Photo by Melody

Sun and shade, wet and dry: The difference between yours and mine

By LariAnn Garner (LariAnnJune 25, 2008

"This will grow in full sun", is a phrase most gardeners have heard. What you may not have heard is that your "full sun" may not be the same as my "full sun". In fact, the difference may be so great as to cause you to lose your plant altogether, or have more success with it than I have! The same applies to how moist or dry a plant likes to be. Read on to find out why. . .

Gardening picture

Shade or sun?

If you are about to acquire a new plant, the first information you'll want to know is how much sun it can take and how much water it should receive. One would think that such information is easy to come by and, indeed, most plant listings provide guidance about these needs. The difficulty arises when the guidance is followed to the letter and your plant languishes or dies. If you've ever had this experience, or you hope never to have it, what I have to share here will be of benefit.

I became curious about this when I acquired some tropical plants and was assured that they grew in full sun in their native habitat. This habitat was a tropical rain forest, so lots of sun and lots of moisture was the ticket, right? Well, I found out quickly that "full sun" in a tropical rain forest is nothing like "full sun" in south Florida. In fact, full sun in a tropical rain forest is more like part shade because of the broken cloud cover and frequent downpours. Compare that to a south Florida winter or spring day, where "full sun" is brutal, non-ending sunshine from dawn to dusk, with no clouds or breaks for rain. Plants that do just fine in the "full sun" rain forest environment will be toast in south Florida full sun.

Moist or dry?

Once I learned that full sun in a rain forest means part shade in south Florida, I then thought about moisture. Rain forest means, well, rain, and lots of it, right? Actually, that is true, but that doesn't mean the plant loves to be sopping wet. How is this possible? The key is in knowing what kind of root environment the plant's habitat provides. A plant growing on rocks or in loose debris on the forest floor is going to have a lot of air around the root zone. This is true even when the plant is exposed to frequent rain showers. Contrast this with a plant grown in a soil medium that stays moist all the time, even when no rain is constantly wetting it. Plants that need the extra root aeration are going to languish or rot when grown in soil that is always moist or wet. In lieu of the extremely open or exposed condition of the roots in their native habitat, such plants will require a drier soil medium. This seems counter-intuitive until you understand that sometimes "wet" is really drier than you think! Understanding this also explains how certain kinds of cactus thrive in a rain forest. That fact alone should be enough to get you asking more questions!

Native knowledge

Whenever I have difficulty growing a particular plant, I wish for the kind of detailed information that is generally lacking. I want to know the seasonal conditions of sunlight and temperature, of soil and moisture, and of the community of plants that surround my garden specimen in native habitat. Instead, what I get is probably what the day was like when the discoverer of the plant found it. The day was sunny and the plant was growing out in the open, away from trees, so that means it likes full sun, and so forth. No matter that the day in question was the first time in two months that the sun had been out for more than an hour straight! See what I mean? But all is not lost, because often your plant will provide you clues about what it needs.

Coming up: If Plants Could Talk: Reading the needs of your plants

Photo credit: NWS public domain image

  About LariAnn Garner  
LariAnn GarnerLariAnn has been gardening and working with plants since her teenage years growing up in Maryland. Her intense interest in plants led her to college at the University of Florida, where she obtained her Bachelor's degree in Botany and Master of Agriculture in Plant Physiology. In the late 1970s she began hybridizing Alocasias, and that work has expanded to Philodendrons, Anthuriums, and Caladiums as well. She lives in south Florida with her partner and son and is research director at Aroidia Research, her privately funded organization devoted to the study and breeding of new, hardier, and more interesting aroid plants.

  Helpful links  
Share on Facebook Share on Stumbleupon

[ Mail this article | Print this article ]

» Read articles about: Tropicals, Soil And Composting, Weather And Storms, Hardiness Zones

» Read more articles written by LariAnn Garner

« Check out our past articles!

Discussion about this article:

We recommend Firefox
Overwhelmed? There's a lot to see here. Try starting at our homepage.

[ Home | About | Advertise | Media Kit | Mission | Featured Companies | Submit an Article | Terms of Use | Tour | Rules | Privacy Policy | Contact Us ]

Back to the top

Copyright © 2000-2015 Dave's Garden, an Internet Brands company. All Rights Reserved.

Hope for America