Photo by Melody

Comments regarding National Arbor Day Foundation

Click here to return to National Arbor Day Foundation's listing.

You are viewing only negative comments

  Feedback History and Summary  
64 positives
26 neutrals
64 negatives

Comments:

Page 1 | 2 Next »

RatingAuthorContent
Negative David1977
(1 review)
On Mar 2, 2014, David1977 Lexington, SC wrote:

I joined the foundation because I love plants. Even sent the foundation $20 dollars so that I could get the 'free' plants they were offering. What happened, nothing!! Did not get any plants but I did get the offer to send them more money. This foundation is BS!! Do not join! Do not send money!

Negative Wazimd
(1 review)
On Feb 14, 2014, Wazimd Lawrenceville, GA wrote:

About 6 years ago I joined, the Arbor Day Foundation. I was very excited and bought several trees including 2 Sweet Cherry Trees (Bing and Black Tartarian). After a few years they were 8 feet tall with a 4 feet spread, they gave flowers but did not give me any fruits for a few years. I decided to wait a few more years, got a few really tiny berries one year and then the same the year after that.

Never found out what kind of tree it was, but I know one thing it was not a Bing Cherry. So I cut them down and used them for fire wood. Sorry I had to wait so long to find out that this company was running a SCAM!!!

Negative clj422
(1 review)
On Dec 1, 2013, clj422 Parkersburg, WV wrote:

got my trees yesterday. of course ground is frozen and there is snow on the ground. shouldn't the arbor day foundation know this is not the time for planting trees?

Negative NotFree
(1 review)
On Aug 9, 2013, NotFree wrote:

I just received an offer from the Arbor Day Organization that promises me I will get "free" trees for completing a survey. After reading the offer more closely, I could see that I needed to make a donation of at least $10.00 in order to get the trees. They tried to disguise their offer by saying I could redeem "free vouchers". I would have been more likely to send them the money if they had just been honest about their offer. The trees can't be "free" when getting them requires a donation. Why couldn't they just say that they were giving me the opportunity to purchase some trees for a small price? I bet that the survey is a meaningless part of the offer and they aren't interested in my opinions about trees. They just want my money.

Negative BlackDogKurt
(22 reviews)
On May 29, 2013, BlackDogKurt Seymour, CT wrote:

I placed an order for several trees and also for a one-year membership last month. The price can't be beat but in reality, the chances of receiving viable trees is 50-50 at best. Several of the deciduous trees I received had no sign of any life (despite being mid May). The hemlocks I ordered were devoid of a single needle on any of their small branches and were obviously dead. Some of the other trees appeared to have some buds and may yet survive.

I had joined Arbor Day and paid for a one-year membership a few years ago too. At the time, I merely took advantage of the "10 free trees" that they always offer with membership. Of the 10 small twigs they sent back then, about half never showed any signs of life. A few others died almost immediately. Three actually survived. I didn't even bother ordering the 10 free trees offered with my membership this time, opting instead to order from their catalog instead. However, I don't think I will bother with them again though.

Negative Citro
(10 reviews)
On May 12, 2013, Citro Eden, MD wrote:

Sure wish I had read the reviews first! All ten free trees, dead. Both Apricot trees, dead. Both apple trees remain under 3 feet after 5 years. Forsythias so small that I ran over them with a push mower, never seeing them. All cedars, dead. Red maple, dead.
I thought I was helping a non profit so I placed a large order. Big mistake.

Negative Zafak
(6 reviews)
On May 10, 2013, Zafak Oakbrook, KY wrote:

I joined them last year and received a bag of 10 moldy sticks with some anaerobic mud at the bottom of the bag. I didn't care about that, I joined them to help their cause, not get free stuff. Once they got my address, they started sending me a ton of junk mail asking for more money. If they planted 10 trees in my name, they must have killed 15 others to get the paper to send me junk mail. It appears that they also gave my address to two other places that also want $10 donations for free junk. One was to save wolves, the other one was to save the rain forests.

