Photo by Melody

Comments regarding Cottage Farms

Click here to return to Cottage Farms's listing.

  Feedback History and Summary  
65 positives
13 neutrals
51 negatives

Comments:

« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 Next »

RatingAuthorContent
Neutral 17decker
(5 reviews)
On Mar 4, 2009, 17decker Grand Junction, CO wrote:

Spring of 2008 I order three tree roses, three Rose of Sharon, 6 Hydrangeas and the only ones that seem to still be alive are the Rose of Sharons.
I have emailed Cottage Farms and replacements for the tree roses and Hydrangeas are on their way. Honestly I found that ordering through QVC they leed you to beleive the plant will grow in almost any light etc. When in fact the Hydrangeas are very picky. Please take caution when ordering through them to do your home work and know what requirements the plant needs, because I was miss lead.


On April 14th, 2009, 17decker added the following:

Well, the replacement order arrived and the rose trees look to be in good condition, although they are not they same as what I had order originally. The Hydrangeas also not what my original order was, three seem to also be in good condition but the other three might not make it.
This is why my rating remains Neutral
On April 14th, 2009, 17decker added the following:

Well, the replacement order arrived and the rose trees look to be in good condition, although they are not they same as what I had order originally. The Hydrangeas also not what my original order was, three seem to also be in good condition but the other three might not make it.
This is why my rating remains Neutral
Negative Chezca
(4 reviews)
On Sep 10, 2008, Chezca Hayward (Z8b-9a), CA (Zone 8b) wrote:

So far, I'm happy with Cottage Farms... Eventhough ALL of the 50-piece strawberries died (oh I got ONE strawberry fruit at least!). They did, however refunded my money back which was cool. And the heirloom tomatoes- some lived but the tomatoes were the size of big GRAPES so I was very disappointed and I told them. Again, they promise to replace them next season which is awesome. Now on to the asiatic lilies, one word: A-FREAKIN-MAZING! :) I've NEVER gardened before, ever! When I got the lilies in April08, I had to put them in those blue plastic party cups just because I had nowhere to plant them and plus we were moving in a couple of months. They started sprouting in a week and by the time we're moved in, I transplanted them in our new backyard and voila! They shot up to almost 30" and started flowering in mid-June and every morning was a surprise! Especially when the huge white lilies started unfolding! We took pictures of our "babies" just to show off :) (even my husband got into gardening because of these wonderful plants). But alas, they have started to yellow from the bottom leaves up. I guess they're getting ready for dormancy? I also got the sub-zero roses and those have bloomed and re-bloomed like crazy. My hubby thought I was crazy buying these "sticks" until they started to leaf and bloom :). One plant I'm very wary of are their hydrangeas- they're VERY weak and annoying to grow (brittling leaves and almost no growth). I just ordered their black, yellow, pink, and white tulips for this fall planting season and I can't wait to work on those. Also ordered lily-of-the-valley and that one's a scratcher because we just got a puppy and it's supposed to be poisonous (the lily not the puppy:))? Anyway, just thought I'd put my 2 cents in. Not every plant is going to perform the way they show them on tv, as long as they make good on their refund/replacement and have wonderful customer service- there's nothing that can't be fixed, right? Compromise people and happy gardening! :)


On July 8th, 2009, Chezca changed the rating from positive to negative and added the following:

I am now changing it to negative. Mainly because QUITE A NUMBER of the plants I ordered did not grow true to form. My oranges and lemons grew to be just a plain yellow daisy. The shasta daisies are riddled with "fascination", the calla lilies aren't blooming AT ALL this year (very stunted growth), and the only thing doing ok are my asiatic/oriental lilies. VERY DISAPPOINTED WITH COTTAGE FARMS.

As for the replacements, they were the wrong plants on two instances.
On July 8th, 2009, Chezca added the following:

I have now switched to Bluestone Perennials, High Country Gardens, and Annie's. So far so good but have not ordered anything from Annie's because I'm planning on going to their nursery myself.
Neutral HostaLily
(5 reviews)
On Jul 13, 2008, HostaLily Florence, SC (Zone 8a) wrote:

I have ordered from Cottage Farms and have had neutral success.

I have ordered the iris plants, I had some flowers, not many. And yes, they are planted correctly, along with other iris that I have purchased and traded with neighbors.

QVC had a sampler this past spring that I ordered. The mini roses never grew, the gladiolas are ok but not great, the daylilies are very small.....actually I did not think they would grow at all...the roots were very dry.

I did order one of the rose trees as well. This actually has grown for me and flowered, but I expected more.

