Photo by Melody
If you're looking for the today's articles, look no further than here!

Comments regarding Gurney's Seed & Nursery

Click here to return to Gurney's Seed & Nursery's listing.

You are viewing only positive comments

  Feedback History and Summary  
297 positives
114 neutrals
347 negatives


Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... 8 Next »

Positive dogdoc01
(2 reviews)
On Mar 20, 2015, dogdoc01 Oklahoma City, OK wrote:

I ordered 4 apple trees (2 liberty and 2 goldrush) and 1 peach tree. All arrived in great shape. I was very impressed with the root system on these bareroot trees as well as the trees. Hoping to have fruit in a few years. No doubt I will order again!!!!

Positive WTxgarden
(1 review)
On Mar 15, 2015, WTxgarden Coleman, TX wrote:

I ordered a cherry tree and 3 kinds of strawberries. The cherry tree that was sent to me is absolutely the best live plant that I have ever received through the mail. Its doing well. The strawberries had very good roots and started putting out leafs within two days of being planted. All of them were very healthy plants and I could not have asked for better products.

Positive lwbuchholz
(5 reviews)
On Jan 9, 2015, lwbuchholz Manhattan, MT wrote:

Posted on June 29, 2014, updated January 9, 2015
I placed 2 orders from them this spring with their 50% off coupon. The trees came through wonderfully. All the fruit trees have started growing except 2 of them. I contacted them about it and they said they would replace them or credit me. The nut trees haven\'t shown any sign of life yet. I have been told they take longer so I will see. They told me they had a forever warranty. If the nut trees fail I will post again otherwise I am pleased. I wished I had as good of luck with the other nurseries.

On January 9th, 2015, lwbuchholz added the following:

Wow I had some of the plants that didn't make it and I told this company and they immediately made up a shipment order for them no questions asked and I didn't have to jump through any hoops. I will report how the plants come through.
Positive goldenone19
(3 reviews)
On May 31, 2014, goldenone19 Reno, NV wrote:

I got a free top hat blueberry plant from Gurney's all I had to pay was the $5.99 shipping. Some time ago I started to get their magazines and was a little skeptical about ordering from them since I was used to the glossy magazine that Burpee's usually sends. Out of curiosity, I went to their website and subscribed to their e-mails. Like most seed companies subscribing to their e-mail list=better deals. I couldn't pass up the free blueberry plant which included no other catches, saying I had to buy a certain amount to get the plant 'free' It wasn't like that at all. My plant arrived a week later healthy and green. So I went ahead and ordered a pink lemonade blueberry on sale as well. I was surprised with the quality of the Top Hat blueberry seeing as it was 'free' and free usually means dead, so I'm expecting the quality of the pink lemonade blueberry to be of excellent quality as well. I have a small patio garden where I grow most things in pots and usually order from Burpee, this year I have taken a chance on two new seed companies, Gurney's and Territorial Seeds, both experiences have been good so I may consider ordering more from them in the future.

Positive littlebunnyfufu
(5 reviews)
On May 29, 2014, littlebunnyfufu South Sumter, SC wrote:

I have a very large acreage property with five separate fruit orchards with over 150 trees,a half acre blueberry patch, and a half acre strawberry patch. On average I spend thousands of dollars a year on edible landscaping, and I purchase from a wide range of internet plant purveyors.

In the grand scheme of things, Gurney's is a good, reliable company if you understand the company's strengths and quirks. I have ordered from them for years because their customer service is easy to deal with, and their ironclad plant replacement policy is trouble free.

Fruit trees-meaning apples, pears, peaches, plums, apricots-are their overall most reliable product. The vast majority of their trees are larger than what I have been able to procure from other companies, which have higher price points.
The only times I have received relatively small fruit trees are products that are unusual varieties like Trugold peach, Flat is Wonderful peach, Sugar Pearls apricot, or Harlayne apricot.

Their apple trees and pear trees have always been large caliber and very satisfactory.

Blueberry bushes and grape vines have always been of consistently good quality in my experience. The blueberry bushes are relatively expensive for the size of the plant, but they've all arrived alive and vigorous. Ka-Bluey blueberry especially grow quickly especially if potted in Miracle Grow for the first year. Frequently they are triple or quadruple in size when I transplant to the field in the following year.

Though the one year old grape vines look small on arrival, I rarely have any of them fail to establish directly on in-ground planting. I particularly like Pink Reliance for vigor and beauty. By the next year, mine were twenty times larger than planting with minimal care and Miracle Grow fertilizer a couple times a year.

Asparagus crowns are another product that I find very gratifying from Gurney's. Their two year old crowns are the worth the added expense. I've purchased Jersey Supreme, Jersey Knight, Jersey Giant, and Purple Passion-all were enormous crowns compared to two year crowns I've purchased from other websites and at the local brick and mortar big box stores. I have a quarter acre in asparagus on my property, and the survival rate on these crowns has been excellent. I do recommend spraying the crowns with a fungicide on arrival because mildly damp crowns packed in a sealed box has a tendency to get moldy-it's a problem I've noticed from all mail order crowns I've received.

I have come to realize over years of trial and error that the following plants supplied by Gurney's are wee small.

1) Figs - I've used larger toothpicks
2) Bush cherries-Carmine Jewel comes in a 2 inch pot despite it's retail price of $35 a plant
3) Superior Chinese chestnut-drinking straw size and slow growing. (My 3 yr old trees are thigh high to me, and I'm 5'2")
4) Raspberry canes - Small compared to other places I've purchased from and a very small root system. I've found them hard to establish. Survival rate has been like 1-2 plants out of 10 purchased. I've found it true 3 years running on the Anne raspberry plants.

