Photo by Melody
Guess what time it is? It's time for the DG County Fair! Now in it's sixth year, enter your blue-ribbon photos or mouth-watering recipes for a chance to win a gift subscription! Click here here to get all the details, dates and entry rules.

The scoop on 'Meyer Hatchery'

bookmark
  Company Profile  
Meyer Hatchery

Mailing Address:
626 State Route 89
Polk, Ohio 44866 (United States)

Phone: 1-888-568-9755
Fax: (419) 945-9841

Catalog Order Page: Hyperlink
Paper Catalog Cost: Free

» E-Mail them

Add to Bookmarks
» Visit their website
» Like them on Facebook
» Follow them on Twitter
Recent reviews:
Past month Past 6 Months Past 12 Months
Positive 1 3 7
Neutral 0 1 1
Negative 0 1 2
This company specializes in:

  Feedback History and Summary  
32 positives
8 neutrals
18 negatives

Comments:

Displaying the 50 most recent comments:

RatingAuthorContent
Positive chicchick
Pierz, MN
(2 reviews)
August 14, 2014
Customer service is stellar. There was a small problem with my order and replacement chicks were sent immediately. Chicks arrived healthy and are thriving.
Neutral mizG
Winston Salem, NC
(1 review)
July 6, 2014
While the customer service was very good and the chicks are healthy, DO NOT order from them if you expect accurate SEXING. I understand that they will most likely credit me the minimal amount difference I lost by getting several roosters instead of the females I had ordered. It is not really worth bothering to contact the company. A small credit will not fix the fact that I am out three females I was counting on and possibly more as I can't tell about the 6 marans (I ordered 2male?/4female?) and the 2 Sussex(I ordered 2females?)-These breeds are difficult to visually sex early. I can only hope for the best. Time will tell. I still must feed and rehome several males. I have ordered from Mcmurray many times over the years and they are extremely accurate in sexing. Never missed in fact! I will most likely order from Mcmurray next time. They do a better job of counting your chicken before they hatch.
Negative winteree
Grand Prairie, TX
(1 review)
May 16, 2014
so here is what happened i ordered 6 hatching egg's from Meyers because i don't like the idea of shipping live animals through the mail and because it was way cheaper then buying live chicks. And it was all i could afford at the time it was also my last ditch effort after 6 months of trying to get chickens.

I live in the deep south the eggs where coming from the north. I expected the egg's to be have a heating element of some type because it was 40 degrees here in Texas at the time. God knows how cold it was where Meyers was. The egg's where several days late they where suppose to have arrived on the 11th and didn't until the 15th of April. They didn't have a heating element and all but one egg had a detached air cells and the one that didn't have a detached air cell had no air cell at all. So i set the egg's the next day after they reached room temp and This is where the fun begins.

Even though I'm new to hatching eggs in a incubator I'm not new to hatching egg's period. I have been helping my grandma raise chickens since i was a little kid. And i have hatched under broody's just fine.

Long story short none of the egg's hatched. When i opened them to see what had happened the yolks looked like store bought egg yolks. No blood, no veins, no embryo's, no development of any kind. Nothing they looked like i could cook them.
So i called up Meyers to see if their was a chance these egg's had not been fertilized. And i was told by one of their people that i would get either a one time replacement of hatching egg's or my money back since none of the egg's hatched. which i was very happy about and made made the mistake of hailing them for not a week ago.

i don't know if it's me but when someone tells me that they are going to do something i expect them to do it

i then got a e-mail saying i in fact would not be getting a refund of any kind. So i called them again and i had a heart to heart with a very rude person from Meyers. And i found out the hard way that they discriminate ageist new hatchers. And won't give me a refund because i am new to incubator hatching and because i don't have a professional incubator. How did they even know this to begin with you ask? They used a online chicken forum called backyard chickens to spy on my conversations. And used my updates on the Hatch a long thread as an excuse not to give me a refund.

But you know what that's OK because not only am i never going to order anything from them ever again. But I'm going to tell every one that doesn't turn a deaf ear to me not to order from them either because if that's how they treat paying customers i don't want anyone Else to have to go thought this shear amount of stuff they have finished putting me through.

And for the record to the people from Meyers that think it's OK to use my confidence in more experienced hatchers ageist me. I have read EVERY hatching thread, post and book i could get my hands on and i went through the hatching process just like i was suppose to. So if my hatching process was wrong you need to take it up with sally sunshine because her process is the most professional i have seen and i followed her instruction's to the letter and YOUR eggs didn't hatch.

And further more i hope you Meyer people are paying attention I was going to order from you after i got my refund. So i could add some ducks. Now every season i get birds I'll get them from people who sell poultry and have nothing to do with your site. i was going to order from you but i see you all are full of it i can and will get my birds ELSE WHERE.

I will never order anything from Meyers ever again and you shouldn't either

Company representative comment on May 21, 2014:
On May 21, 2014 3:10 PM, Meyer Hatchery responded with:

Unfortunately, there are too many variables involved in a successful hatch, that we do not guarantee hatching eggs. Our policy states:

"...We will ship fresh eggs - the same eggs we hatch here. We guarantee the eggs to be true to breed variety and to arrive in good condition. However, we do not guarantee hatchability due to conditions beyond our control during shipment, and hatching equipment or methods used..."

In your case, April 11th was the ship date, not the arrival date. Most all of our eggs ship on Fridays, expect turkey eggs.

No mention was ever made to our company about detached air cells, cold weather, etc so we can't speak to that.

Found in a general "Meyer Hatchery" search on a forum, not by purposefully spying, comments post by yourself were discovered, that in summary, stated you had second thoughts because you weren't sure what you were doing and were also considering using methods that would be less likely to produce good hatch rates. E.g. homemade parts, heating pad element, etc. We can stand behind our product but can't stand behind those methods. It is why we have the policy in place that we do. So many unknown things can happen during shipment and incubation and clearly did, since we hatched the same eggs, from the same hens, the very same week with great results.

