Photo by Melody

Comments regarding R.H. Shumway Seeds

Click here to return to R.H. Shumway Seeds's listing.

  Feedback History and Summary  
54 positives
8 neutrals
34 negatives


« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 Next »

Positive Vashur
(9 reviews)
On Apr 6, 2007, Vashur Wichita, KS (Zone 6b) wrote:

This was my first order from the company. I ordered onion plants and potato sets because the cost was much less than my usual source. They arrived today and they are really good looking product. I also received a generous bonus pack. I would have liked them a couple of weeks earlier but it is working out for the best anyhow because we now have unseasonably cold weather and they won't have to contend with it. I will certainly use this company for a larger order next year.

Positive happyscientist
(1 review)
On Mar 16, 2007, happyscientist Fairmont, WV wrote:

I had never ordered from this company before, so last month I placed a small test order of around $25. The complete order arrived in less than two weeks and included a few bonus packs of seeds.

Positive dtinn
(9 reviews)
On Feb 11, 2007, dtinn Falmouth, KY wrote:

I have ordered from this company for years without any problem. They may not as flashy as some companies, but they deliver good quality seed at fair prices. I also like the fact that I can order bulk seed without spending an arm and a leg.

Positive gafbuffalo
(6 reviews)
On Jan 21, 2007, gafbuffalo Orchard Park, NY (Zone 5a) wrote:

Good, fast service on seed delivery. This company has a very nice selection of vegetable seeds, generally better than their parent, Jung, at least for what I like to grow. I've never had a problem with germination rates, either.

Positive drlith
(2 reviews)
On May 26, 2006, drlith Lanham, MD wrote:

I ordered about 25 different varieties of seed, 20 asparagus crowns, and 8 different berry shrubs (2 blueberry, 2 lingonberry, 2 gooseberries, and 2 black currents). The seeds were shipped 2-3 weeks after I placed my order (by mail), except fava beans, which were on back order. It was down to the wire with them to get them in time for the narrow planting window, but they did make it here by the first week of March, and I got them in the ground a week later. The shrubs all arrived in one shipment in late March. We put them in the ground right away; one of the gooseberries did not sprout from the existing stems, but it did manage to send up new growth from the roots, and now all the berry bushes are looking happy. The aspargus crowns all eventually came up as well.

I received several bonus packets of "experimental" varieties, which was nice, although they should indicate what the sweetness genetics of the experimental sweet corn are, since certain hybrids shouldn't be planted with certain other hybrids.

All told, I will definitely use RH Shumway again--they have good prices on a lot of old standbys,

Positive nepaug
(1 review)
On May 13, 2006, nepaug New Hartford, CT wrote:

I have ordered seeds from R.H. Shumway for years with no problems. Good seeds at a fair price.

Positive holleegee
(1 review)
On Apr 6, 2006, holleegee Lawson, MO wrote:

This was the first time I ordered from R.H. Shumway. I am so happy with my order, it was shipped very fast and everything I ordered is very good quality. I ordered rhubarb and they have to be at least 6-8 inches long and about three inches around! I also ordered walking onions (multiplyer onions) it says 10 to a package but one package has 19 and the other has 16! My mint chocolate plant is also a nice size! I am very happy with my order! I will order from them again.

Positive bean_freak
(1 review)
On Mar 15, 2006, bean_freak Kellyton, AL (Zone 7b) wrote:

i ordered from Shumway ,s and they were quite fast and i i got what i ask for
also i ask for a order form and they sent it right a way
Go Shumways
wayne M.

Positive shockme_wv
(3 reviews)
On Feb 2, 2006, shockme_wv Grafton, WV wrote:

So far, Shumway's has been so-so. This is my 1st time ordering from them, and they took pretty long for being such a large outfit. I ordered from 3 companies at the same time, and Shumway's delivered last (and was also the largest company). One of them was even snail mailed in versus my Shumway's order that was placed via the internet, and it still arrived before Shumway. The order was incomplete, but the backordered packet did arrive about 2 weeks later. I took a leap of faith and ordered 2 blueberry plants which are to arrive in Spring, so I am keeping the fingers crossed on that one. The good thing about Shumway is their price, they have a lot of varities at a lower cost than other catalogs I received.

On May 15th, 2006, shockme_wv added the following:

Well, my 2 blueberry plants arrived and were in good shape and since being planted (in March) they're doing very well. My rosemary seed did not germinate well (3 came up out of 24 planted) but I don't know if this is because rosemary is difficult or if the seeds were bad). I would order from Shumway's again after my experience which overall was generally positive.
Positive IslandJim
(4 reviews)
On Mar 17, 2005, IslandJim Keizer, OR (Zone 8b) wrote:

I placed an order for three Stevia [rebaudiana] plants from Shumway's on February 28, 2005; they arrived today, March 17, 2005. They were well packed. They arrived a bit dry, but perked up as soon as watered. I'm satisfied with what I got for what I paid. Tomorrow, if the rain stops, I will plant them out.