The sweet potato slips are expensive but have been as good as any that I've gotten from other internet sites. You'll want to open the box immediately and get the slips into water when they arrive because they ship with very little moisture retention packing.

I would advise against ordering live vegetable plants like tomatoes from Gurney's. Tomato plants really don't ship well regardless the seller, and I find tomato plants are pretty much the easiest garden plant to start from seed aside from beans and peas. Growing tomatoes from seed is pretty idiot proof, and seeds are a much better bang for the buck for vegetables in general anyway. One packet of tomato seeds can last me four years of planting-that's true for squash, eggplant, cucumber, pumpkin, and watermelon just to name a few.

The uncertainty in when an order will ship is just a fact of life with Gurney's. If you can't accept it, you need to find some place that ships like clockwork-such as Gurney's sometimes has to locate the plants from its sister companies/network of suppliers before the items can ship. Multiple shipments to complete an order is just the way they function. It's normally two weeks to a month from the time I order before I receive a complete order, and sometimes items can pushed back to ship next season or get cancelled altogether. Those are the breaks when ordering plants over the internet. I've experienced cancellations and deferrals on shipment of product from 100% of the internet nursery's that I've used.

I've used Burpee's, Park Seeds, Wayside Gardens, Raintree Nursery, Burnt Ridge Nursery. Peaceful Valley Farm Supply, Grandpa's Orchard, Stark Brothers, Berries Unlimited, and I'm sure I'm forgetting to list a dozen others.

My favorite thing about Gurney's are-as I mentioned-their hassle free replacement of dead plants regardless of whatever ignorance, idiocy, or neglect a customer inflicted on the hapless plant.

My second favorite thing about Gurney's is that they send links for deep discounts on all their products if you subscribe to their e-mail advertisements. That $35 Carmine Jewel bush cherry was mine for $15. Yes, it's still tiny, but the great thing about bush cherries is that they grow extremely fast and are very forgiving of stupidity we humans inflict on them. I've had Hansen's and Nanking bush cherries go from six inches tall to over five feet tall in 2 years.

Positive chrisp123
(3 reviews)
On Apr 26, 2014, chrisp123 SAGLE, ID wrote:

I ordered in 2013 black walnut blue crop blue berry chandler blue berry 2 raspberries English walnut and some garden seeds. everything grew nicely except the blue crop blueberry, they sent a very nice bigger than advertised English walnut. the blue berry was replaced this year as they ran out last year. customer service was nice to me. I ordered from them again this year and have received all plants and seeds. the butternut didn't look too good upon arrival box end smashed and the tip of tree is broke probably due to ups handling rather than gurney's but planted and will see what happens. by the way the blue berry that died last year when I dug it up this year it had a gopher tunnel under it. so I probably owe gurneys for the second blueberry as it wasn't their fault it died. the hazel nut they sent this year looks good and the Ozark strawberries are showing signs of life despite the cold weather the last part of April here. their black walnuts are a bit on the small side but have good root systems. I would recommend gurneys

Positive juhur7
(9 reviews)
On Apr 25, 2014, juhur7 Anderson, IN (Zone 6a) wrote:

Posted on April 18, 2014, updated April 26, 2014
Posted on April 14, 2013, updated April 18, 2014
Posted on April 2, 2013, updated April 14, 2013
Posted on October 26, 2012, updated April 2, 2013
Posted on September 13, 2012, updated October 26, 2012
I have bought plants from this company many times over the years, I only find the plants get here a little slowly ,only they tell you that to start with about when things are to ship..Everything I have ever bought from this company has grown and done well.

On October 25th, 2012, juhur7 added the following:

i purchased a few rhododendrons as a gift and they looked so nice I kept one for myself,the garlic looks good also. Everything I have ever gotten from this company has done well.I have been getting plants and seeds from Gurney's since the 1970's,since then they have changed location and my opinion stays the same,a good solid place to shop for your garden!
On April 2nd, 2013, juhur7 added the following:

My three little bare root Nanking cherries look good , The perennial Huckleberry looks excellent , The Pink lemonade Blueberry could not look better ,
The other two bare root Blueberries look nice , above average . a Spicebush bare root looks excellent .
These plants are all near to exactly what I would I expect as to the cost . One of the Nanking Cherries has shriveled thin with the other two leaved and growing , only I am satisfied as to the cost as you could not do better in a dollar sale . The third will require special care to grow well , and I am sure it will ,,,
On April 14th, 2013, juhur7 added the following:

Updating the nankink cherry the third skinny little one has budded to leaf and is now growing ..
On April 18th, 2014, juhur7 added the following:

I ordered a few more today , never had any problems with old SD . or that they have moved to IN ,
I will update when they get here , Plants from last year , those that have not been destroyed buy garden pests (animals here)
and my lack of care sometimes , are doing excellent ..
When you consider quality , with this companies specials . it is a much better gardening experience ..
On April 25th, 2014, juhur7 added the following:

Plants arrived today , All in great shape , I still have no problems with the folks at Gurney's ..
If they are now Garden's alive ? I believe ..
On Apr 25, 2014, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Sep 17, 2012 1:41 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you so much for your review. We appreciate you sharing your experience with our company."

Positive u2dan
(2 reviews)
On Apr 24, 2014, u2dan Winthrop, MA wrote:

I wrote a similar review for Michigan Bulb, apparently Gurney's and Spring Hill are related. Their websites look exactly the same but the offer slightly different plants so I am not too worried about the quality since I was happy with my Michigan Bulb order. The only thing I am not happy with are their dynamic price changes which can happen from one second to another.

