Comments regarding Brent & Becky's BulbsClick here to return to Brent & Becky's Bulbs's listing.
You are viewing only neutral comments
|On Mar 5, 2017, Loretta_NJ Pequannock, NJ (Zone 6b) wrote:
I have been buying from this company for many years on and off and have had mostly a good experience. I always expect some disappointment when dealing with live plants and I don't go running back to return every failure or mislabeled plant. Even when one year my bulbs came covered in aphids, I took care of it on my own and did not fault the company because sometimes it happens. I still buy from them but are they a Top 5 company? Not to me.
|On Jun 19, 2016, BJames1 Elizabeth City, NC (Zone 8a) wrote:
Posted on January 5, 2010, updated June 19, 2016
On June 19th, 2016, BJames1 changed the rating from positive to neutral and added the following:
Plant quality has suffered in the past couple of years I have ordered from this company. I have received rotten and virused bulbs and herbaceous perennials that were the size of plugs. Company has tried to compensate for poor quality upon contacting customer service.
|On May 19, 2016, Botanist3 Stanardsville, VA wrote:
Posted on May 11, 2016, updated May 19, 2016
On May 11th, 2016, Botanist3 added the following:
When I first commented on our last shipment of Colocasia, I left out another detail, wanting to be sure before I posted: the Colocasia were shipped with spider mites. Curiously, some leaves, young ones, had been cut off prior to shipping. We noticed this and a \"sandy\" looking pattern on the leaves. Later, a microscope and fine webbing confirmed the infestation. This was not a case of mites crawling onto the plants-they had obviously been there awhile, judging by the eggs and nymphs. Having managed nurseries for over 30 years, few things are as annoying as importing pests into an otherwise clean growing area. Miticide has been applied, along with bottom heat, fertilizer and HID lighting to try and get the 3-4 inch plants to a usable size.
Anyone purchasing these plants should be on the lookout, in case the issue has not been resolved.
On May 19th, 2016, Botanist3 changed the rating from negative to neutral and added the following:
Brent & Becky's did issue a credit for the plants. However, I tried numerous times to reach Jay, who kindly gave contact information/phone, cell numbers-after some days, I've given up on that. After six attempts, there's not much use.
My review was updated to neutral vs. negative. I can't give a positive experience do to the lack of ability to speak with Jay and the inconvenience of having to treat my growing area for mites and having to locate replacement plants needed for a public display.
On May 19, 2016, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
"On May 11, 2016 10:39 AM, Brent & Becky\'s Bulbs responded with:
Good morning! We have taken your comments quite seriously. We have been investigating your order. All we see here on this website is that you are from Stanardsville VA. We only have one customer in Stanardsville and it is a Nursery. On the 2016 order for this customer, there are no Colocasias. Since you haven't contacted us directly about this situation, we're assuming that we may have the wrong customer. Would you be willing to email your customer number, order number or anything else you can share to email@example.com?
|On Apr 25, 2012, Tabacum Mantua, OH (Zone 5a) wrote:
Shipment arrived on time.....but packaging was two small boxes with newspaper stuffing...the dry dahlia bulbs were okay, but the mustifolia canna had a major growth area snapped off, it was still in the box....Has one growth area left, so it will grow to a smaller size....The colocasia arrived in good condition despite its limited packaging.... Prices are reasonable with this company....too bad I don't live closer for pickups.....
|On Aug 27, 2011, dicentra63 West Valley City, UT (Zone 6b) wrote:
Purchased five varieties of snow crocus to plant in the lawn. Two of the varieties failed to emerge, and only a few specimens emerged of the other three.
|On Mar 28, 2011, AS (Zone 7a) wrote:
Posted on July 10, 2006, updated March 28, 2011
On July 26th, 2007, AS added the following:
I finally remembered to update this. Soon after I posted my comment, I was contacted by an employee of Brent and Becky's, who told me that Brent and Becky have never been able to grow the leucocryne successfully in their garden either. I pointed out that their catalog description of growing conditions was misleading, as it suggests this bulb would be perfect for at least one growing season in my soil (though survival over the winter might have been iffy). I also suggested that they label any unfamiliar bulbs that are particularly finicky/ difficult to grow. I wasn't offered any refund, but at least I'm glad to see these particular bulbs are no longer being offered in their catalog. If "education is our most important product", as they claim, they can learn from someone else's mistakes next time, not mine.