Positive selmasoo
(3 reviews)
On Jun 26, 2008, selmasoo Ravenswood, WV (Zone 6a) wrote:

We had purchased a TREE ROSE 36" NOVELTY BI-COLORED from Cottage Farms several weeks before Mother's Day, which was a gift to me from my husband and daughter. When it arrived, though a *little* later than expected, it looked quite healthy. It has now been a little over two months since we planted it and it is full of buds and some beautiful bright pink and white swirled blooms! Great price we paid also ~ just $17.99,(on sale). Couldn't be happier! =)

Positive Etelka
(1 review)
On Jun 17, 2008, Etelka Youngstown, OH wrote:

Cottage Farms has replaced a rose tree within a timely manner and has reponded immediately to a DOA plant order. One was ordered through QVC and the other direct. I will continue purchasing from them.

Negative paulnelissa
(2 reviews)
On Jun 14, 2008, paulnelissa Cincinnati, OH wrote:

My husband and I wanted a weeping pussy willow tree for our yard. We found that both Spring Hill Nursery and Cottage Farm Direct (not through QVC). The tree was half the price at Cottage Farm, so we ordered it. My credit card is charged immediately. The website stated that they needed 14 days to process the order.
I waited and waited and waited. Finally, when the 14 days has passed, I email the customer service department. Two days later, I get an email saying that my order is currently being packed and will ship in 2 days.
Two days later, I get another email saying that the items I ordered are no longer in stock. I call the customer service department.
I tell the woman what happened. She expresses disbelief and places me on hold. Then, she comes back on the line and says that this really happened. They'll refund my credit card. I ask her if I can file a complaint. She says she doesn't think so. I hang up.
I decide I need to speak with a supervisor. I call back and am placed on hold for 20 minutes. While I am on hold, the supervisor calls me. I explain again what happened. He pulls up my account and says, "Yep. We oversold the product. We waited too long to fill your order and then ran out. This happens all the time. Sorry."
I tell him that this is really unacceptable. He says, "Well, we'll refund your credit card. So, do you need anything else?"
I tell him I will never order from them again.

I wouldn't be so mad if I could order this plant elsewhere. But, everywhere else is out of stock. I know this because all of their websites say this. They don't let you order something that can't send you.

Negative skippy2000
(1 review)
On Jun 9, 2008, skippy2000 Valentine, NE wrote:

I preodered two rose of sharon trees from cottage farms on QVC. The plants did fine last year. This spring they have not done anything so I assume they have died. I gave them alot of time since in Nebraska hibiscus are slow to come up. Usually not until June. My other hibiscus are just now starting to come up. I let them know that the plants did not come up. And they informed me that since I recieved them the first of May last year and did contact them unil June they would not replace 70.00 worth of plants. Now it has been cool here this spring and nothing came up as early as usual. And there is no way these plants would have been up the first of May even in a normal year. I will not buy from them again.

Negative ks8angel
(1 review)
On Jun 8, 2008, ks8angel Buffalo, NY wrote:

I ordered a number of plants from Cottage Farms through QVC. The amazing thing is that I had bad luck with most of the plants ordered. I ordered the 30-pc assorted strawberries with 5-tier planter; Ornamental Fringe Tree; 3 Piece Pastel sub-zero rose collection; Emeral Rose Set; 2 Piece Primrose & Sensation Lilacs; and 8 Piece Chef's Choice Heirloom Tomatoes. I also orders some of their fertilizer paks. I followed all their planting directions to the tee. The tree I planted outside and mulched really good since we were still getting some frost. However, the tree is showing no signs of active growth at all, it looks like a stick was just stuck in the ground. The strawberries I planted in the tier pots and place in a window that gets sun all day and kept them watered and fed and kept turning them pots as directed. Once I thought it was safe I placed them on my patio and if there was a threat of frost, covered them with heavy clear plastice to protect them. However, out of all the strawberry plants received in the shipment, only one is even showing any type of growth and that only as 3 leaves on it currently so I don't think that will even produce. The tomatoes I planted in pots and placed in the same sunny window and kept them watered and fed until the ground was warm enough to plant them. However, out of 8 plants received only 6 are still alive, but are not really growing at all. I have plants that I started from seed that are doing better than these plants and that are already stating to flower and produce. The roses and lilacs I also planted in large pots and kept in a sunny warm place, watered and fed until it was safe to plant in the ground. The Pastel Sub-Zero Rose collection has a few new shoots on it but not really actively growing, so I still have hope for them. The Emerald Rose set, has no active growth at all. The lilacs are still alive, but not really showing any new growth, but again I still have hope for them. I've purchased other on-line plants and never had any problems, so I thought I was safe with Cottage Farms. I have a very green thumb and my neighbors love my yard. I had pulled out a number of bushes that were distroyed by a winter storm we got and I was going to replace them with these plants. I have complained to QVC and haven't yet gotten any response, but I'm hoping they will replace the plants. At this moment in time though, I wouldn't puchase any more plants from Cottage Farms.