For example, you get your $20 off coupon which sounds so amazing right? Well, watch the prices of your shopping cart increase a great deal, you end up paying MORE with this coupon than if you don't use one. I had a banana tree in my cart, which I found for $8.99. When I added the coupon, my price went up to 19.99 and the prices on the website changed drastically too.

I became fed up with the price increase so I left the site and ended up finding Gurney's on Amazon with MUCH cheaper prices. I clicked on the Gurneys link which brought me to their site with very low prices and flat rate shipping. I ended up ordering from this version of their site and overall I am happy with the price and service so far. Am awaiting delivery.

Positive dremusicmd
(3 reviews)
On Apr 16, 2014, dremusicmd wrote:

I have ordered seeds, live plants, raspberries, apple trees, plums, peaches, multiple species of maples, pecans, english walnuts, and several ornamental trees. As well as strawberries and seed starting products from Gurneys in multiple orders this season. All have arrived in great condition. Trees and Raspberries are breaking dormancy, strawberries are doing extremely well. I have tomatoes over a foot high under the grow lights and the live plants are holding on despite this cold snap we are experiencing this week. (With a little help by me covering them). I will continue to order from them. Very pleased!

Positive Ncalvert2012
(1 review)
On Apr 15, 2014, Ncalvert2012 Arrowhead Springs, WY wrote:

I have shopped with Gurney's for years and have had nothing but good experiences with them. After reading the negative review from coonhound62301, I had to put it to the test, I had placed a fairly large order with them and decided that I too would actually count the seeds I had ordered to see if I got shorted too. Not only did I NOT get shorted, we stopped counting after the fourth packet if seeds was actually OVER the count stated on the package and in the catalog. I will continue shopping with Gurney's. They are an awesome company.

Positive neferset
(1 review)
On Apr 8, 2014, neferset Rockwood, TN (Zone 7b) wrote:

Posted on April 1, 2014, updated April 8, 2014
I got a coupon that gave me free shipping and half off anything in the store, so I thought, "Why not?" I know Gurney's reputation is far from the best, but I've ordered from places with poor reputations before and come out ok.

My fiance came home and said, "You only ordered 3 Nanking Cherries? You should have gotten at least nine!"

So, I placed another order and applied the same coupon which said it was good all weekend. The coupon applied and I sent the payment information, but the website didn't continue to the confirmation screen. A call to customer service assured me that they had received my order, though, and there was no need to place another one.

Later, my fiance says, "We could use a couple of fruit trees here and here," I asked him if Native Plums would be ok and he said yes, so I placed the third order with the same coupon and the same website issue, though the order was received.

A few days later, I got my confirmations and within about a week of ordering, I got a shipping notice for the first and third order. Much to my surprise, they were going to be delivered the next day by the time I tracked them.

The plants seemed well wrapped. The "Dwarf Venous Orange" which I understand is a Calamondin and not a sweet orange like they have it labeled, arrived in decent health, though it was a bit bug eaten. The first three Nankings were already showing green buds. The two plums are a still fast asleep. I'm hoping they are able to break dormancy, but if I look around, several of the trees we have in my yard haven't yet.

A week later I got the shipping confirmation for the next six Nanking Cherries, on the day they were to arrive this time, and they were much like the previous ones. I can't vouch for everything, but the Nanking Cherries and citrus certainly seem to arrive alive.

On April 8th, 2014, neferset added the following:

I can now vouch for the Native Plums. They are also beginning to wake up for spring. Everything seems to be alive and in good health.
Positive rodlaver4
(2 reviews)
On Mar 8, 2014, rodlaver4 China Grove, NC wrote:

Posted on March 6, 2014, updated March 9, 2014
I received my Spring catalog from Gurneys in the mail. It had a coupon on the front for 100 dollars off a 200 dollar order. Every year when I get my taxes back I order the items for my garden from Gurneys and the coupons on the catalog always save me a lot of money. I've been doing this for years. Well this year I went on their site and got everything I needed for my garden. The total was 228 dollars. i then put my coupon code in, making my total 128 dollars. i completed the checkout process and I thought everything was fine. Until about a week or so later when I received my credit card statement showing I had been charged the full amount. I've always used their coupons and never had this problem. I contacted them about the situation and I've never hard back from them. If they don't do anything to fix the issue, I will not be doing business with them anymore. I don't have the money to get cheated out of 100

On March 8th, 2014, rodlaver4 changed the rating from negative to positive and added the following:

Gurney's finally returned my email and apologized for messing up on my order and refunded me the money they over charged. Thanks to their great customer service i will continue using Gurneys for my garden needs.
Positive badcat
(1 review)
On Jan 10, 2014, badcat BELLEVILLE, IL (Zone 6b) wrote:

I ordered plants last spring from here. they came in but I was busy remodeling our house. So I put the strawberries in the fridge and put the bushes and plants in pots on the back patio..for a couple of months, giving them some water when they started to wilt or when I remembered haha. I had ordered:

Gurney whopper strawberries
Joseph Climbing Rose
Bi Colored Butterfly Bush
Zebra Grass
..and some other stuff ($200 worth)
OH Grapes, 2 type of grapes Niagra and Concord

Strawberries are doing great, Zebra grass was 2 ft tall this fall..even after my husband mowed it over a couple times over the summer..

The Bicolor and Rosebush...I was prepared that they wouldnt be like the picture shown, but I was willing to try them. I really loved the colors. They were about 18"-24" when I got them. They are both 6 feet tall. The colors are correct on them! Made me happy! My Aunt had asked me if the roses had any smell, I got the first blooms..They smell just like my grandmas roses. They smell beautiful and look the same. Definately not disappointed.

Grape vines, I had grapes on them already after planting. I picked them off to promote growth..against my will haha. Im looking farward to what they do this year :). Showed up about 12-18", they are now approx 4 feet.