We simply do not replace or refund hatching eggs unless they arrive damaged. It was not a matter of discrimination, but rather sticking to our policy.

Positive jenjen182
Carlsbad, CA
(1 review)
April 30, 2014
Ordered some RIR Hatching Eggs from Meyer. It took a bit longer than expected, but that was USPS' fault. When the eggs arrived, they looked gorgeous and were wrapped up and padded by multiple layers. I was very impressed with the care put into these eggs. There were no cracks or dirt on them as well. I will be updating on the chicks that hatch, but so far, very impressed!
Company representative comment on May 21, 2014:
On May 21, 2014 3:11 PM, Meyer Hatchery responded with:

That's wonderful! We hope you have a successful hatch. Keep us posted.

Positive allicobra
Jamestown, NY
(3 reviews)
April 29, 2014
I am an experienced chicken owner on a small farm and I sell a lot of eggs direct to customers. Mt. Healthy is usually my preferred hatchery for replacement chicks but last time I put in an order I tried Meyer because of the larger variety they offer. I thought I'd give some insight about my experience.

Biggest Pros:
- Great variety. Offers many different birds all across the spectrum, certainly many more than Mt. Healthy does.
- Allows you to mix these birds in any number, even as few as 1 of each kind, as long as you meet the minimum to be shipped to you.
- Sexing seems to be very accurate. Of the entire batch I ordered I see no signs of any being roos.
- Probably the biggest pro... Excellent communication and service. I received emails of each step along the process. When I had to file a claim, the claim was promptly responded to and promptly taken care of to my satisfaction (and even above and beyond that).

Cons:
- Shipping cost me twice what it did for Mt. Healthy. They did have a heat pad in the box, though, which Mt. Healthy did not have. However, that didn't seem to make a difference because...
- I had casualties... The most I've ever had at once. One chick was DOA (a Marans, of course one of the most expensive), one was visibly weak and soon died despite being given electrolyte mix, a third died randomly overnight with no signs of having been sick, and then a 4th had leg/toe issues and soon couldn't walk. After trying to help it and seeing it fail to thrive and continue to decline, I had to put it down. Meyer did refund me in full for all 3 birds that died, though, and even though the 4th was outside of their 48 hour guarantee window, they refunded me for that one as well (see point in 'Pros' for communication/service). I accept that deaths are a possibility but this is the most I've lost at once before. If deaths bother you a lot... a caution (and a caution against even keeping chickens at all, honestly).

Birds seem a bit closer to breed standards than the ones I've ordered from Mt. Healthy. It's a bit too early to tell for certain, though, as they have a lot of growing left to do. So far, the colors and combs seem right, though.

I was satisfied with my experience and the resolution of my issues with it. I would order from them again.
Positive Bellamore22
Lindon, UT
(1 review)
February 22, 2014
Excellent customer service, promptly responded to questions I had and everything went smoothly. Really easy to order, you can pick a date estimate so you know when to prepare for your chicks, site has a nice layout, and the prices are as good as anywhere I've seen. I ordered 15 sexed chicks, they put in one extra one, which didn't make it, but I still got all 15 I ordered alive and well. 6 months later, they are doing just great, all have turned out to be girls, and have consistently been laying everyday. Compared to high quality breeder stock, I think it takes a trained eye to tell the difference. I noticed that a couple of my hens have been born with some white on what is supposed to be a red ear lobed chicken, so I believe its possible that they are not 100% pure bred. For the average chicken owner, who isn't into showing or anything, I think they will be just fine though, and mine are super pretty. Great experience overall, will order again!
Negative Amanda907
(2 reviews)
January 24, 2014
I placed an order on 12/12/13 for 26 birds including 6 bantams with a ship date of 1/27/14. I several phone calls at 5:30am on 1/24/14. I finally answered the phone, and as soon as Ursula announced who she was and where she was calling from I asked her if she knew it was 5:30am. She seemed unconcerned and told me she wasn't used to the time difference (I am in Alaska) and just kept talking. I feel that as a manager looking at my order she should have been able to note the location of my address. They are in the business of shipping birds all over the US right?
I interrupted her and told her I would call her back at a more appropriate time.

I understand that mistakes happen but I thought it VERY rude for her to not apologize or seem in any way contrite that she woke my entire family. I called them back at 8am and was told that they had an issue with their incubator and would not be shipping my bantams.

I was very very disappointed because they were for 4-H project but hey, things happen right. They said they could ship half my order Monday and then ship the bantam at the next hatch. Sounds okay right? Wrong, I was told they could ship them in July. Uh What??

No one seemed apologetic in the least about disturbing us at 5:30am with multiple phone calls, and they were unconcerned about the order that I had already waited over a month for. What a joke. I canceled the bantam portion of the order and am just hoping they manage to get the rest of it to me next week.

They did credit me the cost of the bantams that I will not receive but my shipping stayed the same.The sales staff were very nice and tried to help the best they could. The management was a joke however, apparently it was the office manager who called my home at 5:30am.

As a business owner I would have done everything I could to correct the failure and had I disturbed someone so rudely in the morning I would have called back at a later time and apologized along with sending a note and maybe small token. This was our first time ordering with Meyer and I think it will be out last. I will update my review to let you know how the birds arrive. I am not particularly hopeful at this point.
Positive TheBeardFarm
Mount Joy, PA
(1 review)
January 15, 2014
I ordered day old chicks.
They were promptly shipped and all arrived healthy and alive.
I raised them, and they are now large hens.
I ordered Barred Rocks, Dominiques and Rhode Island Reds.
Very happy and will order from Meyer Hatchery again.
Positive Sumatra01
Washingtonville, NY
(2 reviews)
November 25, 2013
I ordered two shipments from Meyer hatchery this year. The first was for 10 ducklings back in April. Having had terrible luck with another company last year, we were so glad that these duckings arrived healthy and STAYED healthy. Right now, they are grown up, laying eggs, and I am definitely satisfied with their service in the duck department.