Neutral santeelady
(5 reviews)
On May 31, 2008, santeelady Santee, CA (Zone 9a) wrote:

I have placed 3 seperate orders with Cottage Farms Direct. I was introduced to this company while watching QVC, but I did not order from them, I order from Cottage Farms own website.

I have ordered 4 Tree Roses, 13 mini roses, 4 dwarf grafted trees, various bulbs, kiwi vines, tomato plants and strawberries.

The reason I give this company a neutral is because all of the strawberry plants have died, including the replacements. Also the first order of 7 mini roses was packed so poorly they all were dead on arrival. I have received replacements for those as well, but they still look horrible.

My first order came rather quickly. As for the othe orders, the shipping was beyond slow. Those orders took approx. 1 month to get to me. Replacement orders take about 6-7 weeks to arrive.

I may or may not order from this company again. I will only purchase items on clearance as well, so I don't feel so cheated by he extremely slow delivery times.

Positive agastachegrl
(5 reviews)
On May 30, 2008, agastachegrl Eden Prairie, MN wrote:

Cottage Farms is a classy, customer oriented company as far as my own experiences. Some things come bare root and with time, patience and a little love, most turn out to be beautiful. I've gardened for years and have always been happy with theirs and Roberta's products, via QVC. Both companies are good about replacements and seem happy to help when contacted. I've ordered many, many plants... Sumatra lilies, Honeysuckles, Trumpet vines, Lionotis, Delphiniums, Foxgloves and more. 99% of the time both companies send healthy plants and if not, they're replaced. Keep up the good work Cottage Farms and Roberta's!!

Positive tempoper59
(4 reviews)
On May 15, 2008, tempoper59 Farmdale, OH wrote:

I purchased hundreds of orders with Cottage Farms via QVC. Because I requested many replacement orders with them, QVC will NOT let me order anything else through Cottage Farms. I thought I knew QVC, but they do not put the customer first. I love Cottage Farms, and have landscaped my yard for the last three years with their products. I would recommend them very highly, as they have plants that my local nursery does not have. I now will only shop with Cottage Farms Direct, as I have never had any problems with them directly. QVC lost a very good customer, and will lose more if they continue these ridiculous policies. QVC does not put the customer first, it is the bottom line.


On June 4th, 2008, tempoper59 added the following:

I want to make a correction to my comment. QVC never told me why I am not allowed to order anything else via Cottage Farms, so I took it was due to replacements. I have learned that it is due to cancellations. These orderes were only cancelled due to some hard times I was going through.
On June 15th, 2008, tempoper59 changed the rating from neutral to negative and added the following:

I am changing my neutral to a negaive. This is not for Cottage Farms, but for QVC.
On June 17th, 2008, tempoper59 changed the rating from negative to positive and added the following:

I am making a correction about Cottage Farms. I do not want my feedback to affect the ratings of Cottage Farms. This is not about Cottage Farms, but QVC. I love Cottage Farms, so my feedback is definetely a Positive.
Positive PamWard
(3 reviews)
On May 13, 2008, PamWard Oxford, CT wrote:

I have purchase many items from Cottage Farms over the years, both from the company directly and from QVC and my experiences have been positive. I have had a few issues with the items, but they have always replaced them with no problems. When calling them, I have always been able to speak with someone and never have I gotten a busy phone.

When Cottage Farms tells you that an item will be marked or bagged with a tag, that is how it comes. Their packaging is great.

Positive IAmBlessed
(1 review)
On May 2, 2008, IAmBlessed Houston, TX wrote:

