Do the plants mind?

Lake Orion, MI(Zone 6a)

I know this is the oddest question, but whenever I see a topiary, or a bonsai, or any other trained, pruned, manipulated plant, I wonder -- does the plant mind? I don't know if plants have "feelings" (as we would relate to them) or any sense of what is natural for them. But I do wonder if plants care that I'm pruning them. I don't have qualms about doing it for the health of the plant (at least my definition of health), but whenever I prune for appearance I always sort of apologize to the plant.

Anyone else get these empathetic feelings?

barb

Plano, TX

--i feel bad for plants that are going to die in lowes or home depot because they have given up on them-- when i walk around my yard and check each plant i feel bad for the ones not doing well--not just bad for myself loosing a plant but for the plant--a plant being a living thing it's hard not to think of living things as somehow having feelings!

Barnesville, GA(Zone 7b)

Well, at the risk of sounding like a "loony"..........the feelings for our plants are natural since we DO care for them and in addition, what is wrong with talking to them?? except for people that can see you.........LOL. DH has grown accustomed to my mutterings while out in the yard.........talking to the birds, whatever creature I might upset while working. I think they ALL respond to our feelings. Here is one of the "mini-dragons" in a pot of thyme ........I'm happy to see these lil guys since they help care for the plants also by eating the bad boys!!

Thumbnail by bugme
St. Simon's Island, GA(Zone 9a)

You know, I'm glad to know that I'm not the only one who thinks like that. I do feel bad for sickly plants, and I talk to all mine, especially those that have just been planted or are looking a little sad. I talk to the roses as I prune, and the flowers as I fertilize, etc. I'm so excited about spring! We've had a few really nice days, and I've been sick, and I'm chomping at the bit to get outside.

Barnesville, GA(Zone 7b)

happy,
But do you talk to the "critters"? I'm already hearing spring "peepers" and a lovely sound it is to me. We have a wetlands area on our property and it will never be changed. Oh, spring please get here!!!!!!!!

Thumbnail by bugme
St. Simon's Island, GA(Zone 9a)

Oh, yes. We have lots of little critters around here. Tree frogs, lizards, bugs, and lots of other stuff too. I'm usually telling them to run away from the dogs, as my 3 Dalmatians are hard on the wildlife here. I can't wait to get out and dig in the dirt!

(Zone 6a)

I talk to my plants too, I think my neighbors might have heard me talking to a bush once....it was embarassing! But I talk to all my plants "don't you look well today!", "what nice growth you're putting on." ect. ect. . I talk the critters too! It makes it all even more enjoyable!

Steven

Plano, TX

i have an atrium in the house with a light that i put on at night so they get extra light durring the winter--when i turn it off at night i tell the plants "good night" and if i forget to turn it on at night for them i feel bad--i have windows with mini blinds and plants that sit on a window seat by the windows--i feel so bad if i forget to open the blinds and come home from work and they had to sit in the dark!

(Zone 6a)

Sometimes I forget to turn on my growlights and my plants end up sitting in the dark till 2 or 3 in the afternoon. Poor things :(

Steven

Plano, TX

well i kept mine up all night when i didn't know they needed the dark too!!

(Zone 6a)

:) I think I've forgot to turn the light off too, poor things must get tired with light for 24 hours straight!

Lake Orion, MI(Zone 6a)

Now there's another good question! Do the plants need darkness? Lots of people in my neighborhood have accent lighting on their plants (mostly the trees) all night. Is that good, bad, or does it matter?
barb

Plano, TX

i know it does for mums--i remember reading that--and for tomatos

(Zone 6a)

I heard tomatos grow at night, so that could be why.

Lake Orion, MI(Zone 6a)

Meaning they like the light, or the dark?

(Zone 6a)

I think they need the dark at night cause thats when they grow, however they need the sun during the day probably to store up energy.

Bay City, MI(Zone 6a)

Plants also need to go through a daily dark phase (the light independent reactions of photosynthesis), also called the Calvin cycle. During this cycle, the plant uses the energy and hydrogen from the light phase, plus carbon dioxide from the air, to manufacture glucose (the plant's food).

Al

Plano, TX

thanks al--very good explanation!

(Zone 6a)

thanks Al! I've never heard it explained so well!

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.
BACK TO TOP