Chickens are naturally more fragile, and unfortunately, two arrived dead in the box at my second order this May. Another two died withing the next 48 hours. Thankfully, Meyer sent replacements later on. Having raised chickens for many years, I know these things happen during shipping, and it has not given me enough reason to dislike this company. Also, as you many have seen by my putting the word 'stayed' healthy, in caps above, I am someone who looks not so much at the short term, but at the longevity of the animals within the next few weeks. Many people only judge a hatchery by the first 2 or 3 days after receiving the birds. Well, I must say, Meyer excels in having longer-term healthy birds. No failure to thrive, a strong immune system, and they have managed to avoid genetic defects present in other commercial hatcheries.

All this said, I am very happy with Meyers, and will certainly be ordering from them in the future.
Positive StewedMammal
Pembroke, MA
(4 reviews)
September 29, 2013
I ordered 20 chicks back in April. Lost 2 within a few days after arrival and one had a leg problem, but the remaining pullets and cockerel are beautiful and the pullets are laying great. Would defiantly order from them again.
Negative grantfarm
Tellico Plains, TN
(1 review)
August 24, 2013
I ordered a batch of chicks from Meyers that arrived in the 14th of august. Within 2hrs. of getting them home the chicks started showing signs of illness. I made sure they were not in a draft, the heat was correct, they had plenty of water, etc. I also used vital-pack plus water additive and gro-gel plus for their food. Nothing has worked and now all are either dead or dying. If your thinking I can't handle mail order chicks this is the 6th time I've ordered chicks and have always had good results. UNTIL NOW. Meyers Hatchery has completely let this farmer down. There isn't any reason in the middle of august for chicks to have this kind of trouble. The worst situation I have experienced is when I ordered chicks very early in the year. I will not be ordering from Meyers again.
Negative patricks1
Bath, PA
(1 review)
June 13, 2013
Ordered 5 baby chicks and had expedited delivery. 2 arrived dead and the 3rd died a day later. The response from the company was call on Friday to give the final number dead and we can send more. I know to a hatchery this may be normal but not to me or my family. I understand the risk of shipping live baby animals but to have heartless, disrespectful individuals ask you to wait till they all may die... is disgusting. Will never use them again
Negative kanakukkula
(1 review)
June 12, 2013
Today we received 9 Indian Runner ducklings from Meyer Hatchery, Ohio. We're in PA, so we figured it would be safe to order from an adjacent state, given post office problems of late. 8 of the 9 were dead, some for some time. Only one remains, and seems o.k. One month ago, we received a shipment from Meyers, for 5 Rhode Island Reds, 5 Barred Rocks, and 5 Columbian Wyandotte chicks. 3 arrived dead, and 2 more succumbed despite dropper feedings with electrolyte water. We are not novices to raising chicks and ducks, and lost at the most 1 per shipment before. It's not so much the money; it's the suffering of these little ones, which were to be basically pets. We won't be doing business with Meyers any more, needless to say. No refunds can compensate for what those poor birds endured. Our advice is to pick up at the hatchery. We believe the fault lies with both the post office and Meyers. KanaKukkula, PA
Negative AandDinIndy
Indianapolis, IN
(1 review)
May 28, 2013
Spring 2012 I ordered a rainbow pullet pack. Spring 2013 I have 22 hens that lay brown eggs. I tried to order another rainbow assortment and asked them to tell me what chicks they are sending me so I know I'm getting what I paid for. Basically they said we don't care if you're not happy about what you already got and no we aren't going to verify that what we send you is what you paid for. They cancelled my order and don't seem the lease bit concerned that I'm unhappy. Fine, I'll take my business elsewhere and be sure to let other potential customers know about how I was treated.
Positive gusser33
Windsor Locks, CT
(1 review)
May 25, 2013
I ordered 7 chickens in November 2012 with delivery for April 2013. When ordering these chickens the representative was very helpful in helping me decide which chickens would best suit my needs. Very helpful and did not rush me in the least. I ordered all different breeds as i just want them for pets. In March i received a message from Meyer that the chickens were due shortly and i would be getting an email informing me as to the ship date. I received another message and finally one stating that the chickens had been shipped. I received them the next morning at 9:30. Great delivery. One chick was very sickly and i didn't think she was going to make it and when i spoke with the rep. she told me what i should do but gave me a credit for the bird. Well, it was a Buckeye and the poor thing did struggle to survive. But she did finally, after a few weeks pull through. I would recommend Meyer to anyone looking for good quality chicks delivered by a company that provides outstanding service.
Negative Gypsy1964
Brunswick, OH (Zone 6a)
(1 review)
May 8, 2013
I ordered 3 started pullets in January 2013 (1 easter egger, 1 golden buff, 1 black australorp) . I live in Medina County Ohio about 40 miles away and drove to pick up the hens on April 27. I had them about 1 week and the golden buff started sneezing and shaking her head. About 2 days later the other 2 started doing the same thing. They all have a terrible "odor". Not anything I've smelled before. I called Meyer and talked with a customer service person. I asked her if anyone else had called with these symptoms and was told no. I asked her what she thought was wrong and she said its just a respiratory cold because the weather has been cold. Not true. Its been in the mid 70's around here. Perfect weather. She didn't seem to know anything about chickens and was on the "My Pet Chicken" website trying to answer my questions. Never once asked me if I wanted a refund. I'm thinking they have CRD (or Corzya, even worse) and went to TSC to get Duramycin-10. It's been 2 days and none of them are better yet. It's looking like I will have to "do away" with the 3 because CRD is easily spread and I don't want my flock exposed to this. It's treatable but is often reoccurring and the 3 will always be carriers. I'm glad I have not formally introduced the sick ones to my flock yet, but time will tell if my chickens will get sick from the 3 new ones. I will never purchase chickens of any age from Meyer Hatchery. Just be warned!
Positive Keith77
Peebles, OH
(1 review)
March 17, 2013
My experience with Meyer has been totally great. I received 2 orders this month on 3/5, and on 3/12. 15 chicks ordered for each date15 chicks arrived alive each date and all chicks still alive and doing well. Very strong, eating good, and no pasty butt. I did request a heat pack and it was still warm when the chicks arrived. I ordered 52 chicks and 17 ducks from another hatchery delivered 2/26. I lost 15 in the first 24 hours and 6 more within 48 hours. 6 ducks were DOA and 3 more died within 24 hours. To say the least, I was disappointed. I will definitely order from Meyers again.
Positive flamerider68
Irvine, KY
(1 review)
February 13, 2013
Posted on February 11, 2013, updated February 13, 2013
I ordered chicks on the 4th(Monday) and recieved them on the 7th(Thursday). It took them three days to get to me about 2-3 hours from the hatchery per mapquest. This was the first time that I had ever ordered from a hatchery and to say that I was excited to get my babies would be an understatement. I tracked my ordered and found that they had finally made it to my Post Office as I getting my youngest daughter ready for school. I called the Post Office and was told that I could meet them at the back door and actually pick my order up early before they opened...gotta love small towns!! :) Right away, I noticed 8 that were DOA. :( I called Meyer as soon as I got them home and informed them of the casualties and sadly,within a few hours there were more. The death toll was 11 out of 16 on the first day of arrival. They told me that they would replace the 11 but, that I had to order additional chicks to make an order of 15 because they no longer ship any less than that. I was fine with that but, they would not sell me the 4 chicks at the same price I had just bought just three days before in the same week.This is where I have a problem. Not only were my chicks dead and/or dying but, I had to order more and pay more! To me, this is bad business! My second gripe is that the shipping container was too large, not enough holes punched out, only one small heating pad that covered less than half of the box. The shipping costs are too high. I've since shopped around with other companies and their shipping is way less and most were on the other side of the US whereas, Meyer is just a few hours away. At this point, I'm not sure that I will be doing business with this company again. It'll depend on how fast the replacement chicks arrive and if they arrive alive this time and stay alive. I will keep everyone up to date as to what hapened after recieving them which should be within the next couple of days.
On February 13th, 2013, flamerider68 changed the rating from neutral to positive and added the following:

