch and a mini computer.

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

That was my impression from reading about it. And the other thing that made me hesitate about jumping on the iPad bandwagon was that it's usually not the greatest idea to be, essentially, the beta testers for a product.

Still, those lovely ads for the iPad featuring a page from Winnie the Pooh showing Ernest H. Shepard's illustrations in full color were SO tempting!

(Sheryl) Gainesboro, TN(Zone 6b)

Aw, I didn't see them. Probably a good thing!

Minneapolis, MN(Zone 5a)

greenhouse_gal,
I have an iPod Touch and downloaded the Kindle app to it and I love it. I've been reading like a mad man since I got the iPod Touch. It's a great size for taking with you and you can go forward or back in the pages with a flick of the finger. No need to purchase a Kindle or anything else if you have an iPod Touch.
My .02
Mike

Albuquerque, NM(Zone 7a)

Thanks, Mike. I already have an IPod Nano but will check out the Touch.

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

Treelover, I have the iPod Touch but haven't downloaded the Kindle app for it. I read very quickly, so I have the text on my Kindle set to the smallest size possible in order to have the most words on a page, and I think that would be an issue with the Touch. I am now thinking of getting an iPad, though, so that I can check email and websites while traveling, since we're planning a vacation.

June, I love my iPod Touch. Actually I could check my email on that, too, but it would be hard to type much with that tiny popup keyboard.

Sheryl, how portable is your DH's iPad, and would it cumbersome on a plane?

Jamestown, KY(Zone 6a)

I got the Kindle for Christmas and I absolutely love it!! There are thousands of free books on Amazon.com and I have already downloaded 59 free ones that I really want to read. There are reviews if you are not familiar with the book. Prices start at $.99 and up.

My DIL got a Kindle also. She loves it too.

Benton, KY(Zone 7a)

Me too.
Got a Kindle for Christmas and am just learning to navigate. I'm going to love it!
I also made a case for it out of an old blue jean leg that I'd overdyed, preferring to make my own instead of opting for the commercial ones.

Thumbnail by melody
Mobile, AL(Zone 8b)

Hi, In and around 1997 I started e-book reading with RCA's eBook Reader downloading books from Fictionwise.com Loved it & still use it. RCA sold the thing to a company called ebookwise.com. The first RCA version was $300.00 or so. The new company let us Have the new version for $35.00. Now I have Two, Keeping all new software updates on the new one. They do lots I wish my Kindle could. I've sent 3 books on gardening back to Amazon & they are very understanding about the referencing awkwardness letting me keep the books 2 weeks more with a full refund. With ebookwise you highlight a word or name, you are then offered the choice to see when the name first appears and next appears then just as easy go back to last use, and you are on the page you are reading. So refering back or forward is a breeze. It is backlit it & is touch screen. But I love my Kindel, the ease of buying books,the instant book arrival with wispernet, the pre-order download. AND THE IPAD APP. So when Kindel has ebookwise.coms nice extras it will be perfect. As for the nook I did look, but jeez I have too much stuff. JIMT.

Acton, CA(Zone 8b)

daughter got a kindle and she loves it, though the price has already come down since we got it for her... but my wife got an IPad for the same reason and for the $$ the iPad was definitely a better buy... she can hardly put it down. It does SO much more... but still can work just like a kindle if you just want to read something.

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

I got a Kindle last Mother's Day and really liked it, but then I did end up getting an iPad because we were going to France this fall and I needed some way to keep in touch via email and the web. I almost never use my Kindle anymore, although I do use the Kindle app on the iPad. I just like the reading experience on the iPad better. I downloaded Zinio for magazines and that's nice, too. You get full color and can expand the pages with a couple of fingers if you need to make the text larger.

Minneapolis, MN(Zone 5a)

Well, I broke down and purchased a Kindle and I LOVE it! Just prior to Valentines Day, Amazon had a special for free two-day shipping on the Kindle. I ordered the Kindle on Thursday, 2-10-11, and I received the Kindle on Friday, 2-11-11. A great deal.

MY iPod Touch is almost full of music and decided I should get the Kindle so I could free up space on the iPod Touch for more music. (I know I need to break down and buy the 64G iPod Touch.)

Between the iPad and Kindle, there is a HUGE difference in price, but the iPad does a lot more than the Kindle. I do like the size of the Kindle (the smaller Kindle). A co-worker has the larger Kindle and she does not really like it because it's so big and clunky to carry around.