On July 26th, 2007, AS added the following:
To clarify: Personally, I've added them to my "never again" list, based on their customer service. I buy bulbs for my benefit, not to trial unfamiliar bulbs for the company's benefit. But given that their other bulbs were fine, I wouldn't recommend against them either, as long as you stick to familiar things.
On March 28th, 2011, AS added the following:
After seeing a couple of recent comments and sympathizing, I wanted to comment that I'd definitely read this company's guarantee before ordering, and make sure you can live with it. I didn't, and regretted it. What it boils down to is that they guarantee that 1) the bulbs will reach you in good condition. 2) IF you can get them to grow, they will be true to name. There's no guarantee that they will be big enough to bloom the first year, and they specifically do not guarantee that their bulbs will grow successfully. It seems like this works fine for most of the things they sell, but it can be frustrating when things go wrong. (My own customer service experience felt irritatingly condescending.)
I'd also note that they are somewhat weak on warnings for bulbs that may be a little tougher to grow successfully. As an example, at least two other bulb companies note under calochortus that they hate freezing and thawing, but B & B do not. This might be a problem in parts of the country where freeze/thaw cycles are common. Given their guarantee, I suggest some independent research before ordering anything unfamiliar.
|On Mar 22, 2011, hoegarten70 Neeses, SC wrote:
These guys seem really awesome! I cannot wait to order!
|On Sep 15, 2010, kat81002 denver,
United States wrote:
your products are fine i would not say good but just fine.I would say you should step up in the competition.
On Sep 15, 2010, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
"On Sep 17, 2010 10:32 AM, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
|On Jun 6, 2010, givemethebeach West Lafayette, IN wrote:
Why is it that when i go to the Brent and Becky's website i get "Dave's Garden"? With all the cybercrime issues on the internet, this makes me very reluctant to use this site.
On Jun 6, 2010, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
"On Jun 7, 2010 9:23 AM, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
Susan, I have to say that this is troubling to me, too! How bizarre! Let me just make sure that you went to http://www.brentandbeckysbulbs.com. We don't have any login information on our website. It's free for anyone to browse. I'll check with the DG staff here and make sure our links are directing properly. Thanks for bringing this to our attention!
|On Oct 4, 2008, Dodes Coudersport, PA wrote:
I ordered a subsatnital number of tulip bulbs last fall and planted them according to directions. Although packaging was certainly adequate, several of my bulbs were mishapen and soft. I didn't plant those. Most of the tulips that came up in the spring were fine, but probably 1/10 of them either never came up or were tiny and not robust. In all fairness to the comopany, I never contacted them with the problem so I can't report whether or not they would have made it right.
|On Apr 27, 2008, Miarka Ware Neck, VA (Zone 7b) wrote:
I have bought 3 batches of Crocosmia from B&B's and they have never come up. Also, their Gladiolus, sold as hardy here didn't come up the second year even though I dug them up and put them in the garage for the winter. I don't know, maybe it's me???
|On Apr 7, 2008, knexsen Virginia Beach, VA wrote:
I'm not sure what to think about this company, and may have to ammend my review later. I placed an order a few months ago, and was a bit disappointed to see they were waiting to send it until the first week in April, as I am zone 7B and every other site I've ordered from sent my items a month earlier. Also, I'd ordered several seed packets and feel I should have received them much sooner!
On Apr 7, 2008, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
On Apr 8, 2008 11:41 AM, Brent & Becky's Bulbs added:
Normally, when an order is put into our system, we use an "educated guess" as to when the appropriate time to plant will be. Mother Nature has had a fairly sick sense of humor lately and sometimes things warm more quickly than we thought. But that's why we email the acknowledgment to give the customer the opportunity to call to say, PLEASE send them earlier or PLEASE send them later, whichever the case may be! We really do want them to land when YOU want them, so we encourage people to give us a call if we you'd like it changed.
|On Apr 2, 2007, keight Harrisonburg, VA wrote:
The following is an email I sent to Brent and Becky's...FIVE times. Since they do not respond to my emails, maybe they will respond here:
On April 10th, 2007, keight changed the rating from negative to neutral and added the following:
I've changed my rating to neutral because I received a refund for the mislabeled bulbs. I am satisfied with the refund.
|On Sep 3, 2006, tacobe11e Arlington, VA (Zone 7a) wrote:
I ordered a variety of bulbs including cannas and calla lily. I planted the cannas in different beds around my garden. None of the cannas came up. Neither did the calla. About two-thirds of the other bulbs, which included crocosmia and bletilla, came up.
|On Sep 3, 2006, White_Hydrangea Aurora, CO (Zone 5a) wrote:
They came highly recommended, and I was going to try to put an order in with them, hopefully in time to get some bulbs this fall, but this company apparently no longer exists. Trying to link to their website gets me "Page Not Found." I don't think I have time to wait.
