Looking for a new router

Leesburg, FL(Zone 9b)

MY current router is about 7 yrs old. It's a D-link, which has been very good to me over the yrs.... but i think it's on the fritz.
sometimes someone cant get connected, dropped connections ... so i've started looking for new ones,

Last month i purchased a new Laser printer, and in the instructions for wireless set up, it mentions an AOSS button on a router - which it seems only Buffalo has.

I've looked at various Buffalo routers with many good reviews... BUT when you look at the 1stars, or 1eggs .... you start to lean in the other direction.

So, while on Newegg, i set the filter to Top Reviews .... and again, a lot of great looking routers, but again, each one that is highly rated, there are a low percentage of 1egg reviews.

Is it just a crap shoot when you get one to set up correctly?

I want a Dual Band, N, and 300Mbsp would be nice.

Some have USB ports -- do i really need that? The Buffalo has one where you can connect an external HDD for file sharing - but i've read a few reviews that the set up is a PITA or doesnt work.

I'm just getting confused. I'd like to stay in the 'under $100 ' price range... but if it 's a great unit - I wouldnt mind going to under $150
as if it last 10 yrs, it will be a good deal.

all those bad reviews are just so hard to over look.

any input??


**edited for typos

This message was edited Jan 16, 2011 3:36 PM

Leesburg, FL(Zone 9b)

I think I found one that i like.

I've never had Netgear 'anything' but this one looks promising...

only thing it does not have is gigabit ethernet ports -- but i dont think that is a necessity

dont have them now, and we are mostly wireless now anyways.

I have my tower and i have an extra ethernet cable hooked up at my desk for a laptop if i want to be hardwired.

this one has an on/off switch and a 'wifi on/off' switch. I like both of those options.

and 80bucks. it's the WNDR3400 N600

any input ??

Washington, MO(Zone 6a)

I ditched D-Link years ago for Netgear and haven't looked back. I have both a router and range extender by them, and neither has given me any problems at all. If you can't afford Cisco, then Netgear is the way to go, IMO. =)

Leesburg, FL(Zone 9b)

thanks Eggs.

Leesburg, FL(Zone 9b)

oh, what sort of a difference [on my tower] would a "gigabit" make? the price jump is about 50 bucks.

Washington, MO(Zone 6a)

Beats the heck outta me. I have a 16mb pipe, and get all the speed I'm paying for. I also can't see any need for more throughput. =)

Leesburg, FL(Zone 9b)

I always think to myself... how fast is fast, and how much fast can it get? we have hi-speed 'cable' internet.
my laptop has an "n" card... i think it's good and fast at home. [over the summer it can get really slow because we are on a 'dish'. ] even hardwired it's slow.

so -- i guess i dont need gigbit.

Leesburg, FL(Zone 9b)

I did order the N600 netgear... should be here in a few days. hopefully set up will be a breeze.

Leesburg, FL(Zone 9b)

Set up was a breeze -- would have been seamless if i would have labeled the cables before reconnecting them, as they all were in the wrong order. Probably would have been less than 10 min setup otherwise. Very happy with my purchase.

Washington, MO(Zone 6a)


Powder Springs, GA(Zone 7b)

I bought the Netgear router/modem last year and found it much nicer to have the combo modem/router in one unit - at least this way I only have to power it down if necessary instead of a router and a modem and have one less AC adapter and one less cable (between modem and router), and less desk clutter. Set up was very easy. Thank goodness that AT&T DSL required no calls for set up - just plug it in and let the software determine most of the settings. It is a shame Comcast requires you call them in order to put your new MAC address of the modem in their database to connect.

As for the extra speed, it is only good for two or more computers on the same LAN moving files or massive data between each other and even that will be bottle-necked by the hard disks. Maybe you can back up pictures a bit faster but how much faster? As for accessing the web it makes no difference since the bottle neck is your ISP.

Leesburg, FL(Zone 9b)

since i have phone, cable and TV thru Comcast...i 'have' to use their modem which they very kindly charge me a monthly fee for....
I dont recall Comcast having to come up to do anything... we set it up ourselves [Ok, i did] it was pretty easy. But having 1 box instead of 2 would be nice.

Powder Springs, GA(Zone 7b)

That's because you still have their modem which has the MAC address that is in their database that allows you to access the web! Go and change it out for a combo router/modem and I bet it won't work without a phone call to them (unless they changed in the last year) and then good luck on getting them to act on the first phone call!

Talk about fun! I put a new Motorola Surfboard router/modem (from Best Buy) in on New Year's Eve '09 for my BIL in Nashville, TN. Kept having to call Comcast and getting the royal runaround. Even with a contract in hand with all the right verbiage (or garbage) they kept pushing me off to another department saying you must pay to get on. Gee whiz - what good was the paper contract for? Finally after getting their databases in line with the written contract I had to call again to get them to enter the NEW MAC address (they still had his old MAC address when he was a customer with them five years before! Why he wanted to go back to cable vs. DSL was beyond me after this runaround) No matter who I talked to they couldn't get it through their thick skulls that the new equipment had a new MAC address. Finally after another 30 minutes or longer someone actually listened and put in the new address. Five minutes later we were surfing away happy as pigs in mud!

Post a Reply to this Thread

Please or sign up to post.