Photo by Melody

Comments regarding Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Co.

Click here to return to Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Co.'s listing.

  Feedback History and Summary  
1049 positives
23 neutrals
44 negatives


« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | ... 28 Next »

Positive wittyusername
(3 reviews)
On Mar 14, 2016, wittyusername Los Angeles, CA (Zone 10a) wrote:

The biggest problem I have with Baker Seeds is that I want to plant way more things than I have room for. But seriously, they're one of my favourite suppliers. They have excellent selection, economic and fast shipping, and a very informative website. I've had particularly good luck with their herb seeds.

Positive CackleberryFarm
(1 review)
On Mar 7, 2016, CackleberryFarm Elkland, MO wrote:

I have ordered from Baker Creek several times over the past few years and have always been pleased. This year I received my seeds 3 days after placing my order online. They have an awesome website that is very informative and easy to use. The catalog is the best ever. The seeds always do very well, even better than expected! Thank you Baker Creek!

Positive MissWells
(1 review)
On Mar 2, 2016, MissWells Marysville, OH wrote:

I just received my first seed order from Baker Creek and I couldn't be more happy! Very prompt shipping and shipping cost very reasonably priced. The bonus pack of seeds as a thank you for the order was a pleasant surprise :) I have not planted but am very excited to. I will be ordering from this company again.

Positive sjwyoak
(1 review)
On Feb 15, 2016, sjwyoak Palmer, AK wrote:

This is my second year ordering from Baker's Creek. i'm very happy. the order came quickly and last year the seeds germinated well and the seeds per pkt were generous. Thank you.

Positive amce
(1 review)
On Feb 12, 2016, amce Hawley, TX wrote:

I have ordered seed from this company for years. They have always shipped my order out quickly and the seed germination is great. I also buy all my corn from them as they test it for GMO contamination. I just love this company.

Positive LeannaT
(1 review)
On Feb 9, 2016, LeannaT Fort Wayne, IN wrote:

I love the rare unique seeds Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Co. offers and really appreciate their ethos. I've bought their products for a couple years now and have always been very happy with how quickly my orders arrive and with the quality of their products. I will happily continue to be their patron and supporter.

Positive BotanicalBoi
(9 reviews)
On Feb 7, 2016, BotanicalBoi Carrollton, GA (Zone 7b) wrote:

❀ ¯¨'*·~-.¸¸,.-~*'✿ƒavorite Çompany✿*·~-.¸¸,.-~*'❀

Always a pleasure to deal with. Seeds always have high germination rates and always perform very well! I love that this company is consistent, offers a print catalog and quality product. My only wish is that they offered even more varieties :-) I am a greedy gardener when it comes to nice heirlooms! Looking forward to trying more of your seeds this coming spring.

Thank you!

Positive kmathews7577
(1 review)
On Feb 6, 2016, kmathews7577 Cocoa, FL wrote:

We received all the seeds we ordered in a timely fashion without having to call and argue with them. We have not started any of them as of yet, as we just received them. We will order from them again.

Positive dlaurence
(9 reviews)
On Jan 28, 2016, dlaurence Richmond, MO (Zone 5a) wrote:

Excellent customer service. Maybe I'm lucky, but I paid for seeds late night January 19, and received package January 23.

Positive twintoes
(5 reviews)
On Jan 17, 2016, twintoes Tuckasegee, NC (Zone 7a) wrote:

First time ordering from them. Received the order very quickly, along with a free pack of seeds as a gift. The quantity of seeds were generous as well. Looking forward to growing the seeds and hoping for better than average germination.

Positive Chiligardener
(1 review)
On Jan 9, 2016, Chiligardener Phoenix, AZ wrote:

Extremely pleased with this company.
They had Exactly what I have been searching for locally and couldn't find.
Everything came Quite quickly, and better than I hoped.
Definitely my go to store now for those hard to find seeds!

Positive Scuttlebutt
(1 review)
On Dec 29, 2015, Scuttlebutt Windsor Locks, CT wrote:

I have ordered from Baker's Creek for 4 years now. The seeds have high germination rates and produce well. The variety is fantastic and I order almost exclusively from this company.

Positive Nccharliehorse
(1 review)
On Dec 27, 2015, Nccharliehorse Weaverville, NC wrote:

I have ordered from Baker Creek five times over the last several years. I have been very happy with the seeds. They always have great germination rates. Very pleasant customer service! Speedy shipping! I LOVE their rocky top lettuce mix. It always grows well and I can pick it from early spring to late fall. They have some very nice exotic varieties too. The kids had a fun time growing the black Incan corn last year. I love their catalog. The pictures and descriptions are very detailed. It makes ordering so much fun.