I was amazed over all the negative comments! I ordered several items from Cottage Farms via QVC: Calla LIly Collection w/fertilizer, 50pc Cream/Crop Strawberry Collectiion, 8 pc. Chef's Heiloom Tomato Garden, and a 36" Pink Fountaini Tree Rose. I also ordered 3 types of the Bud 'N Flower Bloom Fertilizers - Rose, Fruit and Vegetables, and Flower Booster. I did not know what to expect so I waited - my orders were received at appropriate times for my region. I was told that the tree rose will come bare-root (had no clue). I planted it in a container in my backyard, feed it the rose food and within a couple of weeks, I noticed greenery. Now, after 6 weeks, I have beautiful mini pink roses blooming and they smell good. I am a container gardner ... I planted a bunch of strawberries in a 15" planter --- beautiful plants are growing with lots of flowers and fruit. The tomatos are a different story. Some thrived after potting, some different however, they were quickly replaced when I called QVC. Matter of fact, the replacements were as dry as the initial order (I live in the Gulf Coast). I replaced the dead ones, fed them and currently, after 2 weeks, beautiful plants that are 5 times the size with flowers. I also wanted to test using the Calla Lilly collection --- I planted 3 bulbs in a 6' pot. The came with their own fertilizer and I initially used it but changed to the Cottage FArms Bud 'N Booster. I now have beautiful stalk and leaves growing!
To all the negative people ... I am sorry for your experiences however, I too spent a lot of money at QVC, some have been returned or replaced. I liked the quick service I received and I like Cottage Farms so much that I just placed an order directy from them today! QVC no longer has the fertilizer I like for my fruit/vegies so I am getting it directly from the source. So far, Cottage Farms, I like your products and your plants.

Positive gardening_diva
(2 reviews)
On Apr 28, 2008, gardening_diva Arkadelphia, AR wrote:

I ordered several products from cottage farms recently. The plants arrived in excellent condition. They were all labeled and packed neatly. I ordered cannas, mini roses, hibiscus, and oriental poppies. The plants seem to be doing well. I am not an expert gardener, but it appears that even I can't mess these up.

Positive memart
(1 review)
On Apr 27, 2008, memart Mountain Top, PA wrote:

My daughter bought me a tree hydrangea as a birthday gift in March. It was delivered on April 25, which was the perfect planting time for our area. It was in great condition and larger than I expected. The buds are swollen and ready to open. We planted it today, and my only complaint is that there were no planting instructions, but I have a friend with a "green thumb" who helped me. At the same time my daughter bought herself four bush hydrangeas and they are beautiful. Two even arrived with blooms almost ready to open. A few years ago she bought a cherry tree that looked almost like a dead stick when it arrived, but you should see it now! The only problem with it is the birds that eat the cherries before she gets them!

Neutral colliwobbles
(9 reviews)
On Apr 27, 2008, colliwobbles (Jana) Shoreline, WA (Zone 8a) wrote:

Last year I ordered 3 items from Cottage Farms through QVC. The first was clematis, and when it arrived, the pots were not secure in the box, and so the plants were all broken and mangled. I sent them back to QVC and received a refund.

The 2nd item was Chocolate Cosmos. The plants looked dead when they arrived, and when I contacted Cottage Farms, they told me that the plants were dormant and would come to life. Well, they never did, and I was promised a replacement order in 2008, because the Spring shipping season had ended. I had pretty much forgotten about the replacement order, until I received a shipping notification via e-mail a few weeks ago. The flowers arrived, and once again the pots weren't secure , but the plants seemed ok. I was immediately disappointed to not see Chocolate Cosmos. Their customer service did say that they would substitute if the same plant wasn't available. They didn't include any information on the replacement plants that were sent, but I've figured out that it's Pink Mist Scabiosa. I'm glad they kept their word and replaced my order, but I'm still disappointed that it's not what I ordered in the first place.

By the way, the 3rd item I ordered was a Crocosmia collection, and most of them turned out ok.

Positive scully931
(9 reviews)
On Apr 17, 2008, scully931 Pittsburgh, PA wrote:

I've been ordering from Cottage Farms for a few years now. I really like their company. I've lost a few plants along the way, but they are always quite friendly about sending replacements. My Harry Lauder's Walking Stick - not a cheap plant - didn't do much last year. (As in, no leaves at all until fall, well after I had already requested a new one.) No problem! They are sending me a new one this year. I just received my wisteria and bamboo today and both are much larger than I expected. Really, quite a nice company. I think they had some growing pains the first couple of years they were on QVC, but it all seems to be resolved and I would order from them again in a second. :-)

Positive lilliev
(1 review)
On Apr 13, 2008, lilliev Wilmer, AL wrote:

Last year I bought a "Blue" Rose of Sharron and a Japanese Red Maple tree from Cottage Farms and QVC. They are growing and blooming like they should be.

Positive ItsAMiracle
(1 review)
On Apr 11, 2008, ItsAMiracle Lynn Haven, FL wrote:

I always say, take time to...
play in the dirt.

(That way I am not too disappointed when the flowers don't grow.) LOLLLLL

No really, I love fiddling outside with flowers, love the sunshine but suffer with a severe gardening knowledge deficit. This means that it is truly miraculous when anything grows...and even more remarkable when it blooms and/or returns the next year!

