I was excited to get my daylillies, and plant them. I agree, they are a wonderful size at shipment. However, they just haven't grown as big as I expected, and as big as the catalog states. I know they have only been in the ground for 2 months, so I am going to give them the benefit of the doubt, which is why I am rating "neutral". I also ordered from Bluestone Perennials, and that daylilly has bloomed before the Oakes, and even though it was much much smaller at shipment, it is now taller than the Oakes ones. Hopefully with a full growing season, next spring will bring better results. Yes, I have been watering, they are in full sun, and I have used a fertilizer on them. Pandora's box bloomed yesterday, but I have yet to see scapes come up from the other 2. Hopefully I will see results soon, or at least have the greens grow taller!