Irving, TX(Zone 8a)

I just bought this book: Gardening and Planting by the moon 2011, pubblisher Quantum Foulsham.
I started to read and it is a fantastic book and really explains a lot about moon gardening.

My only problem is that the planting dates are not the same of the Farmer's Almanac calendar.
Farmer's Almanac: January 4th-5th Good Days For Planting Aboveground Crops Such As Sweet Corn, Beans And Peppers, In Southern Florida, Texas And California.
Book: January 4th no planting, January 5th plant root vegetables

By this book, the next date for planting above ground crop will be on Janyary 12th, while for the Farmer's Almanac January12th is consider a Barren Day. Do No Planting.

So now I am totally confused !!
Which calendar should I follow ???
I though there was only one moon ... I guess there are many interpretations ??

Please help

Thumbnail by drthor
Lumberton, TX(Zone 8b)

I think the Farmer's Almanac goes by astronomy and the other by astrology. It does make it confusing. I wonder about planting half the seeds one way and the other half the other way and see which trumps.

Irving, TX(Zone 8a)

So now I am really confused !!!
They totaly don't agree whit each other !!

So.App.Mtns., United States(Zone 5b)

There are several methods used in determining moon signs. Some are using our Earth as the center, others ise the sun as the center.

"Biodynamic methods are based on the heliocentric, or astronomical, position of the moon. This system is more complicated and also takes into consideration eclipses, trine, apogee and perigee as well as descending and ascending moons. (The Gardening by the Moon Calendar is based on the geocentric and astrological calculations.)"
that's from my post here

Lumberton, TX(Zone 8b)

I'm about to plant seeds under the grow light I got myself for Christmas, and plan to use the Farmer's Almanac calendar. Maybe I'll plant just a few according to the other and if the results are dramatically different, I'll report. Seeds to go in on the 4th! Then I'll plant a few of the same on the 12th.

This message was edited Jan 2, 2011 12:56 PM

Irving, TX(Zone 8a)

So far I have always used the Farmer's Almanac calendar for planting and did very well.
Thanks Darius, now I understand a little bit more ... still confused !!

So.App.Mtns., United States(Zone 5b)

Hey, it still confuses me even after all this time! I always get geocentric and heliocentric mixed up. I should do a comparison of both systems but it's not high on my list even though I believe Rudolph Steiner was right on about cosmic influences.

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.