Later, I joined their $20 hazelnut program and received three twigs, the tallest of which was 3 inches high. The nuts were still attached to the small twigs but were growing green mold. In fact, the whole inside of the bag was green mold with roots and three tiny sticks poking out. When I tried to lift the hazelnut twigs out of the bag, two of them just desentigrated. The third one has grown more mold and shown no signs of plant growth.

Negative unhappyarborday
(1 review)
On Apr 21, 2013, unhappyarborday Bristol, VA wrote:

I placed an order with Arbor Day. I called within 10 minutes after I placed the order because I was going to be out of town so I wanted to make sure I would be home when my plants arrived. I was told there was no way I would know when my plants arrived and I also would not receive any type of confirmation when my plants would be were shipped. Since I probably would not be home when my plants arrived, I cancel my order. My credit card has now been charged and it looks like it is going to be a REAL PROBLEM to get my refund (esp. the membership fee), which I never plan on using, or recommending Arbor Day to anyone. Since they won't work with their customer on when the plants arrive, I really wonder if they really care about the plants. It appears the only thing they care about is getting your money.

Negative BirdyNumNums
(1 review)
On Dec 27, 2012, BirdyNumNums Eagle, NE wrote:

I 100% know for a fact that the Arbor Day Foundation has its own employees write positive reviews on Dave's Garden. I was told by the employees themselves. The ADF is SHADY! Nature Explore and the ADF have questionable dealings. Nature Explore actually has a church writing checks to their contractors. The IRS needs to look into both orgs.

Negative mgkd
(1 review)
On Dec 26, 2012, mgkd Portland, OR wrote:

I just received an Arbor Day Foundation Tree Survey. I decided to look up that CEO's [Chief Executive's] salary: $380,164. The junk mail solicitation letter was "signed":
John Rosenow
Chief Executive

Negative shalomkjg
(2 reviews)
On Jul 7, 2012, shalomkjg Olympia, WA wrote:

I am sad to say I am also extremely displeased with this company, the service, and the hazelnut trees program. I am a novice gardener, but doing quite well overall, especially with my 4 other hazelnut trees bought locally. I am also successfully self propogating lilacs and mock orange, etc. Hazelnuts are somewhat hardy, tough trees, well usually. I live in the Pacific Northwest, hazelnut capital, so they tend to thrive here. However, Arbor day could not tell me when they shipped, just a general idea, but the three tree twigs were in the mail for at least 2 weeks from what I understood (I waited 6 months for them due to the ship date). I then received 8 inch thin, sickly twigs with white mold/fungicide/ or something on them. They were alive at the time so I planted them same day/time received and in a great location, well draining, not too deeply planted, not too shallow, etc. and they died (no green on the stem if rubbed) within a month, no leaves, etc. Customer service was polite but would not refund my money or send a replacement when I called to see what they intended to do, basically they said,"Thank you for the donation." They did not reply to my two emails as well with the questions, concerns, and complaint about the trees. I do not plan to purchase from Arbor Day Foundation again nor recommend them to others....

Negative a1spec
(1 review)
On May 31, 2012, a1spec Sutton, MA wrote:

I stupidly order trees from this org. several times. Fool me once.....The 1st batch of trees included "paper birch". I understand that the prices are low but if you sell yourself as people trying to introduce more trees into the world, and experts, shouldnt you know hat you are selling? They sold me 10 twigs which I nursed and fussed over and spent $$$ & time on and they are not paper birch. They are some variety of birch but they are nowhere near white. This is 5 years down the road, the twigs are now 12' tall with dark brown bark. of ~ 25 conifer I bought maybe 3 are alive. Lastly I bought 3 eastern Redbuds - I got twigs with NO ROOT BALL - NONE. 1 root like someone yanked it out of the ground and threw it in the box.

Their resolution is to send me more twigs - which I do not feel compensates me. I spent time & $$ and could have gone in other directions if they kept their end of the deal. I think they are all about a few people at the top lining their pockets while they, and I have no proof of this, probably get Agriculture students to work for nothing.