Last year I placed an order for the first time with QVC for 3 Cottage Farms rose bushes, 3 hibiscus, 3 hydrangeas and tons of daylillies. (Must have been pretty hormonal that day.) My hope and ambition can only be attributed to the certainty of the CF rep and the QVC host, that the process was absolutely fool proof, completely guaranteed, and yes Virginia, even I could become a successful gardener.

Despite my usual failure rate, there were only a few plants that did not grow last year. QVC promptly refunded the cost of those plants. This year...I have growing plants! There are little green leaves on the hibiscus bushes. I have gorgeous blooming daylillies! (Who knew?) The rose bushes are absolutely covered with buds, and the quality of the rose bushes compared to the quality of the other bushes I have had that came from the local garden shop is phenomenal. Rich green leaves, thick long stems...(I wonder what would happen if I had remembered to fertilize?)

Will I order again from Cottage Farms? YOU BET! They even make ME look good!

That is right, I didn't mention the hydrangeas. They were tiny, and unfortunately their demise was at the hands of an absent minded hubby and his lawn mower. Apparently there are some gardening problems that even a superb company like Cottage Farms can't resolve.

Negative Gizinator
(1 review)
On Apr 8, 2008, Gizinator Albany, NY wrote:

I too have had a negative experience with Cottage Farms
and am glad to be given an opportunity to let people know
to be careful about them. I ordered 3 hydrangeas through
QVC. They arrived on time but they had been placed into
a large box with no bracing or protection at all. They were
badly beat up from having been thrown around the box
during shipping. Also, they were quite sickly and full of bugs.
I tried to nurse them along for a couple of weeks but it
was a lost cause. I won't buy anything else from them.

Negative shovelit
(2 reviews)
On Apr 7, 2008, shovelit Buford, GA wrote:

I recently ordered the Strawberry kit (5 level carousel) thru QVC and am totally satisfied. I've raised strawberries in pots for years and wanted to try some new stock. This was my first online live plant order ever (I'm fully retired now) and I was a bit nervous about plant quality. I carefully laid out the dormant plants and the count was exactly 30,which is two to each plant area on the carousel. While a couple were a bit small, they are all alive and thriving on my screened-in sun-porch. We have had some cooler weather but the growth rate seems to be unaffected. All plants have robust new leaves now (18 days after receipt). Will I reorder from this supplier???? Yes.


On May 11th, 2008, shovelit changed the rating from positive to negative and added the following:

Right after I wrote the original review, the plants started dying at the rate of two or three a day. I called Cottage Farms and they sent 16 more plants - 8 Ooh-la-la's and 8 Sweet desire. All but 3 of those were DOA. Then we contacted QVC who sent out an entire new kit. These 30 plants actually had some life-sign out of the package and once again have all come out of dormancy and are showing greenery. I gave the "potting" mix that came to a neighbor I don't like and put these plants in a different medium. It's called "Jungle Growth Professional Mix". It's made in Statham, Georgia and beats Miracle Grow. Cottage Farms is entirely too much hassle. I will not order again.
Positive lsu630
(1 review)
On Apr 7, 2008, lsu630 Slidell, LA wrote:

On Sunday, March 16th I ordered a butterfly magnolia and 6 hydrangeas. On Wednesday, March 19th they arrived. I was a bit concerned as I was going out of town Thursday and Friday. I took the hydrangeas out of the box and placed them outside under cover until I could get back and plant them. They were a nice size and healthy. On Easter Sunday (March 23rd) I unboxed the butterfly magnolia;It had several closed buds on it - healthy! Twelve days later (April 4th) it has already bloomed and is absolutely beautiful! The following Sunday, March 30th I planted the hydrangeas. So far, they are doing well. I look forward to purchasing again from Cottage Farms!

Positive Suncoast
(1 review)
On Apr 1, 2008, Suncoast Senoia, GA wrote:

I recently purchased the 8 piece Fireball hedge rose collection from Cottage Farms through QVC. After ordering, I discovered this website and was concerned about the negative comments. My order was shipped on a Friday and was delivered the following Tuesday. I got exactly what I ordered, it was packed well and each of the 8 plants were in excellent condition and no distress. I've since planted them and so far so good. They have all taken on new growth already and look healthy. Only time will tell. This was my first experience ordering plants through the mail, and I will definitely be ordering from Cottage Farms again.