I really like this company and Im getting around my order for them this year.

Positive BiffLundgren
(8 reviews)
On Dec 7, 2013, BiffLundgren Midland, MI wrote:

I ordered Sundance and PixieCrunch apple trees in the spring and the trees were very healthy upon arrival. They both made it through the year in very good shape.

I've read Cathy's notes below and I just want to point out how important it is to let your customers know if you can fill their orders or not. This would have given her time to look elsewhere for her fall plants.

I wish she could have gotten her plants in the ground this fall. It is 'that' frustrating when you look forward getting what you ordered only to be told you won't get your plants.

My experience with Gurney's has been a very big positive for me...I've been waiting twenty years to get some land to plant a small vineyard and orchard. The PixieCrunch and Sundance were very solid beautiful trees with good reviews at

Positive Kvrotsos
(1 review)
On Nov 7, 2013, Kvrotsos Montclair, NJ wrote:

Like other people writing reviews here, we were surprised that the dwarf peach tree we ordered arrived as a 4-foot, thumb-thick "twig" with a few roots. We kept faith, though, and planted it as directed. The first year, it amazed us as it thrived and grew. By year two, it bore fruit. Over the past two years (years 3 & 4), it survived an October blizzard and two hurricanes, and it bears more bounteous, delicious peaches every summer. Give twigs a chance! Our tree is everything the Gurney's catalogue promised, and the peaches are truly the best we have ever tasted.

On Nov 7, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Nov 15, 2013 4:37 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you so much for your wonderful feedback, enjoy those peaches."

Positive chefearly
(1 review)
On Oct 16, 2013, chefearly Visalia, CA wrote:

I am a Master Gardener in central California. My focus is School Gardens. There are over 50 school gardens in our area, all dependent on donations and grants for sustainability of their gardens. Last month, I wrote to over 35 seed companies asking for seed donations from their 2013 seed collection. I also said that I would pay shipping costs if need be. Well, to my delight, I received a BIG box of seeds soon to be out of date from Gurney Seeds. And they did not ask me to pay anything! Now I have the pleasant task of distributing these packets of seeds to school gardens for their upcoming plantings!! Gurney's is an awesome partner in education. Thank you!

On Oct 16, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Nov 15, 2013 4:39 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your feedback, so happy we could help."

Positive Hoosierguy1986
(3 reviews)
On Jun 24, 2013, Hoosierguy1986 Fort Wayne, IN wrote:

See a lot of negative reviews and maybe I am lucky. I had an email offer for a gold rush apple tree for around 5 bucks that I couldn't pass up. The tree shipped in excellent condition with massive roots and the trunk as big around as my thumb. Shipped early in the year well before I had time to get it in the ground so I stuck it in my wife's flower pot an kept it watered few weeks later things warmed up in Indiana and I planted it in the ground. Few more weeks and everything came to life. Awesome to see! Figured I would give credit where it's due. I got an awesome price and a really healthy tree!

On Jun 24, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Jun 25, 2013 9:21 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you very much for your review about our company and our products. Enjoy your tree!"

Positive Zafak
(6 reviews)
On May 22, 2013, Zafak Oakbrook, KY wrote:

90% of what I ordered was nice sized and started growing well right from the start. The carmine jewel dwarf cherry's, currant, and wolf berry had leaf die back to the point that I was going to compost them, but they re-sprouted new leaves. I did not expect the plants to have die back considering the nursery is in the next state.

The only thing that I didnt like was that the standard apple tree was topped at 3 feet before being shipped, and whoever did it apparently had a hard time cutting because it had three cut marks below where it was topped, as if they kept trying to go higher up the tree until they could get their pruners to cut all the way through the tree. But the tree is putting on new growth so I cant complain much

Positive Miller13
(2 reviews)
On May 20, 2013, Miller13 Nibley, UT wrote:

I have to give this company a positive rating. I bought a sugar pearls apricot and a rose bush from this company in the spring of 2012. The apricot was the tiniest tree i have ever received. I can't complain however, because it said 2-4' in the description and mine was a little over 3'. But it was full of life. This is it's second year in my garden, it is still very small but it bloomed this spring!

The rose bush did not make it through the winter. I called them and they sent me a refund check without any hassle at all.

From what i remember from a year ago, shipping was problem free as well.

On May 20, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 21, 2013 1:26 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

We appreciate your feedback. Thank you for sharing and Happy Gardening!"

Positive laurelr0420
(1 review)
On May 20, 2013, laurelr0420 CANDLER, NC wrote:

We ordered several plants - fruit trees, berries, asparagus, arctic kiwis. We ended up getting sucked into one of their pay $100 for $200 deals. Most of the plants have been growing beautifully but a few didn't work out. For those, we took advantage of their 100% guarantee and received a hassle-free refund. I plan to order from them again.

On May 20, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 21, 2013 1:25 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your feedback. Enjoy you plants!"

Positive bubba1972
(1 review)
On May 4, 2013, bubba1972 Oliver Springs, TN wrote:

ordered 500 strawberry plants just try out the company got them quicker than quoted planted in a stacker type hydroponic system 490 roots are doing very well 10 did not make it but very pleased will be ordering 3000 roots next year

On May 4, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 8, 2013 12:09 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your post and enjoy those strawberries!"

Positive SLUGO
(3 reviews)
On Apr 26, 2013, SLUGO Joplin, MO wrote:

Over the last 3 years I have ordered fruit trees, blackberries, raspberries, and vegetable seed from Gurneys. I have received everything that I ordered in good condition, at the right time to plant it. I had one tree that did not live and it was quickly replaced with a hardier tree than the original, no questions asked.
I will continue to do business with this company!