I would not buy anything from them. They cannot be trusted. The vast majority of thier trees are non viable.

Negative Everfreeflora
(1 review)
On May 5, 2012, Everfreeflora Blackfoot, ID wrote:

Im not sure this organization(company) truly cares for its cause. I donated last year and got the 10 free twigs, i wasent expencting anything amazing as it was just a donation, but none of them lived, i wasn't upset or anything since it was only $10 and i didnt have room for that many trees to begin with. However i recently placed an order for two japanese cherry trees with them since the National Cherry Blossom Festival had them listed as their prime source for people wanting to have their own... i received one of the two today, about 3 feet long with spinly hairs for "roots", now unfortunaly for me i don't forsee this taking off to a wonderful start with suck lackluster roots on a brance this size. I would completely recomend you use a more competent nursery for your tree needs, one wich will make sure their plants are well rooted before they send them to you, one that actually cares for their image and the fate of their plants.

Negative caterino1
(6 reviews)
On Apr 10, 2012, caterino1 Newburgh, NY wrote:

donated to this foundation and just received my ten free moldy, smelly trees. This is the last time I will have any kind of dealings with them. Last year I bought trees from them and all I have to show for it are a few sticks, they did nothing but sit there last year, no growth, just sticks, I have been a member for a few years now, but no more. To whoever reads this don't waste your time or money

Negative sideeous
(1 review)
On Mar 19, 2012, sideeous Claremore, OK wrote:

I bought a membership, for $10.00, then went head over heels and trusted the foundation, bought $800.00 in northern privets to make a hedge wall around my property, everyone of the 400 plants i bought were small and had very small roots, i planted them in early March, they said the hedges grew 3-6' per year, a year later they are the same size as when i planted them, about a third of them died, the other two thirds grow leaves but have not expanded at all, they are the same twigs sent to me when i planted them only they have some leaves on them. False advertising probable, and the size of some of these hedges are really a joke, they also shorted me around 30 of them had to have them send me the other 30 or so. They sent me some crepe myrtles to replace the third that died in December when i asked them to send them to me in the spring. I went ahead and planted them and they aren't doing anything 3 months later not even a bud. I would avoid these "foundations" they are only fronts for the super rich to hide their wealth in, and don't really care that i spent $800 dollars on them, they said after sending the crype mrytles that dont do anything it was all they could do. Sorry company "foundation" whatever.

Negative lazybear
(1 review)
On Aug 25, 2011, lazybear Redmond, WA wrote:

The Arbor Day Foundation is a nonprofit that sells retail seedlings by mail. The foundations only objective is to sell more trees and memberships. This company should be paying taxes like other for-profit retailers because the ADF is no charity. I'm going to request an inquiry from the Commerce Department in to their shady business.

I bought trees from the ADF and most of them lived. I'm really soured by the way the ADF has disrespected me as a customer with loads of junk mail, and sending membership renewal notices every other month after I purchased a year of membership in exchange for trees.

Don't give these dodgy people your address, unless you want a bunch of junk mail asking for money. The surplus nursery stock they liquidate is way overpriced, IMO. But worst, are their business practices, very unethical... After you order, The company continually tries to obtain revenue by deceiving their customers /"members". If you become a member of the "foundation" the company will send you repeated renewal notices by mail asking for more money. I understand they may even try to charge your credit card the membership fee after you don't respond before your membership runs out.