On Sep 3, 2006, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
On Sep 5, 2006 11:14 AM, Brent & Becky's Bulbs added:
Alas, as many times as I've tried, Mother Nature won't change bulb season being the same as hurricane season! Tropical Storm Ernesto - which was 10mph shy of beiing a hurricane - had its eye pass between us and Virginia Beach. There are places that today - 4 days later, still don't have power or phone. Our website when down when everything else did.
|On Aug 18, 2006, audreyannewert Athol, MA wrote:
as of Aug 18, their website is not available. Is the company still in business?
On Aug 18, 2006, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
On Aug 18, 2006 9:56 AM, Brent & Becky's Bulbs added:
On 8/18 we lost our internet connection 3 times and our website, which is "in-house", was unable to be accessed. It was down as well this morning (8/19). We have an IT guy and the cable company on the case. We apologize for any inconvenience, and hope to have this glitch resolved quickly! If you can not log on to our website, feel free to call us toll free at 877-661-2852 and place your order, or just to check the status of our site.
|On Aug 3, 2006, cupre Albuquerque, NM wrote:
My order included Iris foetidissima and Agapanthus Blue Heaven. The Agapanthus was pretty tiny but I've come to find that most companies send pretty small Ag's, not like the gallon cans you can buy in nurseries in California. Now in it's second growing season, it produced a tiny flower spike. The Iris foetidissima was very tiny and variable, some being small but plump, and a couple being so small that I thought they were pieces that must have fallen off the "real" plant. Two died soon after planting and the other 3 are about 4 inches tall in their second growing season. I'll try again with less unusual bulbs this year.
|On Jun 13, 2006, Corgi_Lily Lowell, MI wrote:
I ordered several different types of Lilies in late winter. Being in a cold zone, it was quite late before they were shipped. All of the Asiatics were large and lovely; two types of the Orientals were not nearly as nice or as large. Realizing that different bulbs can come in different sizes, this did not deter me; but I did phone immediately as one type of hybrid was smooshy- all of that type. They were very nice on the phone- said all of that type were really not so great that year and I could have a refund or they could go and sift through what was left to find me some better bulbs. I took the first option as it was getting a bit late to plant lilies in my yard. Anyway- what problems I did have were quickly resolved in a friendly manner. I only wish they had an early shipping option.
|On Apr 30, 2006, Soupy51 Saint Paul, MN wrote:
I was pretty disappointed receiving an email a couple of weeks ago from this supplier letting me know that the cannas I purchased from them was not available. If I had known at the time I placed the order, I would have purchased it from another source. Now, it is too late, and other sources are sold out, and I will have to wait another year before I can grow this plant. I realize that sometimes their vendor does not come through on their end, so hopefully this is a one time issue.
|On Mar 20, 2006, johnrobbins Chesterton, IN wrote:
I had been buying bulbs from Brent & Beckys for many years, (back when it was the Daffodil Mart before White Flower Farms bought them out). I was attracted to them because of the wide variety of daffodils offered. The variety offered had been declining over the past few years, so their appeal had declined as well, but what is troubling and reason I am writing this post is that the last two orders I placed from them have not bloomed the first year after planting. Now bulbs offered for sale should be fully formed, mature and ready to bloom the first season after planting for the bud should be fully formed (in embryonic stage) and ready to go.
On May 18th, 2006, johnrobbins changed the rating from negative to neutral and added the following:
While still annoyed at the non-blooming performance of some daffodils I had ordered in the past, my previous post was probably a bit harsh, written in a fit of pique. I did talk to their plant manager (Jay) who was very courteous and pleasant. I have reviewed their 2006 catalog and must admit that I have long wanted to order Xit (which I denied myself last year) which is again available, and there are a few other offerings which look intriquing enough to tempt me to once again order from them, so I'll cross my fingers and hope for the best.
