Do you know this variety??

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

They said I should ask here!!
Thanks!!
:)
http://davesgarden.com/forums/t/718437/

Susan

Thumbnail by soulgardenlove
Stanford, CA(Zone 9b)

It could be 'Butterfly' but someone else may have a different idea. There aren't that many common variegated varieties.
http://davesgarden.com/pf/showimage/74532/

Springfield, IL(Zone 6a)

That was my first guess if it is grafted ... David

Walhalla, SC

Looks a bit more like 'beni shichihenge' to me...since butterfly usually has more of a light pink by this time of year (although you might be behind).

Newport News, VA(Zone 7b)

Beni Shichihenge is my guess too, the dark red is typical of what I've seen at our local nursery.

Laura

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

Well.. isn't this interesting!! I so appreciate the info!!

The name on the tag last year DID say "Butterfly"...as grown by a home grower that sells out of her back yard, so the tag was hers and hand written... and she doesn't specialize in Japanese Maples.. I just happened to see this and my heart jumped. It was $5!!!!

I was confused as the word, "rainbow" was the one sticking out in my head.. which is why I shouldn't count on my head to remember things.. The tag is under ground somewhere. However, I've looked at the pictures here and on google and it does seem to more closely resemble 'beni shichihenge' but a comment in the PF by Todd Boland and comments I've found elsewhere say they are very close.. so maybe mine is butterfly and one just hasn't been pictured like mine yet in the PF's? I would like to put it in the PF's, so ya think Butterfly is a safe bet?

Thanks!!
:)
Susan

Springfield, IL(Zone 6a)

Your area was freeze effected although this may have been put inside or been in a green house it could have been effected by cooler temps ...the most apprapros question is is it grafted if not how was it proagated... if seed grown it is not truly either!! david

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

I called her today to inquire about other plants and she said it is Butterfly.. How she grew it I don't know and it is planted outdoors and not protected..
:)

Susan

Newport News, VA(Zone 7b)

It's pretty regardless!

Laura

Puyallup, WA(Zone 8a)

I'm voting for Beni Shishihenge because of the red/pink tinge. hard to say though! Attached is a photo of my Butterfly, about 3 years old. Photo taken this afternoon!

Though now that I look at them side by side, I see your photo shows leaves with more "serrated" edges than my Beni Shishihenge. My butterfly definitely has that same leaf type.

This message was edited May 3, 2007 2:58 PM

Thumbnail by roxysgarden
Puyallup, WA(Zone 8a)

And here's a photo of my Beni Shishihenge. It's a bit blurry because it's very windy outside today!

Thumbnail by roxysgarden
Springfield, IL(Zone 6a)

A lttle late Roxy the plant has been identified by grower as Butterfkly see 2 posts above your first post ...D

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

Yes, but Roxy isn't the only one with doubts! http://davesgarden.com/forums/t/718437/ I'm going to take more pics! :)

Susan

Puyallup, WA(Zone 8a)

Well, I think I've talked myself out of it being Beni Shishehenge, but I'm not convinced it's Butterfly, either! I've never seen Butterfly (at least around here) with that much red/pink in the leaves, but the leaf shape is definitely right with those serrated edges.

Besides, I'm always looking for an excuse to post photos of my maples! I plan to get some photos of all my favorites this weekend to post. I only lost one this winter!

Stanford, CA(Zone 9b)

Susan, the amount of pink on the edges of the leaves and the amount of green in the leaf are determined by the amount of sunshine. It varies tremendously. I was going to post a photo of my Butterfly foliage but then didn't as mine is in bright shade so stays mostly white with little green all year long. I thought that it would confuse things.

Here's a photo of summer foliage on a tree with more sun.
http://www.carlmontnursery.com/product.asp?product_id=502§ion=177

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

"In the spring, the cream portion of the leaves are pink and in the fall the cream portions are a magenta color. The growth is usually short and twiggy to a large shrub or small tree." -- from the web site.. but yes, I agree, the pictures don't match up do they? I will continue to photograph and see how it changes throughout the season.. Regardless of the variety, I just love it though!!

Susan

Stanford, CA(Zone 9b)

Susan - I think that the website is wrong about short and shrubby. My tree and most sites say that Butterfly is a small upright tree.

Walhalla, SC

Small upright and shrubby would best describe it I think. Most trees that I have seen have been somewhat bushy but with an upright tree shape. So, somewhere between a tree and a large lanky shrub is what I would expect to see.

Meanwhile, 'beni shichihenge' seems to lean a bit more towards tree form from what I've seen.

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

Well... it was a tiny little baby when I got it last year and it's just a little more than that right now... so, it would be quite a while before I saw the full growth! :)

I'll just keep it out of the PF's for now and just enjoy it regardless of name! :)

Can anyone point me to a thread that shows how propagation of Japanese Maples is done? I'm curious how my back yard seller made more of these.. Thanks :)

Susan

Newport News, VA(Zone 7b)

The butterfly JMs I've seen in my area, which probably number about a half dozen 3-9 foot trees, all are upright and very vertical in shape with a little "vase" towards the top. Maybe they were pruned that way, but the were one of the narrower JM shapes I've seen.