I don't want my money back, I just want this foundation shut down. Capitalism isn't evil, but companies like the National Arbor Day Foundation make it feel that way. -Devin

Negative Dogwood33
(4 reviews)
On Jun 19, 2011, Dogwood33 wrote:

I ordered one dogwood and one japanese red maple. They sent us two trees and both were planted. The Japanese maple died but the other tree prospered and grew and then we realized it was NOT a dogwood but a weeping willow. I didn't want to kill off the tree by removing it but I have to say there is a huge difference between a large water hungry tree like a WW and a dogwood. I called the Arbor Foundation and even emailed and sent pictures of the wrong tree they had sent. Not only did I not receive a response but then they didn't even bother to offer suggestions or even replace it. I would never ever order a tree from them again. They did send a Japanese red maple and its growing in a pot and will have to go out in the ground soon, but like I said I am not very happy with their service. Sending the wrong tree is not acceptable, especially if its in the ground and growing before you even know what it is you planted. I have little trust for them and they have lousy customer service.

Negative Thunderlilies
(3 reviews)
On May 6, 2011, Thunderlilies Battle Creek, MI wrote:

I hate to give a negative because I love what they stand for, but I have not had a good experience with these folks and will no longer be ordering from them.

I have purchased quite a few fruit trees and green giants from them over the last couple of years... and, at this time, all the fruit trees are struggling and not growing. Over half of the baby green giants have died...
Plants I have ordered from other nurseries have flourished in my garden.

When I contacted them about one of my fruit trees that had died I had to pay 1/2 of the cost of the original to get a new tree.

On the other hand, their prices are low, which is great, if you're willing to take that risk. And the free red maple they send with your order grows very well. So, if the rest of your order doesn't do so great, at least you have that red maple tree!

Negative Gwennie76
(1 review)
On May 2, 2011, Gwennie76 Taylor, TX wrote:

I ordered two almond trees from them. After a few years of growth, they are decidedly PEACH trees, not almond trees. Very unhappy.

Negative kathyl0u
(1 review)
On Dec 28, 2010, kathyl0u Corry, PA wrote:

When I sent my $10 "donation" to ADF with the promise of 10 free trees, plus lilac bushes, etc. I didn't expect much, but I did expect some common sense from a foundation that wants to grow healthy plants. Although I sent in late summer/ealry fall the shipment wasn't received till around mid Dec. By then we had 2-4 feet of snow in our yard. We live in the snowbelt. If ADF had done its homework they'd have known that. They claim they'll be shipped at the best time for planting in our area, but Dec. is rarely the best time to plant anything here! We never received the lilac bushes...just as well, I guess. The tiny twigs are still lying out in our back room; no chance to plant them. If ADF really cared about growing things, they wouldn't send the babies to their certain demise by shipping them to a snowy death! Such a shame.

Negative marybe
(1 review)
On Sep 8, 2010, marybe Portland, OR wrote:

I would Avoid this scam at all costs. They tell you the trees are free, but charge you 10 bucks to join...ok, so it turns out what you pay for what you get, a buck a plant, a buck a sick and and paltry plant that is. After 40 years I know what good stock is, and this is not it...and this is the first 100% negative review I've ever given.

Stunted stock that no self respecting nursury would sell. I also made the mistake of ordering a few extra plants...they came dead, and never recovered though they got immedicate and tender care. The few things that did survive were the smallest excuses for nursery stock I've seen in 40 years of mail orders!! Bare none.
And, to top it all off...if you don't watch them, they will renew your "$10 membership" each year without your permission, costing you even more.
To top it 0ff even more, they call themselves a "non-profit", as if they are doing us and the world a favor...well, if the world deserves to get ripped off, by folks selling garbage, and paying no taxes either, they I guess they are right on.
Personally, I stand by my assessment:
AVOID this company, it is dishonest and inept, and doesn't even attempt to approach the quality good gardeners have come to appreciate.

Negative Phrederica_VA
(6 reviews)
On Aug 29, 2010, Phrederica_VA Montpelier, VA wrote:

Sure, they send little twigs that may or may not survive. But the worst part is they always send them at the worst time of year. They claim it is "the best for your area", but June is a terrible time to plant in Virginia! It is not even in their range of when they are supposed to arrive. I read another complaint from someone way up north who got their trees long after the ground was frozen solid.

My theory is that they get the trees at the end of the season from cheap tree sellers at a huge discount. I find it hard to believe that they want people to grow trees when they are so uninterested in the success of their seedlings.