Positive RareFruit2909
(5 reviews)
On Dec 26, 2015, RareFruit2909 Lebanon, OH wrote:

Great catalog for anyone wanting to experiment with the rare and unusual. Seeds are a bit pricey compared to other catalogs, especially for the more common varieties, but they provide a good service in conserving rare food crops and offering a variety of difficult-to-find choices to American gardeners. Very fast shipment of orders.

Positive Ajones813
(1 review)
On Dec 5, 2015, Ajones813 Ocala, FL wrote:

I have placed 4 seed orders through Baker's Creek. Not only has the order placing been easy and convenient, but shipping has been speedy and I've had an excellent turn out with their seeds! I am one that will over plant to be sure I have at least 1 plant in every spot. However, with Baker's Creek seeds, I've had to do a lot of thinning due to most seeds germinating. Lol. Thank you Baker's Creek for an all-around great experience with your company and products!

Positive grwgrn57
(3 reviews)
On Nov 20, 2015, grwgrn57 Fieldon, IL wrote:

I have ordered from Baker Creek when the catalog was just like a leaflet. I have never received any seeds that did not sprout. Everything is just as described. The variety is wonderful. The service is great. They shipped fast. I have a 7000 sq yd garden and the majority crops grown are Baker Creek. Love Love Love them GO ORGANIC!!!!!

Positive HenOak7911
(1 review)
On Oct 26, 2015, HenOak7911 Danbury, WI wrote:

Bakers Creek is the only seed company we use. I cannot say enough good about them. When we first started ordering seeds from them years ago they sent out handwritten thank you notes. Now that the company is larger the note is printed on the bottom of the order slip but it's still means just as much. They always ship on time and they include a packet or two of free seeds depending on the size of your order. Out in the garden their seeds grow and produce better than anything else we have tried.

Positive kking9157
(1 review)
On Oct 15, 2015, kking9157 Athens, AL wrote:

I love Baker Creek. I ordered two separate times and received my order quickly and correctly. I even got a free pack of seeds on my second order. I can't wait for my heirloom winter garden to produce fresh produce, all non-GMO! Keep up the great work guys!

Positive MossieJoe
(1 review)
On Jul 22, 2015, MossieJoe Kellogg, ID wrote:

I love these seeds, had great luck with all of them. Just ordered a few pkts for late summer planting and received 4 free pkts. Thank you!!

Positive 4RealFood
(7 reviews)
On Jun 11, 2015, 4RealFood Mount Orab, OH (Zone 6a) wrote:

Baker Creek is one of only two companies I will order my garden seed from. Heirloom seed and they are on the front lines to keep our seeds non-GMO. Keep fighting the good fight!
Interesting and fun varieties. The seeds and germination rate are excellent!

Positive liz006
(1 review)
On Jun 10, 2015, liz006 Monroe, GA wrote:

Love this company! Have been ordering unique seeds from them for over 6 years now and am yet to be disappointed. I highly recommend them for their rare, heirloom varieties. Their absolutely stunning seed catalog is also well worth signing up for. They usually throw in a free seed packet with an order as well.

Negative Spanky1951
(1 review)
On Jun 5, 2015, Spanky1951 Mill Creek, IN wrote:

Extremely surprised to see so many positive reviews of this company.
I received their catalog and placed all my seeds in one basket by ordering everything for my garden this year from them.

I'm talking about 18 different vegetables. The vast majority did not germinate....some were even planted twice and still did grow. Only the three varieties radishes (pretty much all radishes seem to grow no matter what) and the two varieties of sweet corn were almost 100% successful.

I ended up scurrying to the local nursery and grabbing the dregs they had left over in order to get my garden in. What a shame. So many interesting seeds and so little germination. Obviously, I will never order from them again.

On Jun 5, 2015, Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Co. responded with:

"On Jun 8, 2015 1:19 PM, Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Co. responded with:

We are so sorry to hear you had problems with your seed germinating! We always germ test our seed, and do not offer it for sale until we get a passing germ test on that lot. That being said, many things can happen to the seed when it leaves our warehouse that can affect germination, including irradiation from the mail service, to leaving the package sitting on the dash in the hot sun... This is why we guarantee germination of our seed for one year from the date of purchase. If you will contact us at [email protected], we'd be happy to make this right! We can send you a refund for the seeds that did not germinate, or we can send you some different seed if you would like to try again later."

Positive shellbell818
(2 reviews)
On Jun 1, 2015, shellbell818 Bartlett, IL wrote:

This is my first year starting everything (mostly everything) from seed and I choose this company based on reviews. I had near 100% germination on all seeds from my two separate purchases made this year. My 3 types of onions molded over (my fault) and my Tronchuda Kale did not sprout. (Did I mention this was my first year starting from seeds?). I am very pleased with my purchase. I received my order in a reasonable amount of time and received a packet of freebie seeds with each order. That is always exciting. I would recommend this company to anyone looking for exciting and rare vegetables to grow. Being that I'm new to gardening and very new to starting seeds I would have appreciated more information on each packet/website description stating the normal seed packet information like when to sow how long they take to mature etc. but google has been helpful in that matter.