If you get a Kindle, you will not be disappointed.

It is true that you cannot buy books from anywhere other than Amazon when you own the Kindle. I purchased a book on another website that said it could be read on the Kindle (and there was even a Kindle download link) and it will not transfer to the Kindle. I can read it on my computer, but that's it.
Mike

Jamestown, KY(Zone 6a)

I purchased ebooks from a person, not Amazon. He sent it to my computer then I transferred it to Kindle.
My daughter-in-law downloads free ebooks from her public library onto her Kindle.

P.S. I love my Kindle too.

Minneapolis, MN(Zone 5a)

fc,
How do you get the ebooks on your Kindle? The books I purchased are in the Kindle app on my computer (iMac), but when I update my Kindle (I turn on the Wireless) only those books I've purchased through Amazon transfer to the Kindle.

Any help you can offer will be appreciated.
Thanks,
Mike


Jamestown, KY(Zone 6a)

Mike,
The ebooks were sent to my email. I saved them on my desktop. Then I plugged Kindle straight into computer with USB cord. Somewhere you have a choice in a drop down menu to put it into Kindle via 2 choices that I can't think of now. I went to my email to see if I could refresh my memory and my yahoo can't load my emails right now. I will look again this evening when I get home.
But there is a way.

Jamestown, KY(Zone 6a)

treelover3,
Okay I looked in my email and it was a notice from Amazon that this person named Kdmoore that I bought a book from had sent it to my personal acccount. Let me copy and paste. That can explain it better than I can:


Hello from Amazon.com,

kdmoore has sent the following document to your free Personal Document Service account ("name"@free.kindle.com):

You can receive this document directly on your Kindle by connecting to a Wi-Fi network. Alternatively you can download the document to your computer by logging into your Amazon.com account and clicking on the link below:
(the name of the book)
You can then transfer the document to your Kindle through the USB cable.

You can learn more about transferring personal documents to your Kindle in our help pages:
http://www.amazon.com/kindlepersonaldocuments/
If you would like immediate assistance, please contact customer support at +1-866-321-8851 (US customers) or +1-206-266-0927 (International Customers).

Sincerely,
Amazon Kindle Support


It worked for me.
Judy

Gulfport, MS

Just had to add--I have a NOOK and I love it. Does anyone else have NOOK or is Kindle the only game in town?

Minneapolis, MN(Zone 5a)

Judy,
Thank you so much. I've been so busy I have not had the time to keep up with my thread updates on Dave's. I will give your suggestion a try.
Thanks again for taking the time to help me.
Mike

Minneapolis, MN(Zone 5a)

Yahoo! Success!
I am forever in your debt, Judy!
Thanks again,
Mike

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

My granddaughter's aunt got her a Nook for Christmas and she hadn't used it, so I bought her a gift card for it. Unfortunately they won't accept her purchases unless she also lists a credit card. She is fourteen and doesn't need a credit card, nor do I want her using mine. This is a very stupid business practice; I don't think the other ereaders have that stumbling block. Now her aunt is out the money for the Nook and I'm out the money for the gift card.

Auburn, AL(Zone 8a)

I love my Kindle, I started off with a first gen (purchased when they first became available) I'm a voracious reader and can easily read 4-5 books weekly. After several years of some very heavy use my beloved Dale (kindle) died sometime in the night..I of course, was devastated. I called Amazon to see if some sort of surgery, first aid etc could be given. Imagine my surprise when the customer service rep told me not to worry, a new kindle would be shipped out ASAP. I was thrilled and to top it off Amazon credited my account the amount needed in order to purchase a new cover. LOL either I caught them on a very good day or they happened to glance at the 3000+ books I've downloaded.

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

I'm sure your buying history didn't hurt! They should really just give Kindles away for free; I know my purchases went up when I got mine!

Auburn, AL(Zone 8a)

Between the kindle and the prime membership Amazon has me...and they know it!

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

Me too....my credit card knows it also!

Jamestown, KY(Zone 6a)

Don't forget that you can get thousands of free books on Amazon's website. I check it every few weeks because they change their free lists. There are always books on there that sound good. I read the reviews people have left. That helps too. I haven't spent a whole lot of money unless it's a book I really really want and it is not free.

Southern NJ, United States(Zone 7a)

Where do you find the free books? I see some posted on FB but they are almost never books I'd want to read.

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.
BACK TO TOP