I made the mistake, after receiving half-dead sticks in the heat of June, to order some hazel nut trees. They were beautiful seedlings when they arrived in a timely manner in spring. They looked like they were greenhouse raised, not field raised, and normally I would have carefully hardened them off. But, the directions promised me that the best method was planting them immediately. The first mild frost blasted the bark right off of them.

Negative egardens
(9 reviews)
On Apr 26, 2010, egardens Hutto, TX wrote:

Ordered months in advance, their website lists old shipping dates, follow up e-mail informed me they ship much later to Texas for dormancy and heat window. I was fine with that. I ordered from several suppliers last year. The Arbor day plants I paid for were the worst performers and most are disposed of now. All the free plants did great, crape myrtles, forsythia, and red maple, all the purchased plants did terrible, so I guess we are even as far as the value is concerned (I spent $60 on many plants, got 8 free plants as a bonus and they are all doing fine, while every plant I bought I discarded or is extremely stressed still). I would especially dissuade anyone from purchasing the evergreen seedlings, unless you want to pot them and nurse them back to health (Which Arbor day themselves say it is best not to do).

Negative kentuckywoman2
(1 review)
On Jun 2, 2009, kentuckywoman2 Louisville, KY wrote:

Last spring I gave a $10 contribution for which I was to receive 10 flowering trees and 1 crapemyrtle. I expected the trees to be shipping in the spring or early summer, but by NOVEMBER I still had not received my trees. I called and got no response to my inquiry of "Where are my trees?", so I emailed and finally got a response. However, the response was that since I was in hardiness zone 7, the trees would be shipped in December! First of all, I'm in hardiness zone 6, NOT 7. When I alerted the Arbor Day Foundation to that, they said that they were the ONLY organization to "update" the hardiness zones, and now I was in Zone 7. Then, the customer service gal, Carla, proceeded to tell ME what my weather is like here in Kentucky! I finally escalated the call to speak to her supervisor, who shipped me my trees around the end of November. Unfortunately, we had already had a couple of freezes and since our soil is mainly clay, I had a very difficult time trying to dig deep enough to plant the "twigs" they sent me. Needless to say, THEY ALL DIED. I recently requested a replacement shipment and was told, by the same Carla, that my replacement trees would be shipped in Spring of 2010, unless I wanted them to be shipped in Fall 2009! Unacceptable! Again, the last time they shipped in "Fall", it was actually way past Fall and into Winter. Again, I informed them that their zones were not correct, according to our weather patterns, and again, this Carla proceeded to tell ME what our weather here in Kentucky is like! Finally, I requested a refund of my $10 and I'm now told it will take about 3-4 weeks. At least that's faster than they ship their "twigs." I have been a member since 2003 and this Carla person was the last straw. She's rude and arrogant and if she's the best they can do to represent their customer service department, then they have a real problem. In any case, I'll do my tree and shrub buying from a local nursery. I'll not do business with the Arbor Day Foundation again. They are clueless. Absolutely clueless.

Negative jbarton7
(1 review)
On Jun 1, 2009, jbarton7 Arvada, CO wrote:

I gave a donation to the Arbor Day Foundation over three months ago with the promise from them that I would received 8 free trees and a lilac bush. I have yet to recieve them. I don't expect to receive something in return for a donation but I do expect an organization to honor its promises and to remit promised goods. I cannot respect a company that uses a bait and switch tactic to suck donations out of people. I can respect a company that does simply ask for a donation and doesn't promise anything to me personally in return, and I can donate to those organizations. All I have received from ADF is more solicitations for money and more (empty I'm sure) promises of goods. As a company, I mean organization, that seems very commercially interested, this is very poor business practice as I will never buy a plant from them and will talk anyone out of it who threatens to do so.

To make things worse, I have been trying to email them about my complaint for over a week now and their website is broken and supposedly being repaired. It makes them seem to be hiding from the complaints.

