It's time to vote on our 2017 photo contest! Vote for your favorite photos of the year here!

Review: 2011 MOON PLANTING guide for gardeners

Irving, TX(Zone 8a)

I just received the "2011 MOON PLANTING guide for gardeners" and I am really impress.
This guide has a colorful calendar with every day of the month with drawings that help you to understand what and when to plant. Also moon signs and other stuff.
It is really easy to understand.
I bought it on Amazon.
You can read the description here:
I think this guide is much more advanced than the Farmer's Almanac and takes in consideration the Zodiac signs.


Thumbnail by drthor
Houston Heights, TX(Zone 9a)

According to your posted link, the guide cost $15 and the shipping is also $15. I think it would be worth it but outside my budget. I hope you will continue to post on the forum. Cam

Irving, TX(Zone 8a)

The link is from the company that makes the guide, which is in Australia.
You need to buy the guide from Amazon, so you will have free shipping.
This guide is a little bit different from the Farmer's Almanac.
It has so much more and I will be following this calendar this year. My friends too.
It is kind of hard to write it down ... so many colorful drawings, moon up and down.
The guide really explain in very easy terminology the "byo-dinamic" culture.
I hope it will help me to deterr those monsters of Squash Vine Borers ... (giggles)

Houston Heights, TX(Zone 9a)

Thanks for the tip. I know my farming ancestors planted by the moon but I bought and almanac and I dont think it was the real thing altho it looked like it. It seemed like more entertainment than real planting information but I am still eager to try the old method so I'm really interested in the book. Thanks, Cam

Pueblo West, CO(Zone 5b)

Mager's is a planting chart based on the Southern Hemisphere and Australian Eastern Standard Time, which I didn't know until I began reading it. The author says to adjust for daylight savings time and different time zones. I have no idea how to do this and to complicate things more, aren't their summers our winters here in the Midwest?

Anyway, I don't think I will use Mager's guide though it is nicely illlustrated and a fairly good explanation of how lunar planting works is included. One thing that puzzles me is that he advises readers to plant fruit and plants producing seed crops in fire signs (barren signs).

Mager's calender seems a lot like the Kimberton Hills Biodynamic Agricultural Planting Guide in theory.

If you are new to lunar gardening (planting by the moon), I highly recommend Divine Inspiration's Gardening By the Moon because it's very simple and straight forward where as the others are not.

Carrollton, TX(Zone 8a)

I received my book for 2011 yesterday and read it this morning while waiting for my DW who was having a surgical procedure. Then I read it again and I'm still not sure I understand it. For those of us not familiar with the zodiac and ecliptics, nodes, trines, etc. it is all very confusing. But being the trooper that I am I will persevere and do my best to follow the calendar and hope good things happen in the garden.

Carrollton, TX(Zone 8a)

Ok, which book is it? I just realized I purchased the "2011 North American Biodynamic Sowing and Planting Calendar (Maria & Matthias Thun), not the "2011 Moon Planting Guide" book. How many books are you touting and how much do you receive for each one that sells based on your recommendation? I feel betrayed as well as broke! (ha!).

If the Moon Planting Guide is easier to understand, I may switch for 2012. I really need a “Moon Planting Guide for Dummies”!

Irving, TX(Zone 8a)

I love the Maria Thun book. That's is what I ended up following.
Don't worry about this ... even if I really like it, Maria's is much better.
I have already pre-ordered in Amazon teh 2012 Maria Thun calendar.

Carrollton, TX(Zone 8a)

Do you know where I can sign up for a class that teaches about the Zodiac and all that is involved? Keep an eye out for that book that I'm looking for, "Planting by the Moon for Dummies".

Irving, TX(Zone 8a)

Actually keep your eyes open on the list of classes at NHG.
The last saturday of each month (apart summer) the Herb Society of Dallas met there and they have fantastic free classes.
One of the member said that she is researching the planting by the moon and soon she will give a lecture.

Plano, TX(Zone 8a)

What is NHG? It sounds interesting, esp since there's no "Dummies" book available. Or can you recommend a starter's guide?

Irving, TX(Zone 8a)

I am glad that you are asking because you are missing the best nursery in town.
NHG = North Haven Garden, check the address here;
Not only it is an amazing nursery with very unusual and colletcors plants, but they have the best FREE education programs in the DFW area.
Check their website under "EVENTS"

Plano, TX(Zone 8a)

Awesome! Thank you! I had a neighbor once who gardened by the moon. He was very nice and a bit kooky, but he always had great success with his vegetable garden. For three years I have tried to grow tomatoes with poor results. Maybe I should give it a try. We are putting in a kitchen garden soon and it could be fun to experiment with this technique. As for my flower beds, I have never been happy with the standard fare available from the local DIY stores. It should be fun to see what they have.
Thanks, Kathy

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.