alright, I promised an update and here it is.lol My replacement chicks shipped out on the 11th(Monday) and I awoke to a phone call this morning from the Post Office informing me that my babies were there! They allowed me to pick them up early again! :) I arrived with chick saver(electrolites), water and some feed and a pair of sissors to open the box with. Based on last week's horrific sight, I really didn't expect to be greeted by healthy birds BUT, I was proven wrong!! I was greeted with 15(no extras) cute little faces!! There is one that may be a little iffy but, that's to be expected though.. However, I'm glad I brought the water and chick saver..they were thirsty!! Secondly, I want to update everyone about the company. Jess, a rep for Meyer Hatchery called me yesterday morning. She said that she had reviewed my case and found they had over charged me for the 4 additional chicks needed to meet the 15 min. She also credited me for the additional chicks that was lost in the first 48 hour period. So, currently I am a happy customer! I have changed my rating from a neutral to a postive based on these three things:
*excellent customer service
*faster shipping time
*Delivery of living Chicks
Neutral SamA2
Lowell, MA
(1 review)
February 1, 2013
Just a response to ambertx90:
You asked what makes shipping day-old chicks different from shipping newborn puppies or kittens, and here's the answer: As mammals, newborn puppies and kittens rely on their mother's milk from the time they're born, so shipping them before they're older and more independent would be a pretty bad idea. Chicks are different, though: for up to 72 hours after hatching, they are still ingesting their yolk sac, which means they really don't need food or water during that time. Those first couple days are actually the single BEST time you could ship a chick. They need to be sent in a group, though, so they can stay warm from each others' body heat.

And why day-old chicks instead of eggs? The embryo inside a fertilized egg is actually quite a bit more fragile than a day-old chick. When you ship fertile eggs, the success rate is 75-80%, and it's not unusual to lose more than half of them because of rough handling during shipping (you may not know it until later, when they don't hatch). Meanwhile, when you ship day old chicks, the standard rate of survival is about 99%. Which one of those sounds more humane?
Neutral ambertx90
CLINTON TOWNSHIP, MI
(1 review)
January 24, 2013
I'm surprised this is still legal. Honestly, the people who are paying to have these defenseless LIVE animals shipped within a day of birth in a cardboard box to be days without care are just as greedy as the people who run this company. This is a sickening practice and no one would think to do it to a newborn dog or cat, but somehow think it's ok to do to birds?! What makes it different? Just buy fertile eggs and an incubator, atleast there is not developed, feeling, breathing life that you're gambling with.
Positive GardenRiot
Ashville, OH
(4 reviews)
January 14, 2013
We order many chicks every year, and have ordered from several different hatcheries, among them Murray McMurray, Mt. Healthy, and Meyer.

I've had no problems with any hatchery, and different varieties from different hatcheries perform differently. For instance, my MMM Easter Eggers outperform Meyer Easter Eggers in terms of laying ability, by I prefer Meyer's red sex links to MMM's.