I have little faith at this point that they are interested in anything that has to do with improving the earth. I am sure the only thing they are interested in is taking as much money as they can get their hands on. And they do not care how unethical their methods are to obtain it.

Negative twettie
(1 review)
On May 11, 2009, twettie Petal, MS wrote:

I sent $20 and got 10 twigs, 7 of which had a hair root on each, and 3 with no roots and the size of a pencil. The seven with the roots were about the same size as a pencil. Of the seven planted a month ago 4 are showing some very small growth on them. I pulled the rest out and their roots had not gained any hairs so I threw them away. I should be dead by the time they are full grown trees. I feel dupped. I could have gone to a tree nursery and got a better deal. I will not order any more trees from this organization, and would advise anyone else not to unless they want to give a donation to an organization that is deceptive about what they really send you.

Negative yardener
(19 reviews)
On Jan 16, 2009, yardener Greenfield, OH (Zone 6a) wrote:

What do you expect for 10 bucks. Over the years its been kind of a hobby for me to see if the sticks will grow into anything. After ordering 40 flowering "sticks" (the last order was 5 years ago) I have 3 Washington Hawthorns and 2 crabapples. Lets see, thats 1 out of 8 that make it to waist height in 10 years. Thats $8 per tree. Still a good bargain? I wouldn't waist my time.
I've had over 85% success rate with better bargains at other tree sources.
If you want a challenge, order from NADF. If you want trees, go somewhere else.

Negative GideonOrchards
(4 reviews)
On Jan 10, 2009, GideonOrchards Springboro, PA wrote:

NADF is the bad result of trying to mix business and charity.

I've ordered from them a couple times over the years.

Currently, they are having a competition with Autumn ridge to see who can sell the smallest twigs and call them "trees" without breaking into maniacal laughter when you call and ask, "um, hello, you sent me a handfull of twigs by mistake, I ordered trees."

I fully expect that the Scarlet Oaks they sell will soon be shipped out in the form of an acorn. It will simplify planting.

Apples and pears I ordered were borderline acceptable. Other trees (cherries and such) were too small.

Folks, it's pretty simple. You'll spend 5 or 10 bucks on the most useless crap, so spend 5 or 10 bucks on a tree that will then produce fruit for you 5 or more years earlier than what this charity/business sells you, and you avoid the aggravation of trying to find your new plantings among the clover and dandelions.

Support the cause with a straight donation - buy your trees elsewhere.

Negative Bethli
(1 review)
On Aug 12, 2008, Bethli Durham, CT wrote:

Buyer Beware! Trees are smaller than a #2 pencil and most won't grow at all. Worst of all this applies to purchased trees not just the 10 free trees that comes with the membership. The trees are so tiny that if they grow at all they need to be planted in a protected garden for at least a year. At the size they arrive it is doubtful that they will be able to survive a winter.

If you want to support the Foundation, do so. Just don't bother to order trees. Save your money for a site with a proven track record.

Negative dkgarber
(1 review)
On May 16, 2008, dkgarber Franklin, MA wrote:

I wasn't expecting much out of the 10 free trees, so when I opened a package of sticks, I wasn't too disappointed, as I figured they'd be crap.

However, I did buy 4 Pee Gee Hydrangeas and was flabbergasted when they arrived in the same condition and size as the free trees. Wait a minute..you mean I paid good money for these?

It's now 2 years later and my Pee Gees are only about a foot tall. I have to mark them with red ribbon each spring or they'd get pulled as "weeds". They are a moderately fast growing tree normally, but mine are about the same size as 2 years ago--they 've sprouteda few branches, but not much.

I just topdressed them w/some humus and cmposted manure to try and boost them up a bit.

I am beyond disappointed. I expected them to be "experts" but was I wrong.

Negative LLCOUTY
(2 reviews)
On May 18, 2007, LLCOUTY Hagerman, NM wrote:

I also got 10 twigs, only one grew, this company is a big JOKE !!