Positive msdst8
(1 review)
On May 23, 2015, msdst8 Mullica Hill, NJ wrote:

Today I received my second order and am again pleased. They have a wonderful selection of seeds and I experienced great germination rates with my first order. I'm also very satisfied with the customer service. With my first order, I emailed them about when to plant something as there was conflicting information online (not on their site, on other sites I went to). The rep was so helpful. Also, shipping was really fast for that I can track my orders.

Positive jillde
(1 review)
On Apr 27, 2015, jillde Leavenworth, WA wrote:

My experience with Baker Creek has only been great! Most of their seeds do good for me. (we live in the Mountains and only have about 3 months growing time). I make sure if possible to order seeds that mature in 80 days. They have good descriptions of the plants and helpful hints. Because of them, I tried Purslane and love it! I also think they have the most beautiful seed packets I've ever seen. And I really appreciate the free packet of seed with my order; I think it is very generous and kind (and makes me smile). I feel real good about telling other gardeners in my area about their seeds. I will continue to do business with them until I can't have a garden anymore...hope I'm a 106 by then.

Positive tmaryso43
(1 review)
On Apr 26, 2015, tmaryso43 Taos, MO wrote:

I found the peppers I wanted and ordered them online. I received them quickly (already planted some). They also sent me a free package of cilantro. Going to plant them next. Thanks Baker Creek! Love your seeds!

Positive floralbell
(2 reviews)
On Apr 25, 2015, floralbell Holland Patent, NY wrote:

Placed online order for about $170-they had a nice selection and nothing was sold out. Order received in about 10 days, some nice free seeds included, too! The ones that I started have all germinated.Very pleased so far with the transaction and quality/quantity of seeds. I also love their catalog.

Positive greenguy111
(1 review)
On Apr 24, 2015, greenguy111 Pittsburgh, PA (Zone 5b) wrote:

This was the first company I have ever ordered seeds from. I found their catalog in a local bookstore & loved that they were Non GMO, Heirloom types. I also really liked that they had photos and the histories of almost all their plants/seeds. I ended up taking a shot & placed an order.

It was very easy to navigate their website. They were sold out of a few things that I wanted, but no big deal, I just ordered something else. I paid and instantly got an email confirmation of my order. A few days later, I got an email confirmation of my order shipping out. And a few more days later I had the seeds at my door!

I love the design of the seed packets! I also really love that they give you a brief history and growing directions. Now, I did order a few things and they came in sort of a generic package and didn't have a history or directions, so I had to look those up myself, but no big deal really.

I sowed some seeds on a Saturday & they had all started to germinate 3 days later! I was so excited, I ended up placing a second order of seeds from them!

I've had two positive experiences from them & I will be buying more from them. Thank you!

Positive kbadams9
(2 reviews)
On Apr 17, 2015, kbadams9 New Meadows, ID wrote:

Baker Creek always meets my expectations! I have purchased about $250 in seeds each year for the last 4 years. Germination is better than any other company I have ordered from. When you start seeds in the greenhouse it is important to know you can trust the seeds will actually sprout, especially for those varieties that take so long to emerge. Seeds I ordered from other companies this year averaged 25% germination rate and were twice as expensive! Baker Creek 95%. Look forward to their catalog, love the website and very happy with their reasonably priced products. You can't go wrong.

(1 review)
On Mar 29, 2015, IMAGOODSHOT Prairieville, LA wrote:

I placed a $200.00 online. The very day they shipped my order they sent out an email offering their Whole Seed Catalog for free with any $50.00 order. I thought when I received my order it would contain the free catalog. Nope. Okay, no problem. I send a nice email explaining the situation, fully expecting a nice response. Wrong again. What I got was an email from Lisa C. saying my order was placed prior to the when they initiated offer and that she had no way to send me the catalog for free. This is the same catalog that I had bought and paid for the previous year not only for myself but for my daughter as well.
Well nearly two months later I realize I still have not gotten the (5) dahlia bulbs from this same order so I send another email again explaining nicely about the catalog offer and that I would appreciate it if they could send me the catalog with my dahlia bulbs that they had apparently forgotten to ship. Several days later I get an email from them that consists of two items: A copy of my original receipt, and a tracking# showing that something was being shipped to me. No apology, no explanation as to why it took so long - just a tracking#. Okay, well I don't know where you guys went to customer service school at but where I come from that is just downright rude! And to make matters worse, I got the package in from them yesterday, opened it to find only (2) dahlia bulbs instead of the (5) they charged for. Wow. I was going to make a small dahlia bed at the side of my greenhouse. WTH am I going to make with 2 dahlia bulbs? Oh... and they still didn't send me a catalog. That's okay guys, I will no longer be needing it as you made it abundantly clear on several occasions that you did not need my business.