Although I have received chicks through the mail from Meyer, we have started driving to pick them up to save shipping costs when we buy started pullets. Meyer has such a great price on started pullets--we can't start them ourselves for that price, so buying the started pullets saves us money and effort. I was concerned that pullets started at the hatchery would be afraid of people, but the red sex link pullets we get from them are the friendliest chickens I have, and were from the start. I don't know how they keep them so friendly, since clearly they aren't getting individual attention and there are many birds in one pen, but even when we picked them up the hatchery worker just walked into the pen (they're floor raised) and picked the hens up for us--the hens didn't run away. They also lay extremely well. We are in our third year with some of our Meyer RSL hens, and they are still laying 5-7 off-the-charts super jumbo eggs a week. No health problems, no behavior problems, just great hens.

I do wish they had an option to not have the beaks clipped on their started pullets. We don't need it done, and it looks gross. I will say that they free range just as well as the rest of the flock even with the clipped beak, which was something I worried about.

My experiences with Meyer have all been positive. The customer service has been pleasant and has resolved any small problems I've had quickly and nicely. I'm an experienced chicken raiser and have ordered several hundred chicks through the mail and Meyer is as consistent as any other hatchery, with good prices.
Positive thepondlady
Lexington, KY
(1 review)
September 13, 2012
WHAT A GREAT COMPANY~! We have a small farm and were looking to add ducks. This company had a very nice selection of ducklings, so my children put together our FIRST online poultry order ever. A little scared to buy living things to be mailed, we decided to add to the order with a couple more items. No problem with Meyer. Then added some health items the day before hatch date, again Meyer said no problem. I even called on the hatch date , asking how my babies were? Meyer said great, they were going out later that day. recieved an email saying they were coming, and sure enough (after letting my post office know) got the call that I had a chirping box. My son drove into to town with me, and to our DELIGHT, the box was smartly constructed for our live animals, and all were happily chirping. We have BEAUTIFUL HEALTHY ALERT fabulous ducklings. I would reccomend this company as a truely good source for poultry. Customer Sevice A+. Would buy again. And as my ducklings grow up, I will be thankful that the mother stock at Meyer was obviously good stock.
Negative tamra1223
Carnesville, GA
(1 review)
August 27, 2012
My first experience with my was with my first order I ordered 39 chicks and only got 37 not only did I receive 37 chicks I also received someone else's box of 50 now my chicks were supposed to have been vaccinated against Marek's but I am for sure that the 50 were not I called Meyer and they sent me the chick that we could not identify as our own not only that we sent them pictures of all the chicks, now you would think that someone that is in the business of hatching chicks could identify them...guess again...the next box I received 3 dead sultans and 3 dead lakenvelders now Meyer has closed my account...which is probably a good thing...Back to the 50 misc. box it had what looked to be like 6 Welsummers in it 3m and 3f now here it is 2 mos. later and I have a female Welsummer acting like it has Marek's I have segregated her from the rest of my flock but Doc says its to late they have already been exposed, that means all my chicks I have hatched or bought from a private dealer have been exposed too....WILL NEVER RECOMMEND BUYING FROM MEYER...WONDER IF THEY WILL PAY TO REPLACE MY FLOCK IF THEY ALL DIE...NOT
Positive ChickSter99
Chester, GA
(2 reviews)
June 21, 2012
I ordered my chicks from a different hatchery but bought supplies from Meyer because they were priced more reasonably. My supplies were delivered in a very timely manner. I was very pleased with the packaging of the supplies-nothing was broken, smashed, or missing. There was also good communication via email from customer service about products that I had questions about.
Positive petset77
Fort Garland, CO (Zone 4b)
(1 review)
June 6, 2012
We placed a small order of six chicks, based on their detailed website listing availability and hatch dates. We got two each of Rhode Island Red, White Leghorn, and Columbian Wyandotte. Hatch date was June 3, and ship date June 4. They arrived at the post office June 6, all healthy and active. The phone personnel were helpful and knowledgeable. The website has photos and info on many breeds, along with availability of each for months upcoming, making the choice of one's purchase simple. I originally went to the site to buy a breed that would not be hatching for a month, so I chose the ones I did based on availability. I will be doing business with them again.
Positive mustlovespam
Gardiner, ME
(1 review)
May 5, 2012
Posted on May 3, 2012, updated May 5, 2012
Posted on May 3, 2012, updated May 3, 2012
Where, oh where, shall I begin? You know the saying, “Don’t count your chicks until they hatch”, well “I put all my eggs in one basket” and now I’m sitting here with an empty brooder. To say I’m disappointed would be a mild understatement.
I started my search for hatcheries this winter when I came across the “All Pullet Rainbow Pack” at Meyer Hatchery that boasted “We will make every effort to include as many different breeds as possible, but guarantee a minimum of 5.” Perfect!! That’s what I want! So I read some reviews, some positive, some negative, but decided that I’d give them the benefit of the doubt anyhow. This was in February.

Strike 1: (should have listened to the warning bells going off in my head)
March 21st, I called to place my order. When it was completed, she said “You should receive those between the 4th and 6th of May” “May?” I asked, “According to the website, they’re available is the first weeks in April?” To which I was told, “the website is a little misleading!” Really? You think? If you’re going to have a very clear and concise weekly calendar with availability dates listed on it, it should be accurate!!!