On Mar 20, 2006, Brent & Becky's Bulbs responded with:
On Mar 21, 2006 12:58 PM, Brent & Becky's Bulbs added:
Just got back from the New England Flower Show (had fun meeting all of you Bostonians!) and gave John a call. He was nice enough to try and recap his experiance with his '03 and '04 orders. He mentioned that he may not have identified himself at his calls so that we could have put notes in his file and handle his concerns with more TLC, but none-the-less, we've reiterated with our CSRs to take notes on every call so we can handle them and follow up more effectively. We sell bulbs, but our real product is education...both for the consumer AND for US. We know what works well for us here in VA, zone 7B - we've only gardened here - and encourage all of our customers to communicate their successes and failures so we get a better idea of how things perform in other areas of the country.
|On Dec 5, 2005, shimer Marietta, GA (Zone 7b) wrote:
This Aug. I went looking for bulb vendors using the Garden Watchdog. From the reviews, I tried ordering from 3, among them Brent and Becky's. I've been delighted with the quality of the bulbs from all 3 vendors I tried: all excellent.
|On Oct 26, 2005, kbaumle Northwest, OH (Zone 5b) wrote:
This was my first experience with Brent & Becky's and I have to say I'm amazed at the size of the bulbs! Communication was good. They sent an e-mail for confirmation of the order, as well as when it was shipped. If how the bulbs look are any indication of their performance, I have no doubt I will have wonderful flowers next spring!
On January 19th, 2007, kbaumle changed the rating from positive to neutral and added the following:
I'm changing my rating to neutral, due to my current experience with a second order with B & B's. I ordered four hippeastrum bulbs, each a different cultivar. As of now, two have bloomed, and they are both the same. I e-mailed the company about the error (I am missing 'Charisma') and I have not received any response. I e-mailed from a link on their website (firstname.lastname@example.org), and when several days went by and I didn't hear from them, I e-mailed again, with the email@example.com e-mail address also posted on their website. I have not gotten a response from the second e-mail either.
While the incorrect bulb has performed well, it's not what I ordered. I'm quite surprised that I've not gotten any response to this whatsoever.
|On Aug 30, 2005, Ladyday Mitchell, IN wrote:
I loved their catalog and all the information it contains, as well as the large selection of bulbs available. However, I did not have good results from the bulbs I ordered. Some of the tulips bloomed (possibly squirrel predation was to blame) but the foxtail lilies were a huge disappointment. One grew and bloomed, not well; others didn't bloom at all, altho one did grow and bloom the second summer. I hesitate to order them again, with that kind of a track record.
|On Jul 25, 2005, andidandi wrote:
This company provides a mixed experience, leaning toward a negative. Their site provides no way to email, so you have to call, and they did not properly account for my order on two different occaissions. Once the count was wrong, the second time they failed to provide the credit owed for an out of stock item. They seem to get by on their reputation for good stock, but have customer service issues.
|On Jul 8, 2005, LucasCatChow Tulsa, OK wrote:
This was my first order from B&B and it was not a great experience. This spring I ordered some white Liatris. While I was on the phone ordering this, I added a Ginger plant on a whim. B&B quoted me a total, it sounded good, so away we went. A month later I get a note saying that they had misquoted the shipping on the ginger and they were adding another $10.00 to my credit card. I would not have ordered the Ginger if I'd known how much the charge was to be. And to add insult to injury of the 10 white Liatris bulbs only 2 were white. The rest were the neon Purple (probably Kobald) which was not in my color scheme at all. When I called to complain they were fairly nice. I was credited for the price of the Liatris (but not shipping) and told (in essence) that the company is not responsible for quoting correct prices when an order is placed with them. So now I know how they are to do business with. I give them a neutral because that's how I feel about buying from them again. I'll look at other places I'm POSITIVE about first.
|On Jun 23, 2005, gardenbooks Houston, TX (Zone 9a) wrote:
The plants were healthy and are growing well. The instruction booklet that came with them is very helpful. However, this company's business practices are very poor. My plants were shipped and my credit card was billed over two months ago. Two days ago they posted a charge to my credit card for additional shipping. I learned about this from a postcard that was sent to me. I checked my account online and saw when the charge was posted. I have a real problem with charges made to my credit card account that I do not know about or approve. The original charge to my account was the amount stated in the confirmation email I received after placing my order. A shipping charge was included in that original amount. It seems to me that they made a mistake in not charging me enough for shipping and that it was discovered later. I was not notified by phone or email; just a postcard after the fact.
|On May 24, 2005, acbailey17 North Andover, MA wrote:
I am a relatively new gardener and was very excited to order from B&B. I have ordered twice and both times my experience was similar.
|On Jan 4, 2005, langbr Lenexa, KS (Zone 6a) wrote:
Placed 2 orders for fall bulbs from B&B. Very happy with all the bulbs. No rotten or disintegrating ones in the bunch. All of the fall-blooming crocus and colchicum bloomed this year.
|On Nov 19, 2004, kdjoergensen Waxhaw (Charlotte), NC (Zone 7b) wrote:
This company gets great reviews, but they have not lived up to my expectations when it comes to size of some of their products, particular daylilies and tulips were small. This is the reason for rating 'Neutral'.
|On Oct 21, 2004, PlantsnobIN Paoli, IN wrote:
Placed order this fall, rec'd bulbs quickly and in good condition. The fall crocus I rec'd earlier is blooming today, the color is even better than I could have hoped for. Only wish I had ordered more of them.
