Photo by Melody
Our 19th Annual Photo Contest is now open for entries. You can submit your best images HERE

Reviews of Roses - A Firefly Guide

Good Rating
Book Profile
Author (1): Orietta Sala

Softcopy edition:
Publish date: Month Unknown 2003
Published by: Firefly Books
List price: $24.95
ISBN Number: 1552976270



  Feedback History and Summary  
2 positives
No neutrals
No negatives


Positive DonnaMack On Nov 17, 2014, DonnaMack wrote:

This is a beautiful hardcover book that is incredibly practical. It categorizes roses by use, such as roses in beds, shrub roses, climber and ramblers, cold climate roses, ground cover roses, and gives examples and substitutes. It is loaded with gorgeous photographs, and is particularly useful if you are trying to choose roses of a type. There is a terrific chart helping the reader to choose roses for position and climate. There is a thorough yet unpretentious and clear exposition on the different rose types, from the oldest to the most modern. It is sturdy, yet strong enough to carry around. Highest recommendation.

Positive amarettonc On Jan 10, 2007, amarettonc wrote:

This book was first printed in Spain in 2002; this is the English translation. The roses are grouped as climbers/ramblers, roses in beds, shrub roses, borders/hedges/espaliers, groundcover roses, miniatures/patio roses, and cold-climate roses. There are also brief chapters on cultivation, classification, competitions, creators/breeders, and rose associations. This book is a standard guide for the different rose varieties, but for each rose the author includes at least one suggestion for a similar rose and compares attributes. For example, the author suggests 'Jacques Cartier' as an alternative for 'Comte de Chambord', and notes: " 'Jacques Cartier' . .. is very similar to 'Comte de Chambord' in terms of overall appearance, with the same leaves and the same elegance . . . (s)ome experts hold that the reflowering is less abundant." All roses in the book (including the alternatives) are listed in the index. Each rose profiled (and most of the alternative selections) include a beautiful and tempting! color photo. I found this book to be very helpful in deciding between rose varieties, and fascinating reading.

Add your own comment and rating to this book

Return to the Garden Bookworm homepage

Overwhelmed? There's a lot to see here. Try starting at our homepage.

[ Home | About | Advertise | Media Kit | Mission | Tour | Contact Us ]

Back to the top


Hope for America