Strike 2: (I don’t have a good feeling about this)
May 3rd, a month and a half later, having yet to see an update on my order status, I call Meyer and get a very pleasant lady looks my order up and says ”Hmmm…I’ve never seen this before, there are no line items on your order. I see that you placed an order on March 21st, that you were charged $71 on April 19th, but nothing was shipped out. I’ll have to check into this, and I’ll call you back”

Strike 3: (Really? You call that customer service?)
I receive a call back from Meyer within 15 minutes explaining that there was a “glitch” in the computer and that they were sorry, but my order was not shipped out because there was no order to ship. And that all they could do was to place another order and that I would receive it at the end of May? Another month?? Unacceptable!!! No offer to discount my order. No “we’ll add some chickens to your order for your trouble”. Not even a mention to deduct the shipping charge. Just a sorry, better luck next time.

I live in Maine; production tips off in October as it is. They wouldn’t lay until the end of November at that rate, if at all, until the following spring. I can’t even begin to tell you how dissatisfied and disappointed I am!

So now I’m left scrambling to find a hatchery or a person or a neighbor that might possibly have some chicks that I can purchase as I’ve already missed out on the orders from the local feed stores because I put my faith in Meyer! I’m not the type that makes mistakes twice, so I will NOT be doing business with them again, and being human, the story of my dissatisfaction will be told again and again and again…

On May 3rd, 2012, mustlovespam changed the rating from negative to positive and added the following:

UPDATE: Posted the review you see above on Meyer's website and received a call from them less than an hour after hitting send. The woman was friendly and apologetic that my order was handled. We worked out an alternate shipping date, and she added a vit-a-pack (vitamin supplement to put in their water once a week) to my order. She apologized again and told me she'd keep in touch until my order shipped.

Then after she got off the phone, she noticed that I was also charged the wrong amount and called me right back to let me know that she'd be crediting my account the difference.



My confidence has been renewed in human kind. Let's hope all goes well :)
On May 5th, 2012, mustlovespam added the following:

I guess there's something to be said about not sending an email when you're upset. It's one thing to write it, but completely another to send it.
I've had such a fast and positive response from Meyer, that I am now feeling guilty about posting something so negative. I'm now singing their praises. I got a personally written card from Jess @ Meyer apologizing once again and wishing me all the best once my chicks arrive this coming week.

{does anyone know how to delete a post?}
Negative LaysEggs
Blue Ridge, VA
(1 review)
April 12, 2012
My original order was for 27 chicks including their "meal maker" offer. The first chick death was likely caused by poor handling by the USPS, arriving to me dead in the Meyer container. Their customer service was good even offering to let me wait the full 48 hours of their guarantee period to report any other deaths/problems. By the end of that period I had lost another and a credit was added to my account.

Since then (the chicks are 10 days old today) I have lost six chicks total, despite the new brooder, new coop, no other chickens on the property to pass disease and constant monitoring of food, water and temperature status. I require my children to wash their hands before and after handling food and water containers AND the brooder has been placed inside our house for constant monitoring.

For clarification, this is not my first time with chicks. I have started and grown six flocks of chickens of various breeds over the last twelve years. This has never happened to me before, not even the first time when I was 'green' and probably just got lucky, raising 24 of 24 hatched out and given to me by my neighbor.

This time I have had to watch my eleven year old daughter run away from the brooder crying after finding one of her "babies" lying dead. Not only that but just yesterday I learned a local farm supply store ordered 1500 chicks from Mt. Healthy hatchery and only lost three (3!).

Meyer tells me I have a credit on my account. I will never use it. I would strongly recommend anyone not yet supplied with chicks avoid Meyer hatchery; any savings on their "cheap chicks" is lost to chick demise. These birds are not healthy.
Positive ottobb
Rapid City, MI
(3 reviews)
February 12, 2012
We ordered a batch of 32 chicks. They all arrived alive, and after 2 days we had 29 left (out of an original count of 34, 32 plus 2 "free"). I called the company and they issued credit very willingly. The mortality rate was a little higher than we have experienced with McMurray or Cackle, but overall not bad. We ordered these May of 2011, and they have developed into a nice flock. My one issue would be that we ordered 4 white Cochins, and I'm pretty sure that we didn't receive 4 Cochins. Pretty decent place. We placed another order for April, so I'll update then.
Positive buck108
Ocean City, PA
(2 reviews)
January 30, 2012
This is a good company to order from! Wonderful birds! The kids did great at 4 H last year. I will definetly order from you guys again. Our welsummer hens lay the most beutiful eggs I've ever seen.
Positive ChickenRick
Athens, AL
(1 review)
January 5, 2012
I ordered from Meyer based on chick availability, I wanted them in early Jan 2012. I received a shipping notification on email, and my chicks arrived just over 24 hours after the email. I have ordered from several different hatcheries and must say Meyer is only the 2nd hatchery that ALL of my chicks arrived live and well. They are vibrant, and just waiting to see how they grow. Other hatcheries (which I won't name) I've ordered from and the last 2 years and a late February delivery produced bad luck. Each time when the box was opened it looked like a mass grave. Not with Meyer, and so far I'm 100% satisfied. Thank you Meyer and I will look forward to my next order real soon.
Positive cujo1101
Hollis, OK
(1 review)
November 22, 2011
almost 2 years ago i ordered 25 chicks, 13 buff orpingtons (1 rooster and 11pullets) and 12 dominique (1 rooster and 10 pullets) ana received 1 extra. lost only 2 within 2 weeks the rest survived now i only have 7 buff orpington hens,1 buff orpington rooster and 3 dominique hens, the others have been killed by my son's dog. i am getting anywhere from 8 to 10 eggs a day from my hens in october one hen set on 6 eggs and 5 hatched they are about six weeks old. ihave planned to order more from meyer hatchery this coming year probably another 25 or so from them again.
Negative fabric
Jonesboro, AR
(1 review)
November 19, 2011
Posted on November 13, 2011, updated November 19, 2011
we ordered from Meyer Hatchery,,25 pullets & 2 male orpingtons, recieved them just fine, when we got them home we realized one was going to die, in 48 hours we lost 4 or 5, & we have continued to loose chicks up to now.
we have raised chickens for 10 years, & also hatched our own chicks from the flock we had.
we wanted to introduce new blood line, but not sure that will happen, we have 6 chicks left.
not sure at this time if any will survive. we have 3 or 4 that can stand up & walk.
we will not buy from the meyer hatchery again.