On Apr 26, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 2, 2013 1:32 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your feedback. Enjoy!"

Positive fanofherky
(4 reviews)
On Apr 15, 2013, fanofherky Oakland, IA wrote:

I ordered two blueberry plants. Order was verified at time of placement with estimated shipping date. I was reminded of the shipping date several times. Upon shipment, I was again advised of arrival time. Plants arrived on time and in excellent condition.

On Apr 15, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Apr 17, 2013 2:07 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for posting. Enjoy your berries."

Positive virginiarose
(61 reviews)
On Mar 26, 2013, virginiarose Southeast, VA (Zone 8a) wrote:

I have been ordering from Gurneys for several years and have never had any real problems. I like to take advantage of the half off coupons in spring and blowout specials in the fall. I have gotten lots of shrubs like Butterfly bush and Blueberry bushes some as low as 3.00 each and they were a pretty good size for 3.00.
This year I got three Peonies which were reasonable price for Peonies and all three came to 51.00 and I used my 25.00 coupon so basically I got three nice peonies for 26.00 plus shipping. I was very happy with the bargain I got and the communication was better than ever. I got emails every step of the way letting me know what was going on and when I could expect my plants. The last one came today and it was a very healthy root like the others and I am happy with my purchase, I have always been happy with my purchases from this company. :)

On Mar 26, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Mar 28, 2013 12:11 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

We really appreciate you posting your experience with our company. Send us some pictures sometime if you have a chance. Happy Gardening!"

Positive AmandaDalton
(1 review)
On Mar 5, 2013, AmandaDalton Piedmont, SC wrote:

I have ordered from gurneys yearly for four years. Whenever a product doesn't live they always replace it with no cost to me( no shipping charges or anything) I have only had two plants not make it in all that I have ordered. And I have ordered a lot. They are excellent in their shipping lengths especially if you order early and always have great sale coupons. Their catalogs are accurate and they always send what they advertise. Great company! I will continue to order lifelong from this company. I love that they are so errorless they are able to offer a lifetime gaurentee on their products.

On Mar 5, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Mar 14, 2013 10:39 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your feedback, we appreciate your comments. Happy Gardening!"

Positive dp4A0401
(5 reviews)
On Mar 2, 2013, dp4A0401 Xenia, OH wrote:

Last year I ordered some nursery stock from Gurney's. I ordered bush cherries (which came in a group of 3) and aronia (a native berry bush). The plants looked healthy when received, and grew well initially although I may have lost 2 bush cherries after the Summer's drought. I also ordered deeply discounted late season 3 gooseberries and 4 aronias. I was only shipped two gooseberries, but the (overseas) call center refunded the cost of the missing gooseberrry without hassle. Unfortunately, neither one of the gooseberries appeared to have made it (likely due to the drought), but the aronia did fine (even one I accidently mowed down). This year, I ordered more bush cherries and some currants when they had their 50% off 1 day sale. Overall, I don't expect 100% yield on mail order nursery stock, especially when it's low cost, so my persepctive is generally positive.

On Mar 2, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Mar 14, 2013 10:38 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for sharing. We really appreciate your feedback about how are plants are doing. If you have any problems please let us know and we will be happy to take care of it for you."

Positive grandmawa
(1 review)
On Feb 19, 2013, grandmawa Warsaw, IN wrote:

Have dealt with this company on and off for years. Customer service went through an awful period (reps that knew nothing about plants and/or were not english-speaking) but the last time we talked to them the rep was one of the most expert gardeners I've met and offered great tips for success. Anyway, had to write about the flat wonderful peach. We planted one in 2011 and almost killed it (our fault - Spring was too wet and we should've planted it in a container first, not directly in the ground) Somehow it survived that year and came back last year and went nuts. It's huge and a gorgeous tree. Didn't fruit last year, but we lost all our fruit to the March warmth/April freeze. Can't wait till this year - weather permitting - to see what this tree gives us. If we had it to do all over again I'd plant just these flat wonderfuls instead of all our other peaches! Buy this tree!!!!

On Feb 19, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Mar 14, 2013 10:24 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you so much for your testimonial, we appreciate you sharing your experience with us."

Positive lostinthejungle
(2 reviews)
On Jan 4, 2013, lostinthejungle College Station, TX wrote:

I use the coupon for ordering seeds one to two times a year, and have done this for many years. I start my seeds indoors in winter and transplant in the spring, and then repeat in the summer for fall planting in a quarter acre area.

I order many varieties of vegetable seeds and have never had problems. I've ordered mixtures and hybrids of veggies as well and have been pleased with the variety I've received in each package. As far as seed counts go, Gurney's has never shorted me on seeds - when a package says 25, I usually find 30 or more in the package.

It is worth mentioning that I've had excellent luck with their artichoke seeds. All germinated at 100% without any special planting methods or soaking before hand - all have grown into lovely (and large) plants.

I have ordered bareroots/live plants from time to time and have never had a loss. Many of the perennials exceeded my expectations by the second spring. However I prefer to buy my live plants locally because I personally don't like to wait for plants to be sent to me only at certain times of the year. That is just my personal gardening preference.

For anyone wanting to plant vegetable seed in large volume for personal consumption or canning, you will not be disappointed in the germination rate with Gurney seeds. The bareroot plants they send are young and just starting out - perfect for transplanting (once you understand the special care that goes into planting/growing plants from bareroot).

I've always received seeds within 7-10 business days of ordering with only one package of eggplant being backordered in all of the years I've been shopping at Gurney's. I've learned that live plants should be ordered many months in advance of what your shipping time is due to the occasional backorder and what you order in January might not be delivered until the fall - but that is common with most plant catalog companies.