Negative Brian_H
(1 review)
On May 17, 2007, Brian_H Athol, MA wrote:

I placed my order in the fall and planted the day they arrived. By this spring everything had died (approx 10 trees) except for the two free forsythias they sent. Conversely, everything I ordered from Miller's Nursery is doing very well!

Yes the prices on Arbor Day Foundation are cheap, but is the disappointment worth it?

Negative svd
(1 review)
On Apr 14, 2007, svd Adams, TN wrote:

We started a membership with NASF to help landscape our combined business and home property. I heard good comments about them over the years, and looking at their prices figured they were a safe bet. Our 'premium gift' for membership was ten flowering trees. Looking at their catalog, we assumed these 'trees' would be 1-4 foot branched seedlings/saplings. We were disappointed when they arrived today small enough to fit in our mailbox. To make it worse, the mail carrier expressed her sorrow that her 12-years of experience showed this was about the best we could expect from them.

The seedlings were bound in one bundle, non-branched and gel-coated, with an average size of about 8 inches. Basically twigs with a few roots. Our plan was to plant these with our three girls. Instead I dug some quick holes while they were napping as they would have been heart broken to see them. I went to the extent of fencing around them to keep the errant leaf or running squirrel from knocking them flat. It felt like a scene from a Charlie Brown cartoon.

I planted thousands of trees with the Scouts in Washington for lumber company reclamations and with the Forest Service for erosion control. Even those trees which we packed sometimes miles into the mountains were larger and healthier than what Arbor Day 'gives' away for $10 along with a ton of fliers asking you to spend more. The giveaway plants at the local nurseries are at least branched 3 footers - and they are free add-ons to any purchase. A nursery couldn't give away what NASF sent - even without a purchase. Very sad for $30 million a year foundation.

A mistake I'll never make again...

Negative tangaloor
(5 reviews)
On Dec 20, 2006, tangaloor Benton City, WA wrote:

I ordered a starter set of trees (2005) and did not receive them until the ground was too frozen to plant (late December). I potted them to over winter in my garage following instructions, but none survived to the following spring. Won't be ordering from there again. They ship too late for my part of the country.

Negative jacandbug
(1 review)
On Jul 3, 2006, jacandbug Charleston, TN wrote:

I received five trees in December 2005. This spring all but one tree was dead.

Negative rainforestJen
(1 review)
On Apr 24, 2006, rainforestJen London
United Kingdom wrote:

I have not had personal experience, but have read the comments and done a little research as I'm very concerned where my donation's go to. And I'm concerned about this one.

There is a site that keeps track of these guys It's called Capital Research Centre. http://www.capitalresearch.org.

I did a quick compare. It looks like Arbor Days director earns more salary than the director of the Sierra club, the World Wild Life Federation, and the Humane Society (US, not UK) BUT it earns only about 1/4 of what WWF does. Well see for yourself.

In 2003 Arbor had a revenue of $28,418,604, Sierra club a revenue of $51,814,307 and WWF a Revenue of $105,928,516. Yet the president of NADF earned $302,193.00, as opposed to the President of Sierra Club ($167,083.00) and WWF ($214,542.00). A mere manager at NADF earned $94,246.

The president of the Arbor Day earns more then Sierra Club and WWF, yet the organization brings in revenue less than the others.

Links to validate
http://www.capitalresearch.org/search/orgdisplay.asp?Org=NAD...
http://www.capitalresearch.org/search/orgdisplay.asp?Org=WWF...
http://www.capitalresearch.org/search/orgdisplay.asp?Org=HUS...

This Arbor Day has a manager earning almost as much as the CFO of the Sierra Club. Makes you wonder where your donations are going doesn't it?

Again, I've no direct contact, so delete this if you feel it's necessary, but it looks like I'll have no direct contact either.

Jen

Negative Uquea
(1 review)
On Apr 24, 2006, Uquea Mountain Village, AK wrote:

Having at one time a year or so ago, worked with people in this organization I have to say I saw a lot of envolvement with children. I really liked that. So I too donated.