Positive cjwarren001
(1 review)
On Mar 25, 2008, cjwarren001 Watertown, WI wrote:

03-24-2008
I am just voiceing my thoughts. I have numerous ordering pending on QVC for plants, bulbs and trees from CF. After reading many of the reviews, I was tempted to cancel my orders, but I did not.I am going to give CF a chance to provide me with healthy plants as promised.Being in Quality Control myself, I find that many people want something for nothing.I plan on my plants arriving healthy and ready for planting. I will provide them with the water,food and care they need to thrive.You cannot expect to have plants live without the proper care. I will write again when my orders arrive and will update as the growing season proceeds...stay tuned.

Positive flowergem
(1 review)
On Feb 16, 2008, flowergem Farmington, CT wrote:

I have ordered from them a few times. The plants have mostly grown very well. The main point for me is that, when I had any difficulty at all, their customer service has been helpful and generous. So, I am more than satisfied with this company

Neutral daphnana
(1 review)
On Dec 14, 2007, daphnana Livingston, NJ wrote:

Ordered BlueBird Tree Hibiscus in 2006 through QVC. It arrived on time and in good condition. The following season(2007) it grew hundreds of buds but only one bloomed. And it wasn't a Blue Bird - it was pink (but pretty.) I called CF and they have promised to send a BlueBird in the spring. They suggested I use a bloom fertilizer on the tree I have so that hopefully it will flower next season. Only time will tell! But they were very polite.

Negative allroses1
(1 review)
On Aug 21, 2007, allroses1 Chico, CA wrote:

I ordered from them and received two dead trees and six dead grasses on arrival, they replaced them twice with more dead trees and more dead grasses, never offered to replace with other items that wouldn't pass away during the shipment that takes 6 days. I would never buy from them again and warn all whom do order, unless you like sticks, twigs and dry dead weeds on arrival. very poor service.

Positive littlebit63
(2 reviews)
On Jun 14, 2007, littlebit63 Dyersburg, TN wrote:

I love Cottage Farms. I have never been one to trust mail order when it comes to live plants. So i surprised myself when I bought their 12 piece mini rose collection and the 4 hardy hibiscus last yr(2006) thru QVC.
Each and every plant that I bought arrived in great health. All the roses and two of the hibiscus bloomed.

This yr a friend and I went in together and placed a large order from QVC. Together we bought 3 Rose Trees, Chocolate Vine, Nelly Moser Clematis, and Ice Plants. This was in addition to the 10 piece mini rose collection and the Chicago Peace Rose Tree I had already ordered.
We did lose a few of the plants this yr, I lost 2 mini roses and my friend lost her clematis and rose tree. But I contacted Cottage Farms and I have already gotten the replacements for everything but the rose tree.

My rose trees are doing wonderful, I currently have blooms on all of them and all 22 of the mini roses are either blooming or budding.Including the two that just arrived.. My hibiscus from last yr are putting on lots of buds, so I expect lots of flowers on them. Even the pink ice is beginning to bloom. The Chocolate Vine is growing slowly but surely.

I will continue to do business with Cottage Farms.

Positive CLIF5441
(1 review)
On May 26, 2007, CLIF5441 Stockton, CA wrote:

I have been ordering from them for 6 years thru their website and QVC. This was the first year that I had a tree rose die and they replaced it immediately. I had bought it from QVC and they sent a new one. Last year they sent me a wrong color of the hibiscus tree I ordered and they sent me the right one this spring. The one that was sent as the wrong color I did not have to return and it growing beautifully. I have tried Roberta's and have not had any success, probably because I live in the dry hot summer of central Ca. I have ordered hibiscus,day lillies, roses,scabiosa,magnolia trees,lilacs,hydragena tree,hibiscus trees,etc. and I have had wonderful experience with them. I think we have to order plants that are suitable for our zone to be successful.

Negative Dscalf
(1 review)
On May 24, 2007, Dscalf Port Neches, TX wrote:

I ordered Hot Chocolate Dahlias and Friquolet dahlias from Cottage farms this year. Only one out of six of the Hot Chocolates sprouted -- but it was another dahlia variety. I emailed my complaint and replacements are on the way. However, all six of the Friquolet sprouted, but now that they are blooming, they are not the blooms pictured on their site. I called customer service and offered to send photos of the flowers so they could see that they were not what I ordered, but the service rep said you can't rely on the site photos. I asked her how you were supposed to order specific color and style flowers if you couldn't trust the website. She grudgingly offered to send replacements, but I haven't heard any thing from them yet. I wasn't trying to get "free" plants, I just wanted what I originally ordered for my garden.