For someone who gardens on a large scale for personal use, I am satisfied with the germination rate to $ ratio of seeds and plant quality. I will continue to shop with Gurney's in the future.

On Jan 4, 2013, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Jan 16, 2013 2:55 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you so much for your wonderful feedback concerning our company. We truly appreciate you as a customer and look forward to serving you for many years to come."

Positive djediger
(1 review)
On Dec 14, 2012, djediger PEYTON, CO wrote:

I have ordered shrubs, berry plants, decorative grasses, fruit trees, asparagus, and garden seeds from Gurneys 1-2 times per year for about ten years. My plants and seeds grow and have been vigorous and productive. Gardening is difficult in Colorado to say the least and Gurneys seeds/plants perform wonderfully. Service has been amazing and they have been very helpful in the rare situations I have encountered minor problems.

Positive camalianus
(5 reviews)
On Nov 5, 2012, camalianus Sand Lake, MI wrote:

Posted on October 30, 2012, updated November 5, 2012
I bought some packages of different varieties of seedless watermelon. I got my order on time. Unfortunately only few seeds germinated and those which did weren't seedless.
The cucumber seeds did germinate, however neither one of them looked like the pictures in the catalog.

On November 5th, 2012, camalianus changed the rating from neutral to positive and added the following:

I would like to change my rating to positive because the sweet potatoes were excellent. I order 12 Georgia and 12 Beaugregard. Only 1 failed to grow. The rest produced an abundant crop. Some are huge. Their customer service already contacted me saying they will replace the seed packages. Just the fact the customer service did answer is a move in the right direction.
On Nov 5, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Nov 2, 2012 9:35 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your posting. We will be happy to reship the seeds to you. One of our customer service representatives will contact you for your account information."

Positive greenbrain
(9 reviews)
On Oct 30, 2012, greenbrain Madison, IL (Zone 6b) wrote:

Posted on September 4, 2007, updated October 30, 2012
I've been ordering vegie seeds and small fruit from Gurney's for at least 25 years. I've always had a good experience ordering from this company and was surprised to read all the negative reviews. The substitution of cuke seeds had me a bit ruffled Spring of 2006, but I tried the seeds & found them to be superior to the variety that I had requested. Not only that, but I wasn't charged for the substitution. I'm sad to read that others have not been as pleased dealing with this company. I hope that Gurney's is able to turn things around.

On October 30th, 2012, greenbrain added the following:

I've been ordering from Gurney for years & have had a good experience with flower & veggie seeds, onion & garlic bulbs, & small fruit stock. My most recent order was filled timely & accurately. I'll order again next year.
On Oct 30, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Oct 31, 2012 11:12 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you very much for your feedback. We always appreciate what our customers have to say about our service and our products."

Positive JaGo
(1 review)
On Jun 11, 2012, JaGo Skokie, IL wrote:

I have dealt with this company may times over the years and had only two problems. 1. They ran out of stock on an order and promptly issued a credit. 2. They recently shipped some grape vines close to the end of the shipping season. Unfortunately, probably due to the heat spell, they were not viable. After explaining what happened, they have put me on the shipping schedule for next spring season to complete the order. No muss, no fuss, no arguments. Just good customer service.

On Jun 11, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Jun 12, 2012 10:36 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you so much for sharing your experience with us. We really do try our best to make sure our customers are happy and taken care of."

Positive Scotty16
(1 review)
On May 24, 2012, Scotty16 Mechanicsville, VA wrote:

I have several acres of land and decided to start an orchard last year. I went to a local nursery and purchased about 20 very expensive trees. We have apparently lost 8 so far.

That being said I figured I would try the online route. Ordered from Gurneys and am glad I did! Placed order the first week of March and received trees less than two weeks later. The packaging was great, all the roots were still very moist. This was my first bare root purchase, I followed the directions from their website for planting and as of today all the trees are full of leaves and doing great. Here are the items I ordered:

Order Number: 20621713100
Order Date: 03/02/12
Qty Ordered Item Number Item Description Delivery Estimate

4 08514 AMERICAN PERSIMMON 18-24" 03/16/12-04/06/12
4 08708 PECAN HARDY 1-1 1/2' 03/16/12-04/06/12
3 68045 PEAR OLYMPIC GIANT STD 2-4' 03/16/12-04/06/12
2 68048 PLUM ALDERMAN STD 2-4' 03/16/12-04/06/12
4 12984 APPLE SWEET SIXTEEN STD 2-4' 03/16/12-04/06/12
4 08432 PLUM STANLEY STD 2-4' 03/16/12-04/06/12
2 72500 CARMINE JEWEL DWARF CHERRY 04/29/12-05/20/12
2 65804 PEAR HONEYSWEET STD 2-4' 03/16/12-04/06/12
2 13133 PRUNUS NATIVE PLUM 2-3' 03/16/12-04/06/12

I was notified when the shipment was sent out. I am very pleased with this purchase!! We will buy more next year. I own a small company myself and I find that for every 100 satisfied customers 1 or 2 will slip through a crack. That being said I am sure this company does a large volume of sales, and sometimes things just go wrong. I say give them a shot.

On May 24, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On Jun 1, 2012 1:46 PM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you very much! Enjoy and Happy Gardening."

Positive trjonas
(2 reviews)
On May 19, 2012, trjonas Charlotte, NC wrote:

This review compares my experiences ordering from Gurneys and White Flower Farms. (I'll also post this review under White Flower Farms on this website.) I had positive experiences with both companies.


I ordered one raspberry variety from Gurneys, and one from White Flower Farms. The raspberry bush from Gurney's sprouted right away and is doing marvelously. The raspberry bush from White Flower Farm took a few weeks but is beginning to sprout leaves now.