On November 19th, 2011, fabric added the following:

out of the six chicks we had left, only one has survived.
we had to put a stuffed animal & a mirror in with the chick so it would not be lonely. we wait to see if this one will live.
we have never had such horrible experience with a hatchery chicks before. again they will never get our business again.
Neutral Holyhatty
North Branford, CT
(2 reviews)
October 22, 2011
Got my 28 chicks alittle over a week ago and I have mix feelings about Meyer's, (first time ordering from them). I love the fact that you can have small orders, not that I care cause I usally buy 20+ chicks per order, but it's nice if you want a random breed that your not sure about and try it out. Anyways, my 28 chicks arrived pretty healthy when I opened the box. After around 2 days old many had pasty butt, I used high protein chick stater for them, the pasty butt wasnt really an issue. After day 3, I see one of my chicks was smaller then others and was weak, 2 days later she dies. Then a day later I see another chick weak/sick then she dies 2 days later. So far the rest look strong and healthy and hoping no more will die... I expected Meyer's to be the best hatchery but I'm 2nd guessing that.. Not saying there bad, but it just seems after the 48 hour guarantee from Meyers, that's when the chicks start to die and you can't do anything about it....
Negative Ladypilot48
Champion, MI
(1 review)
May 27, 2011
Posted on May 26, 2011, updated May 27, 2011
Hi everyone!

This is my 1st post so I'm not sure if I'm doing this right, but I want to give it a try !

I'm also new to the World of Chickendom , but I think I'm doing great as far as taking care of my Babies.

Here's the deal.

I orderderd from other hatcheries and haven't had Any fatalities , however , about 1 month ago, I ordered 1 Salmon Favorelle Rooster and 1 SF hen along with 2 Partridge Cochin hens from Meyer Hatchery.

2 weeks ago, they sent me my Tracking number.

I live in Upper Michigan and they were coming from Ohio
I tracked the shipment and on the 1st day, I saw that my babies travelled from their hatchery , to Detroit ( which was perfect because the next stop would be home at my post office ) , BUT then BACK to their hatchery!!

The hatchery said " we dont know Why that happened , but maybe you'll get them in a day or 2 more "!!!

1 1/2 days later at the post office, I opened the box and the first thing I was greeted with was a SF with SPRADDLE LEGS who never opened his/ her eyes !

ALL of the babies had Pasty Butt , however I caught that in time , cured the remaining Cochin , but I Battled it for Several days with my SF until I learned that maybe lowering the brooder heat and offering Plain Greek Yogurt, might help.

Greek because of the higher protein in it.

Got them home and IMMEDIATELY called them to report it .

I put a Bandaid around the baby's legs , but the poor thing was NEVER able to stand and open eyes and he/she didn't make it thru the night ALONG with a SUDDEN loss of a Cochin !

They did honor their 48 hr guarantee for in store credit or money back on my card but since I will NEVER order from them again, why order more babies just to have them sent Again in Horribly poor packaging ( too much room in box and just 1 hole for breathing )!

Being new to the World of Chickens, I have further discovered, that my surviving " Cochin" is actually a Partridge Rock, and a Roo at that ..

I have lost a total of 2 Hens of the 4.

Also, you will read on their website, that they send " 20 percent more chicks with order in case of fatalities "..

I did NOT receive my 20 per cent , and when I mentioned that to them, they THEN, informed me that " they only do that IF they have extras"..

Now, I totally understand that, however, maybe they should ADD that statement right after the original ..I dont know, maybe its me, but that makes sense.

So, needless to say, I WILL NOT use Meyer Hatchery again.


On May 27th, 2011, Ladypilot48 added the following:

Hello again everyone.

I wanted to give you all an update since yesterday's post.

After sending Meyer Hatchery an email regarding my 4 baby chicks I ordered..( my fatalities , lack of " extra chicks " I was supposed to get, and NOW, them sending me the WRONG species regarding the COCHIN, and the sex of my last SALMON FAVORELLE ), below is the " conversation " I had with their " customer service"..

*************************************************

On Thu, 26 May 2011 05:18:50 -0400, Dd Claud wrote:
> AS you have noted, I Did lose a Favorelle and 1 of 2 what were
> supposed to be female PARTRIDGE COCHINS
>
> Being new to chickening, I've been waiting , Since my order received
> , for my last " FEMALE PARTRIDGE COCHIN" to Sprout leg feathers!
>
> Well , here we are , 3 weeks later, and NO leg feathers!
> Besides that , I believe it is a ROOSTER!
>
> I've Had several professional breeders look at her/him , and it's
> believed I might have a Partridge Rock instead !
>
> He/she is an Extremely sweet chicken( they are pets ), however , but
> now I have 2 roosters now.
>
> I would appreciate ANOTHER refund for the Wrong species AND sex.
>
> I Will be calling too, to make sure this is done
>
> Thanks
> Deirdre Claud

**************************************************
Dear Deirdre,

Our policy on roosters is: you can report those at 10-18 weeks of age. That is when you would know for sure if you got a rooster. So please let us know.

As far as the cochin, I am not sure when they develop their leg feathers. Would it be possible to send us a picture? Cochins are rather large birds, so it may take them longer.

I cannot issue a credit "for the wrong species" until we see a picture. And again, as far as the sex, we do have to wait til 10-18 weeks.

Thank you for choosing Meyer Hatchery.

Laura

**************************************************

Wait a moment...