On June 4th, 2007, Dscalf added the following:

I received replacements for the some of the above order. However they were out of the Hot Chocolate dahlias and offered no replacement for those. The replacement bag contained some extremely dried out tubers with no visible eyes and a tag that indicated they were the Friquolet dahlias. I have planted these but am not optimistic about results. I received a dahlia order from another dahlia farm on the same day and the difference in quality was huge. I won't be ordering dahlias from Cottage farms again.
Positive kriswalker
(4 reviews)
On May 24, 2007, kriswalker Sheridan, AR wrote:

I recently purchased three Emerald Rose sets through QVC from Cottage Farms, and I was so thrilled that I located the company and ordered additional items directly from the company. I am a little concerned about the true identity of the people who posted negative comments about this company. I order from Springhill, Breck's, Michigan Bulb and shop my local Lowe's and Home Depot for plants. I have a beautiful 1.5 acre homesite and lots of room for gardening - thank heavens for Cottage Farms when it comes to specialty trees or unique plants that I can't find elsewhere. Their prices are great and thus far, everything I've ever received has been nothing shy of what they promised. I am currently working on a new website where I can let everyone know about our garden progress, as we just purchased a new home (new for us, built in 84) and we've been updating INSIDE the home, but now we're working OUTSIDE. However, due to a wreck in March, I'm recovering from a broken leg and am having to rely on helpful family/friends to help me plant my plants but I'm NOT new to gardening as this is our third home (and final purchase, we hope!). I'll be proud to tell everyone that I got my roses and my weeping cherries from Cottage Farms.


On June 6th, 2007, kriswalker added the following:

Have received another shipment of plants from Cottage Farms, and while they are a little small compared to others such as Sooner Plant Farm, etc., they are healthy and are doing well! My rose is budding out and so are the ones I gave to my mother and sister. My sister is moving so she put her rose in a bucket with potting soil and it's doing very well! The tree has new growth all over it. I also had ordered some hydrangeas and other plants - small but healthy!
Positive rochonjo
(1 review)
On May 10, 2007, rochonjo Superior, WI wrote:

We LOVE Cottage Farms!! We have been purchasing from them for at least 6 years and have never had a negative experience. Yes, we did have to contact them twice about plants that did not come back the following year however they were always very nice and extremely helpful. I thought their custmer service was outstanding!! We have bought close to $1,000 worth of plants and bulbs from them over the years. I can honestly say we refer CF to family and friends all the time! Only an extremely statisfied customer would do that. Thanks to everyone for sharing their stories. I do however have a hard time believing that CF has given them a hard time about any of their past 1 year purchases. Their guarantee is outstanding and they have stood by it with us everytime

Negative fun2garden
(5 reviews)
On May 9, 2007, fun2garden Jefferson City, MO wrote:

I will NEVER order again from Cottage Farms and QVC! Both have displayed disrespect to me when I complained about my 7 orders this spring. QVC first screwed up the orders (sent dead plants, empty box, etc...). Then they told me to contact Cottage Farms - who refused to replace the dead plants and send the missing plants. I reminded them of Philip Watson's statement "We aren't happy if you aren't happy.." but they still refused to correct the problem. I paid in full for all items, and now have lost $400. I've found that SpringHIll Nurseries surpasses Cottage Farms in HONESTY, PRICING and RESPECT!! PLEASE BEWARE OF QVC AND COTTAGE FARMS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


On May 11th, 2007, fun2garden added the following:

LIARS! Please ignore the "kind" message from the company. I have printed a copy of my QVC orders which shows credit card payments, and have contacted my bank regarding transactions from QVC, so obviously Cottage Farms and QVC don't know what they're talking about. I received a call today directly from Cottage Farms (possibly the representative who wrote the comment),but he refused to solve the problem with the orders. I even offered to fax a copy of my evidence (although I wasn't wild about sharing bank account info with those who've already mistreated me..),but the fella said he didn't need it. I am FURIOUS with Cottage Farms' disrespectful attitude and QVC's lack of concern about the issue. Neither company cares about customers...they are only out for your money. So beware gardeners, don't get caught up in the evil web of Cottage Farms!
On May 14th, 2007, fun2garden added the following:

As if I haven't told you enough.......here's another report! Last year I ordered a set of 3 sub-zero roses. They were very pretty, but did not grow very tall. They did not return this spring, so I contacted Cottage Farms. They sent a replacement set. Guess what?? The replacement plants were dead upon arrival. Gee, that makes sense - replace a dead plant with another dead plant. Who's running the company??? I give up! Cottage Farms and QVC will no longer receive orders from me!!!!!! Buyer beware!!
On May 9, 2007, Cottage Farms responded with:

"


On May 10, 2007 11:21 AM, Cottage Farms added:

Cottage Farms is more than happy to stand behind our products with our one year warranty; however, we consulted with QVC about this customer and her orders and were told that the orders she is wanting replaced were not paid for. We do want our customers to be happy and we strive to make sure we meet that challenge by showing the same respect to each question or concern that we receive. In some instances, we must consult with our trading partners to insure that all customers are treated fairly and in this case we found that this customer was asking us to send and replace plants for which she never paid QVC. "


Positive jbm758
(1 review)
On Apr 24, 2007, jbm758 Centreville, MD wrote:

I have ordered many plants from Cottage Farms thru QVC. Never, EVER, had a problem. They have the best variety and customer service. If you do have a problem however you must call within the time allowed. Obviously they are not going to replace something ordered 2 years ago. So order with confidence. Phillip knows his stuff ! He definately should have his own show ! A +++ to Cottage Farms !

Negative pcat
(2 reviews)
On Apr 24, 2007, pcat Berwick, PA (Zone 6a) wrote:

I ordered a 3 rose hybrid tea rose collection from cottage farms through qvc my planting time for planting roses in mid to late april. After calling numerous times i receieved my roses in May. All 3 were extremely small but i really wanted the sterling silver so i planted them anyway. The princess DeMonaco and Margaret merril never grew and sterling silver shows signs of rmv. I called cottage farms to request replacement for the 2 that did not grow and was told they would be sent out next planting season. I had to call several times the following planting season to get them to send them to me. Finally the end of May again the replacement arrived. 2 floribundas not hybrid teas like i ordered and both of them very small and both very dead.
I will never order from this company again. I would rather take my chance on a 2.00 body bag rose. I have put in formal complaints to qvc and the next time i catch philip live on qvc you can bet ill call the testimonial line and share my story live
Pat C

Positive GRANNYMIN67
(1 review)
On Apr 22, 2007, GRANNYMIN67 Grand Bay, AL wrote:

First to the person who said C.F.D. no longer has a web site, they are mistaken, it is now up-graded & absolutely beautiful. I worked for C.F.D. For 12 years, and sadly had to retire at age 69, because of health. I still order from them, & they are the most concenious people ever. They will work with you and for you, any way possible. My tree roses are just absolutely gorgeous, as is everything else I have ever purchased from them. I may no longer work for this company, but I will certainly continue purchasing my plants from them.

Positive lilusgarden
(2 reviews)
On Apr 1, 2007, lilusgarden Charlotte, NC wrote:

I was glad to read the recent posting of the gardener who is in year 2 with their miniature rose garden. I just planted my 8 mini roses after purchasing a few weeks ago. I held off on planting a couple of weeks since we were having a little late cold weather, but replanted the plants in some peat pots and kept them indoors until safe to plant. Yes, they were small plants, but the price was only 20 bucks (or close) for 8 plants! They arrived in good condition. One even had a bloom. After a little tender loving care, they seem to be doing quite well. So far, so good and I will purchase again.

Positive faithsgarden
(1 review)
On Mar 27, 2007, faithsgarden Dacula, GA wrote:

In April of 2006 I purchased the 10 piece miniature rose collection from QVC by Cottage Farms. They arrived in beautiful condition. We planted them in the proper location and they arrived at the proper time to plant for our deep south zone. I never did anything except mulch and a little cutting back and I had little vases of miniature roses all over our house until late fall. I even took them each time we went to friends houses. They produced abundantly and beautifully. Now it is March 2007 and they are coming back strong. Two of them didn't fare as well as the others and I thought maybe they just needed more care (bloom boost food, etc.) last year, but they are already looking stronger than last year. It has been my experience to order from a grower that produces near or in my zone. Those plants always seem to do the best. Cottage Farms is in my zone. Was considering ordering daylillies and hydrangeas from them this year.
Dacula, GA

Positive Ham36
(3 reviews)
On Mar 7, 2007, Ham36 El Paso, TX wrote:

Some of the daylilies and the Rose of Sharon I ordered last year did not do well. I notifed them immediately and good looking replacements have just arrived. I am very pleased.

« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 Next »


Overwhelmed? There's a lot to see here. Try starting at our homepage.

[ Home | About | Advertise | Media Kit | Mission | Featured Companies | Submit an Article | Terms of Use | Tour | Rules | Privacy Policy | Cookie Policy | Contact Us ]

Back to the top

Copyright © 2000-2015 Dave's Garden, an Internet Brands company. All Rights Reserved.
 

Hope for America