I wanted to try three different heirloom tomato plants this year and wanted to be able to choose each variety. Gurneys didn't offer such an option so I ordered from White Flower Farms.

Unfortunately the plants arrived about a week before I could plant them (impossible to plan since they just say the plants will be sent at the right time - no specific date), so I followed the instructions on what to do with the plants in the meantime.

Two did just fine and are now flourishing in the garden. One went rapidly downhill while still in its pot and by the time I knelt down to plant it, it literally came apart in my hand. I called the company and asked if I could split the cost of a replacement plant with them since it wasn't their fault I couldn't plant it right away, but they wouldn't hear of it; they sent me a new plant at no charge, and it arrived in perfect shape and is now flourishing in the garden.


I ordered four strong tomato cages from Gurneys (they only come in sets of two) and though they were quite a bit pricier than your average tomato cage, they're also *quite* a bit sturdier than your average tomato cage. They look great and were worth the extra cost.


I ordered tomato and raspberry food along with a tomato blossom rot prevention product from Gurneys, and they arrived promptly as did the other items in my order. It's too early to say how they'll perform, though.


I ordered zucchini and summer squash plants from White Flower Farms, and a winter spaghetti squash seed packet from Gurney. (A plant wasn't available.) The zucchini plant arrived broken in a box with other plants that were perfect, and White Flower Farms immediately sent out a replacement free of charge. It and the summer squash are both doing great. The winter squash is also doing great; it germinated and grew faster than I would have thought possible.


I ordered a yellow pepper plant from White Flower Farms. It arrived quickly and in perfect condition, and is flourishing in the garden.


I ordered sweet potato plants from Gurneys. They were the last to arrive of my order but they kept me informed so I wasn't left wondering. Of the 12 plants, a few were quite vigorous and a few were almost dead. I planted them all and so far about 9 appear to be healthy. They haven't been in the ground long, though, so the others could still come back.


Here my experience differs between Gurneys and White Flower Farms quite a bit. I wanted to order plants but in many cases they weren't available, and so I had to order seeds instead. This was the case with green onions, too, which I ordered as seeds. These were my orders:


- French tarragon plant
- Green onion seeds
- Basil seeds
- Dill seeds

White Flower Farms:

- Oregano plant
- Thyme plant

White Flower Farms: the oregano and thyme arrived in perfect condition and are doing great.

Gurneys: my order arrived quickly. The French tarragon plant didn't look all that strong, but I figured once it was in the ground it would perk up. It didn't; instead, it weakened every day until it was dead despite special care and attention. I bought a new tarragon plant at a local nursery to replace it. The seeds were even worse. The basil and dill seeds failed to come up at all, and I planted *many* of the seeds. (And I did follow the instructions!) After 3 weeks I finally dug some of the basil seeds up to see if there was any activity, and there was none. Just dead seeds. Of 12 green onion seeds, only 3 came up. I looked at the packets and there were no dates, so I wonder if I was sent seeds that were years old, especially when I compare how fast the winter squash seeds from Gurneys came up. So, I bought herb plants at a local nursery to replace the Gurneys no-shows.

White Flower Farms herb score: 100%
Gurneys herb score: 0%

That said, I didn't call Gurneys to ask them to replace the plants, as I was at the local nursery with my husband anyway and it was easier and quicker to just buy the plants there. Gurneys may have gladly replaced the plants if it had known of my experience.

Overall my experience was positive and I would order from both companies again. I did feel White Flower Farms had an edge in that I felt like I was dealing with a smaller business and real human beings more so than with Gurneys, and they also had more live plants in the fruits and vegetables I wanted (rather than seeds), but on the plus side, Gurneys offered better specials and they sell some nice extra items like the strong tomato cages.

On May 19, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 22, 2012 9:02 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you very much for your posting. We appreciate you letting us know about your experience with our company. Happy Gardening!"

Positive jjr149
(4 reviews)
On May 5, 2012, jjr149 Shiloh, PA wrote:

I am a first time customer of Gurneys, and have been completely satisfied with my experience with them. Specifically, I completed two separate orders, one for flowers/shrub and the other for raspberries/blackberries:
I received these items in well-packaged boxes, with good instructions on what to do. Some were bare-root, some were in small pots, all were completely healthy. In fact, I have had 100% success with these plants, despite some late frosts in PA. The Weigela plant was stunted by the frost, but I have observed new growth in the last couple of days. Also, the Black-eyed susans have just started growing despite being planted about a month ago. All others have taken root in my soil and are growing quite nicely!
Also ordered HERITAGE RASPBERRY, CAROLINE RASPBERRY (x2), JEWEL RASPBERRY, ARAPAHO BLACKBERRY, OUACHITA BLACKBERRY AND APACHE BALCKBERRY. It took about 5 weeks since I planted them, but they are all showing a break in dormancy with either growth on the cane or root suckers. Again, 100% success with these canes. I followed their directions and also did my own research on how to prepare the soil in order to make sure the plants got off to a good start.
My orders were shipped in a timely manner, and Gurneys sent me emails to update when my orders were shipped. To me, they seem to be a well-run mail order firm that can absolutely be trusted. Thank you Gurneys!

On May 5, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 10, 2012 10:01 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for sharing. Enjoy your plants."

Positive champcooper
(5 reviews)
On Apr 29, 2012, champcooper Houston, TX wrote:

Ordered from this company last year successfully and decided to try them again. Was not disappointed, the 4 Indian Pinks I ordered were well packed in the cardboard tubes and looked great. all are planted and doing well (3 days later). My only negative is the length of time for delivery, I ordered in early March and they just arrived here in Tx, almost 2 months later. We had a very warm winter and these could have been in the ground for weeks. Otherwise a very affirmative positive for Gurneys.