On November 7th, 2006, PlantsnobIN changed the rating from positive to neutral and added the following:
Wish I could keep it positive. I ordered more bulbs this spring, with less than stellar results. Out of 40 crocosmias, 1 came up. I emailed twice about the no-shows, only to get a reply of 'croscosmias are late summer plants'. Yes, I know they bloom late, but there was no growth whatsoever. I also ordered lilies, which did ok. But, when one variety bloomed, it wasn't what I ordered. I noticed, but didn't contact the company due to their response to earlier emails. I later rec'd a postcard from them saying the lily had bloomed for them the wrong color. No kidding. No offer to send the correct one next year. I don't think I will be ordering more.
|On Jun 20, 2004, farmerpickle Alpharetta, GA (Zone 7b) wrote:
Most bulbs are in good conditions, but not cheap. I don't like the fact that took couple of months to get my bulbs.
|On Nov 27, 2003, timtijones wrote:
I ordered late this year, and chose to order 400 bulbs from Brent & Becky's. I ordered on October 19th. I heard nothing from them. I emailed them three times and called their answering machine once. Still no response. I finally went out and bought bulbs locally (2nd and 3rd choices by this time) because I wanted to get spring bulbs in the ground before the weather turned more wintry. Finally, on November 11th I received an automated shipping notice. The bulbs arrived on Friday the 14th. While I am pleased with the quality and price of the bulbs themselves, I was very disappointed in their customer service. Reading other comments, it appears that it would not have helped to order earlier anyway, because it looks like everyone's order was shipped at the same time. I may consider ordering from them again, but I won't plan my planting around expecting to receive any bulbs from them in a timely manner.
|On Nov 13, 2003, crc wrote:
I have placed substantial orders from Brent & Becky's for the past three years. They are my only bulb supplier because I have found their prices very reasonable and the quality and selection good. My only complaint is that this fall they were very slow to fill my order, and it proved impossible to contact them about the problem.
|On Jul 6, 2003, califgardner wrote:
I'ved ordered from Brent and Becky's the last two years and they are extreemly nice. Unfortunately the product I received was not very good. The first year I'm convinced I got undersized bulbs...but let it pass. Last year I ordered 200 narcissi as a gift. I inspected them before planting and found 1/4 of them to be rotted and moldy! I called the company and, while they were surprised about this particular variety being rotted, they said they had been having a problem with their shipments from Europe. With such information you would think they would be more careful about what was sent from their warehouse. Although a refund/credit was offered I never received it. I would suppose that if I called them again this year they may remember. However, after reading similar accounts in this venue, I'm afraid it appears as a standard (bad) business practice. Still haven't determined if I will give them another chance.
On July 6th, 2003, califgardner changed the rating from negative to neutral and added the following:
|On Mar 17, 2003, PatriciaCrav wrote:
I ordered from Brent and Becky's Bulbs with good results in 2000 and 2001. In 2002, however, B&B's Bulbs sent dead Anemone coronaria (de Caen) corms AND charged for chionodoxa that were not shipped. I notified the company twice, by email, of the dead corms and overcharge. There was no response.
On March 18th, 2003, PatriciaCrav changed the rating from negative to neutral and added the following:
Becky Heath sent a note explaining personal reasons for the delay in responding to my letter. These things happen. The company will be refunding my costs for dead plants and for the chionodoxa.
On March 18th, 2003, PatriciaCrav added the following:
|On Feb 1, 2002, xanadugardens Paradise, CA (Zone 8b) wrote:
I have heard and read nothing but good about Brent and Becky's. They have a fantastic web site and an excellent reputation. So I was surprised to find that one set of crocosmias I ordered from them sprouted very poorly. Fewer than a quarter came up and those were weak and sickly. Another type of crocosmia from the same order, planted four feet away, sprouted vigorously and completely. Three e-mails later, I am still waiting for a response.