On Mar 29, 2015, Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Co. responded with:

"On Mar 31, 2015 10:00 AM, Baker Creek Heirloom Seed Co. responded with:

We apologize for the confusion, but as we told you in the response to the email we received a day after this post was created, that the dahlias were a pre-order item. It states in the catalog "Order these now and we will ship you good-sized tubers in March, April or May, depending on shipping conditions and your climate location"

We had a crop failure on two of the varieties you purchased, and we mailed you a letter letting you know, as well as offering substitution of 4 different varieties or a refund, your choice. In your email reply to me yesterday evening, you told me what you wanted for replacement, and those are shipping out today.

As for the catalog, we began the free offer on February 5th, and you ordered on February 1st. The special, limited time offer was not retro-active, which is a common business practice. Lisa C.'s response to you asking if you would get a copy was as follows:
The free offer did not come out until 2/5/15 .Sorry for the inconvenience! I have no way to add you to the list it is done automatically."

Positive DakotaDave65
(1 review)
On Mar 16, 2015, DakotaDave65 Bridgewater, SD wrote:

This is my second year ordering from Baker and both times have been wonderful. The seeds have arrived faster than expected with no issues. As with last year I again received an extra envelop of seed for free as a gift. I actually ordered for two other people besides myself this time. Last year was my first time gardening. I learned quite a lot and have no doubt I will learn even more this year. The thing that impressed me the most was that despite my attempts to kill every seed I planted they still produced! And I used no chemicals and the only prep of my ground was putting in some chicken poo and vermiculite when I first tilled the soil. My soil has a few more years to go before it will be good garden dirt but its better than it was last year! Thanks to Baker I keep encouraged to try and realize that its a lot like learning how to walk. This year I will attempt tomatoes and corn and I have made a deal with a neighbor who has several apple trees that I will plant some other fruit trees so we can share and he was more than willing. So thanks to these seeds I am making some new friends I probably would not have otherwise.

Positive Greg_B_72
(2 reviews)
On Mar 14, 2015, Greg_B_72 Fort Wayne, IN wrote:

Ordering on website was easy. I received my order in four days. My order was correct. It even came with a free gift. I will be using Baker Creek Heirloom Seed company agin.

Positive d_boll
(2 reviews)
On Mar 11, 2015, d_boll Largo MD,
United States wrote:

Always a pleasure to do business with this company. Will be back for more before the season is over.

Positive StephintheGardn
(2 reviews)
On Mar 8, 2015, StephintheGardn Massillon, OH wrote:

I ordered seed packets, and live plants (to be delivered in April). The seed packets arrived within about 5 days. I am very happy with their selection, they have many varieties that I cannot get anywhere else. I cannot wait to receive my live plants, I will update my rating once those arrive. I highly recommend Baker Creek Seeds!

Positive prime24
(1 review)
On Mar 3, 2015, prime24 Chippewa Lake, MI (Zone 5b) wrote:

So far they have delivered my online order very hastily. And what's not to love about a seed company that values seed security?

Positive sss56
(8 reviews)
On Mar 3, 2015, sss56 Gastonia, NC (Zone 7b) wrote:

I ordered seeds. They were delivered quickly and I received exactly what I ordered. Thanks. I'll buy from you again.

Positive jumpinjo
(12 reviews)
On Feb 15, 2015, jumpinjo Marshalltown, IA (Zone 5a) wrote:

Good variety, good service, good seeds.

Positive maddux3
(2 reviews)
On Feb 13, 2015, maddux3 Atlanta, GA wrote:

This is my 3rd year using this company and have nothing but great things to say. Awesome selection of seeds at a great price, very inexpensive flat rate shipping, and possibly the fastest turn around time. I've never had germination trouble with any of their seeds and plan to continue trying new things from them for as long as I am gardening!

Positive Silonius3
(1 review)
On Feb 6, 2015, Silonius3 Helena, AL wrote:

Linked to them from FB. Received the catalog in the mail. Ordered my seeds and they arrived quickly. Looking forward to planting them sooner NOT later. Thanks for the fast efficient service.

« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | ... 28 Next »

Overwhelmed? There's a lot to see here. Try starting at our homepage.

[ Home | About | Advertise | Media Kit | Mission | Featured Companies | Tour | Contact Us ]

Back to the top


Hope for America