On Apr 29, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 3, 2012 10:06 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your posting. We apologize it took so long to receive your order. When shipping our plants we follow the guidelines set up by the USDA and ship at the proper planting time for your zone based on availability,"

Positive Kennethd
(7 reviews)
On Apr 26, 2012, Kennethd Killeen, TX wrote:

I ordered one Blue Angle Climbing Rose. I usually do my research prior to ordering anything online since I have been ripped off in the past. I was looking for a specific rose which this company had. I read the reviews and I would not have ordered from them do to the ratings, but I really needed this specific rose so I figured I'll order it. Whats the worst that could happen? I would lose 20 bucks. So, I ordered not expecting too much. I ordered on the 16th of April and the rose arrived on the 24th, well packaged and alive. I am very pleased so far with this company. I planted it and I will keep you updated with the progress of its growth. Ordering any type of live plant online is always a crap shoot at best. There are so many things that can go wrong prior to being delivered. The company should always take the extra steps to make sure the plant has the best chance to survive the harsh conditions of being mailed. Thank you for the rose.

On Apr 26, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 3, 2012 10:38 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your posting and enjoy your rose. If you need anything at all just let us know, we are always happy to help."

Positive T_Kezar
(4 reviews)
On Apr 19, 2012, T_Kezar Cape Porpoise, ME wrote:

Posted on May 28, 2011, updated April 19, 2012
Posted on May 16, 2011, updated May 28, 2011
Posted on May 15, 2011, updated May 16, 2011
This was my first year ordering something from an on-line nursery, and i decided to go with Gurneys. I placed a rather large order ($192) that consisted of many things. all the seeds were shipped/received on time and in good shape as were most of the bare root items i bought. however the 2 chandlers i ordered (item#75479) showed up to early and all leafed out. We had 2 cold nights about 1 week after I got them and they are dead. I also ordered a bunch of raspberries and blackberries and while most are doing well 1 candy red(item#80900) 1 mammoth red(item#80892) and 1 chickasaw blackberry (item#80887) did not survive and are now dead and lifeless(they didn't look all that great even by bare root standards when i got them). I will change this to positive depending on gurneys handling of my situation. i am satisfied 100% with all the other products from gurneys accept my dead plants i got. i waited awhile before posting this to make sure their was going to be no new growth on said dead plants.

On May 16th, 2011, T_Kezar changed the rating from neutral to positive and added the following:

i have been contacted by Donna from Gurneys, and have been offered replacements for the few bare rooted plants that didn't do well. Not only was she friendly and professional, but she responded quickly and obviously cares about their reputation. After reading a lot of the reviews i must state that i don't believe they deserve the bad rep they have been given by a lot of the reviewers. I haven not yet gotten the confirmation on the replacement shipment yet but i trust its in good hands. Even if they do make a mistake i know they will go out of their way to fix it. i will update when i get confirmation on the reshipment
On May 28th, 2011, T_Kezar added the following:

i received the first part of my replacements 4 days ago . was the chickasaw blackberry, while there was almost 0 root on this new blackberry it seems to be doing well. wont know for a few more weeks, but i think she will be good. the rest of my replacement items are out-of-stalk for the summer and i will get them this fall. also the 2 chandlers i planted that came way to early and went threw 2 frosts (with all there leaves already out) have started to throw up new growth from the ground(all stems above ground are dead) . so in all good faith i cannot ask for replacements for the 2 blueberry bushes. I WILL BUY FROM THEM AGAIN
On April 19th, 2012, T_Kezar added the following:

everything is green and happy . just got the last 2 red raspberry replacements today and upon their arrival i promptly ordered 30 asparagus crowns (2nd yr heavy) . looking forward to their arrival. im sure gurneys wont disappoint
On Apr 19, 2012, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

"On May 16, 2011 11:06 AM, Gurney's Seed & Nursery responded with:

Thank you for your feedback. We will be happy to reship the plants that did not do well for you. A customer service representative will be contacing you for you account informtion."

Positive Rhizomes123
(5 reviews)
On Apr 15, 2012, Rhizomes123 Pittsburgh, PA wrote:

I received a catalog in the mail with a coupon on it for $25.00 towards anything in the catalog. I usually throw all of their catalogs in the garbage because of a bad experience that I had with them in the past. Years ago I ordered from them. Weeks passed, months passed and I never got my plants or an email explaining the delay. It was a horrible experience because I have been ordering from Gurney since the mid 1970's. They did apologize (that's all) but I was very, very angry because of missing the beginning of the gardening season. So to get back to my review, since anything that I ordered would be free, I decided to give them another chance. I had nothing to lose. I ordered a Meyer Lemon tree and artichoke seeds. I received the artichoke seeds very quickly and an invoice stating when the Meyer Lemon tree would be shipped (invoice shipping time was around March 12th). The tree was shipped right on time and was in good condition. As i am typing this review, the lemon tree is still healthy and thriving. The artichoke seeds are growing very well and are healthy. Everything was FREE to me like they advertised in the catalog. I have nothing to complain about. Although I am reluctant to place a large order with them, I am satisfied with the service that I got when placing this particular order.

Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... 8 Next »

We recommend Firefox
Overwhelmed? There's a lot to see here. Try starting at our homepage.

[ Home | About | Advertise | Media Kit | Mission | Featured Companies | Submit an Article | Terms of Use | Tour | Rules | Privacy Policy | Contact Us ]

Back to the top

Copyright © 2000-2015 Dave's Garden, an Internet Brands company. All Rights Reserved.

Hope for America