Laura

Gaithersburg, MD(Zone 6b)

I know it has been a year since this thread was posted to...but I do have a Butterfly that I've had 15-20 years. We moved it about a year and a half ago. It has never gotten over 6-7 ft tall. Other than my wife deciding to "prune" it one year, and this year a branch coming down from a silver maple and taking out a chunk of it, it has been a faithful tree. Occasionally I remove branches that form from below the graft. I also pluck branches (usually very small) with non-variegated leaves. From what I see, this has a whole bunch more white than the 'beni shichihenge' I've seen. I posted a pic on another thread. But I'll post a different one here...

Thumbnail by john_hosie
Vienna, WV

It looks like a gorgeous Japanese maple I saw at a local nursery called Floating Cloud. Not sure of Latin name, but I could check if you want....

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

That's gorgeous :)

My Maple succumbed to drought and died. I have irrigation and a well now, so i can water as needed but this was a casualty last year before it was all put into place :( Hope to find and grow another one soon.

Susan

Stanford, CA(Zone 9b)

Sorry you lost your Butterfly Susan. That's always a hard thing. I'm glad that you've got irrigation in so that won't be aproblem anymore

Gaithersburg, MD(Zone 6b)

Butterflies are one of the more common variegated cultivars out there. You should not have trouble finding it at your local nursery.

I've been buying eBay JMs - mostly from jherter and houseofmaples. I've been frustrated by them, though. It seems the one-year grafts have not been quite as stable as I would have hoped. I probably bought too many to start with. Out of 21, (I'll give pics of those that are still around) I've ended up with four dead, and three with the grafted branch dying, but the host tree remaining alive and leafing out on its own.

I've had a particularly tough time with Peaches & Cream. I've gotten one from each of these guys. (I think) Both have succumbed. I finally went to someone else - I think it was acer198797. I expect it to arrive within a week. We'll see if it does better.

I also was surprised to find what I thougth were first year grafts at Home Depot. I've picked up a couple of these. I'll let y'all know how all do, and do the best I can to match names and pics.

One disappointment: jherter's trees arrive with a little label on the outside of the wrapping he puts on the pot. (House of Maples has a nice plastic tag wrapped around the trunk.) I mixed up the trees and tags when things had to be moved around. So now I have to go back and match names to trees based on appearances. I've found that appearances in pictures do not always come all that close to reality in front of your face.

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

Good to know thanks! I rarely see anything at HD that is as unusual, but I will certainly keep my eyes open. I have purchased plants on EBay and the shipping charges eat me up!... But sometimes you've just gotta have it! :)

Austell, GA(Zone 7a)

Susan, try Home Depot. I bought one last week - probably 2-1/2 to 3 ft tall - not very full but it was only $14.97.

Gaithersburg, MD(Zone 6b)

The key to buying eBay stuff is to find a seller who has what you want, and then look for what else he's selling that you'd like. Then buy 4 or so at a time.

For instance, jherter wants $7.50 for shipping on the first one year graft. But each extra one you want costs another $3 for shipping. Batch em together and you get a good deal. I think House of Maples had the same deal. acer198797 was a little more per extra tree, but between the packaging and the quality of the trees, I think it was worth it.

I have also watched the "buy it now" prices. If I see one that is particularly reasonable, I go for it - rather than jump into an auction and take my chances.

Finally, decide how far you are willing to go early. I've found that you can get a lot of the trees for $10-13 if you are patient. There are nuts (and I've been one) who choose to bid over $25 on a tree starting at under $10. But if you decide, for instance, that you're not going over $15, bid that much and don't be concerned if you lose. They offer these same trees over and over again - and sometimes they even email you for a "second chance offer" where they'll sell you a tree at the price you bid. There were only a few trees that I bid on that I really felt I HAD to have. The rest, it was just a matter of waiting. I saw Germain's Gyration go for over $20 several times. But eventually I picked it up for $10. You just have to wait for the squirrels to take care of all the nuts and you'll get a bargain.

I have to say, though, even though it was a little crazy to bid $25 on a tree, the Eskimo Sunset was worth it.


Thumbnail by john_hosie
Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

Thanks for the info! :)

I met a real live guy in one of my garden clubs who claimed to have paid $200 for a daylilly he had to have... I wonder if it came with drinks and dinner! :)



Stanford, CA(Zone 9b)

There have been daylilies that have gone at auction for thousands (yes, count them) thousands of dollars. If he claimed that he spent $200.00 that's probably what he paid. New intros start at $75.00 and go up from there.

Marietta, GA(Zone 7b)

hmmm.. i guess there is a market for everything :) I vacillate on a daylily if it's $5-7 !! :)

I like quality with my flowers... but I certainly lean toward economy and quantity :)

Susan

Post a Reply to this Thread

You cannot post until you , sign up and subscribe. to post.
BACK TO TOP