Now, we have to " wait 10-18 weeks " to see if THEY sent me the sex I ordered ??

Where is THAT statement in their brochure?

And if that is the case,

WHY would they have OPTIONS to order MALE, FEMALE or STRAIGHT RUN , instead of offering ONLY STRAIGHT RUN ONLY for the species I wanted??

As far as their customer service person unsure " when COCHINS " start to get their " leg feathers ", WHY doesnt she know, is she Not a representative of their company?

Ive sent pics of my " COCHIN" to 5 breeders who ALL say that Cochins have leg feathering " at hatch".

1 MAIN thing I did learn about ordering from hatcheries, that Veteran buyers have mentioned several times, is DO YOUR RESEARCH..( which i did ), also, be somewhat leary of hatcheries that DO NOT show actual pictures of their chickens, but only Drawings.

I have done extensive research on chickensforbackyards.com, and have an order being sent out June 6.

I chose them because they not only take small orders, BUT, they offer videos of their chicks, AND actual owners of the chicks bought from them.

Well,
just wanted to be fair and post Their response for Potential buyers at Meyer Hatchery, so they can make a somewhat, educated decision.

My final statistics:

out of 4 babies ordered...

1 Salmon Favorelle Rooster
1 SF hen
2 Partridge Cochin Hens

All 4 had Pasty Butt noticed at the Post Office where I opened the box, BUT was immediately dealt with every few hours once I got them home,

1 had Spraddle Leg and Never Opened his/her eyes and despite placing Hobbles on the legs, and Trying to get the baby to eat,
she/he passed away the next day,

The next day ALSO had a Sudden death of a Cochin hen, despite dealing with her Pasty Butt,

Now, I learn that not only is the hatchery unsure if they sent me a rooster and hen, SF,
but my 2 " Cochins ", ARE NOT Cochins afterall...

Im not sure what my remaining one is, however, she is super sweet and a "lap chicken" tho..

Take care all..
Positive equineplanner
La Grange, KY
(2 reviews)
May 13, 2011
Great experience! Ordered email special which shipped within hours of placing the order online. Ordered 100 and received 104 healthy and vibrant chicks.
Positive lou63
Bridgeton, NJ
(1 review)
April 13, 2011
we had ordered a varity of chickens, they shipped them out monday they ened up an hour away but the post office was nice to call so we got them a day earliar rather then us waiting for them to come to the postal service near me. they shipped us 4 extra and one mystery bird. out of 105 chicks only one was dead. they all seem healthy and a couple of chicks have cones on their head which are very cute. i would order from them again i was very pleased with what i got. thank you
Positive artathart
Hagerstown, MD
(2 reviews)
March 24, 2011
So far, So good. I had a horrible expierence with MurrayMcMurray Hatchery so I placed a order with Meyer. ordered 17 chicks. All my chicks arrived safe and sound. Not one loss. 3 days later, no losses. They all seem healthy and happy. Every order from the other hatchery I lost at least HALF of my baby chicks. I will make any edits to this over the next few weeks if I lose any more but as of right now, I am very satisfied. They were very nice and helpful over the phone as well. Another great thing? You dont have to order 25 chicks and they place a heating pad in the shipping box which I think made a world of differene. They have no pasty bottoms either, Other hatchery....All had pasty bottoms. They were very reasonably priced and I received a lot of help and guidence over the phone when placing my order. This will be my go to online hatchery from now on.
Positive tedgrowsit
Reading, PA
(1 review)
March 8, 2011
I have ordered from this hatchery for several years now. I have always been very satisfied with their service and quality. My latest order included 25+1 of their best brown egg layers, all pullets. They arrived a day earlier than I expected, all lively, all healthy. I appreciate affordable poultry, which they definitely provide. I certainly would not hesitate to order from this company, and would recommend them to others.
Positive Cuckoo2
Highland, IN
(1 review)
December 4, 2010
The phone staff was extremely friendly when I placed my order. My 9 chicks were born November 8 (and 9) 2010. When they did not arrive at the post office on the 9th I called. They said that there were a few late bloomers, and now they were ready to go. At the post office on the 10th there were 3 people in front of me in line. They were all looking around for the source on that peeping noise. The Araucana peeped non-stop until I got the box home. Four weeks later all the chicks are happy and healthy. I highly recommend Meyer Hatchery. They have a great selection and you can order as few as 3 chicks.
Positive berniedoran
Centerburg, OH
(1 review)
November 22, 2010
Posted on October 28, 2010, updated November 22, 2010
ordered 12 black jersey giants, hatched 3AM Oct. 25. had them vac. and picked them up at 3 PM Oct. 25. home at 4 PM, 110 mi round trip. several started eating immediately. by AM Oct 26. all eating and drinking. All going strong today, Oct 28, doubled in size. They will chase a string like a cat!!! very active, unless asleep, even try to catch flies. I can not imagine what else Meyer could do, staff was friendly, etc. I wonder if the people reporting problems received them in the mail. believe me, I am one of the first to bitch if there is a problem, sure do not see one here. Centerburg, Ohio
On November 22nd, 2010, berniedoran added the following:

today, Nov 22, the chicks are four weeks old. still all twelve growing like, well chicks, they look big already, legs are huge, very active. what more to say? Bernie

Read the rest of the comments


Add your own comment and rating to this company

Return to the Garden Watchdog homepage

Learn how to link to this page


We recommend Firefox
Overwhelmed? There's a lot to see here. Try starting at our homepage.

[ Home | About | Advertise | Media Kit | Mission | Featured Companies | Submit an Article | Terms of Use | Tour | Rules | Privacy Policy | Contact Us ]

Back to the top

Copyright © 2000-2014 Dave's Garden, an Internet Brands company. All Rights Reserved.
 

Hope for America