Now I get bombarded with continual requests for more money. Yikes. How many trees died for all the requests for money I've gotten? That doesn't say much for their cause.

Another thing that bothered me was that I never really saw where else any of the donations went to, other than more of thier own programs. They did do that well, promote thier own programs. But I never saw pictures of trees they planted. I never saw any reclaimed or saved rainforest pictures. The web site seemed very commercial (buy buy buy more and more), maybe I missed it but for an ecologically minded organization, they don't seem to do much.

uquea

Negative patmoore49684
(1 review)
On Mar 19, 2006, patmoore49684 Traverse City, MI wrote:

On Aug 30, 2005 I joined the Arbor Day Foundation. I had received an offer to join and receive 10 Colorado Blue Spruce saplings. My wife was looking forward to receiving the trees with great anticipation. Since that time I have received several requests for more donations and offers of a free gift with each offer.

I agree that when you contribute to the foundation you are mainly making a contribution to assist in providing educational materials to others and to assist in providing trees to be planted around the country. Most of the plantings, though, seem to be covered by corporate sponsorships and to be only in the hometowns of these sponsors.

If I had responded to every request for a donation I would have probably donated around a hundred dollars since August and it is only the middle of March.

At this time I still have not received the free Spruce trees.

"Stung once, shame on you; Stung twice shame on me; Stung three times I am a fool." Since I have been stung by the foundation on my first donation I do not feel that I should make anymore donations. The only proof I have that they have used my donation to any good is their newsletter that tells me about the corporate sponsored undertakings about to take place.

By failing to make good on their promise to me they have shown that I cannot rely on the information that they publish.

Negative jbrockettm
(8 reviews)
On Feb 18, 2006, jbrockettm Fort Plain, NY wrote:

Several orders in 2005. Some good and some bad. A few trees I ordered I was pleasantly surprised by. A few were major disappointments. Their ordering and fulfillment system is clearly a disaster given my own experience and that of others on this comment page. I ordered two memberships last spring, one for myself and one for my girlfriend. My free trees came right away and I planted them. I think mostly they are doing fine. My girlfriend's pack, delivered to the same address, for some mysterious reason, was not shipped until fall. I think they will mostly survive too. In the Spring, a few weeks after joining, I ordered 10 oaks. It was still easily cool enough to plant them where I live but they told me it was too late for spring shipping and they would ship them in the fall. In September I ordered some other trees and got them almost right away, planted them fine and they seem to be okay. October came and went, no oaks. November came, Thanksgiving crept up. The day after Thanksgiving, after temperatures had been in the teens for a full week and a foot of snow had fallen here, my oaks showed up at last. I emailed. Reply: "we couldn't ship earlier because of fall heat, but we'll ship you another batch in the spring" (a full year after ordering?). Okay, great, but why did I get all my other trees from them on time? They clearly need some decent software upgrades!


On May 22nd, 2006, jbrockettm changed the rating from neutral to negative and added the following:

Got the white oaks. May 19. In my mailbox. I went to the NADF website. Did I honestly pay $60.00 for these 10 whips??? I've waited a year, and once again they have come LATE. I've already planted over 200 trees this year. They're all fully leafed out. So now I've got these ten tardy whips to deal with and given my experience, it's not worth bothering to plant them, they just won't live.
As for the other trees I've gotten from NADF. None of my girlfriend's 10 free trees made it through the winter. Of 40 seedlings overall that I got last year from this decrepit organization, 1 is still alive. Never again!

Page 1 | 2 Next »


We recommend Firefox
Overwhelmed? There's a lot to see here. Try starting at our homepage.

[ Home | About | Advertise | Media Kit | Mission | Featured Companies | Submit an Article | Terms of Use | Tour | Rules | Privacy Policy | Contact Us ]

Back to the top

Copyright © 2000-2014 Dave's Garden, an Internet Brands company. All Rights Reserved.
 

Hope for America