Positive Dragonfly_eyes
(3 reviews)
On Feb 22, 2005, Dragonfly_eyes Mobile, AL wrote:

I have ordered from Shumway on a couple of different occasions and both times I've been quite pleased with both the speed and quality of the seeds I've bought. The prices were beyond fair according to what I've seen elsewhere on the internet, too. A big thumbs up to Shumways.

Positive Maridian88
(4 reviews)
On Jan 5, 2005, Maridian88 Paradise, TX wrote:

I was shocked at reading all the negative experiences with this company. I ordered from them in 2004 & my order arrived promptly & completely. I am a market farmer & it was a fairly large order, though it was all seeds, no live plants or seed potatoes. I think when you deal with a company affiliated with the Randolph, WI address, you almost HAVE to get your order in extra-early, & I would NEVER order anything but seeds from them. Course most of the other companies at this address will not ship until March or April, but Shumways claims to be the exception to this rule.

Positive sunnybritefarm
(11 reviews)
On Apr 15, 2004, sunnybritefarm Naalehu, HI wrote:

I've never had a problem ordering from them. Have been using them for years. Guess I've been lucky. They have a few items I like , so I'll keep using them.

Negative cemcoatl
(2 reviews)
On Mar 20, 2004, cemcoatl Elgin, TX wrote:

The length of time it takes between ordering from this company is too long . place your orders right now so you can get them next year.

Positive texaswulf
(1 review)
On Jan 23, 2004, texaswulf Conroe, TX wrote:

After reading all the negative remarks here I wasnt sure if i wanted to place an order with this company. However I decided to try my luck and I place a 50 plus dollar order with them. Two weeks later I had my order in hand and it was 100% complete, no back orders or out of stocks. I will use this company again in the future. All I can say is great company and great service!!!!

Positive Farmerdill
(23 reviews)
On Dec 4, 2003, Farmerdill Augusta, GA (Zone 8a) wrote:

I have purchased vegetable seed from the Shumway company since the 40's. The major positive has always been their good selection of traditional open pollinated varieties. In the 60's while it was still a Shumway company located in Rockford , Illinois quality and service began to slip. On occasion mis-labeled cultivars arrived. The company name was bought and moved to Graniteville SC and during the 90's I bought a lot of seed from them. Again the attraction of older cultivars that are difficult to find and the fact that I could go down to the warehouse and buy the seeds without the mailorder hassle.( It was only 11 miles from me) Only problem was that their major supplier (Seeds By Design) which is a major player in the production of heirloom seeds has spent too little time insuring the purity of their cultivars. Since the Jungs buyout and subsequent move to Wisconsin, I hope they get their act together, but I am not holding my breath.

On January 25th, 2004, Farmerdill changed the rating from neutral to positive and added the following:

Placed an order first week of January and was pleasantly surprised to receive complete AND correct order within a week. This was for seeds only. They use to drop ship plants and garden supplies so many problems could have been with contract shippers. At any rate the Jung people show signs of getting the company in order so I have go positive. Downside is that they seem to be phasing out many of the vegetable varieties that drew mw to them in the first place.
Positive PJeff
(1 review)
On Aug 2, 2003, PJeff wrote:

Whenever I use a new supplier, I tend to order small, which is what I did this year. Ordered seeds and three elephant ear bulbs. The elephant ears were only 3 for 12.00, much more reasonable than other sources and they are magnificent!!!

Yes, my order did come in three shipments, but to be honest, I received all in a timely fashion and with explanation.

I would rate my small experience as positive.

Positive BobS
(1 review)
On Apr 25, 2003, BobS wrote:

I notice that most of the negative comments about this company are from past years. This year (2003), I ordered several items from R.H. Shumway, including seed potatoes and vegetable seeds. All except two backordered items arrived promptly and in good condition, and even those two still arrived in time for normal planting. I think these guys deserve a chance!

Neutral LauraJ
(9 reviews)
On Mar 6, 2003, LauraJ Northville, MI wrote:

Their old-fashioned, Farmer's Almanac-like catalogue is cute, but there are NO latin / botanical names for any products. The Spring 2003 catalogue cover says: "Delayed Shipments - Deep Regrets - Problems Addressed". Hmm. The company says that it moved to Randolph, Wisconsin and they apologized for problems with spring 2002 orders. "Some shipments were delayed or late... you had every right to be unhappy." But the company says its new home and new processing facility will result in better shipping.

That said, they carry some interesting things including a REAL "heirloom" -- blue dent corn from the Hopi Indians, which I read elsewhere is from seeds recovered on an archaeological dig!! so I might give them a try with a small order of that.

Negative mareilly
(1 review)
On Mar 3, 2003, mareilly wrote:

I placed my seed order in January. It's now March and I have received every other seed order I placed. Shumway seeds still haven't arrived. I just called their 800 number. Had to redial 5 times before I didn't get a busy signal. Spent 10 minutes on hold before giving up. I just sent them an email from their web site asking about order status. Will keep you posted - am very unhappy.

On March 7th, 2003, mareilly added the following:

After a week of attempting to contact Shumway by phone I finally got through. I was told the majority of items in my order were backordered, but that (what a coincidence!) my order was in the filling department and the other items would probably be sent out today. I told the rep to cancel my order (most of what I wanted was backordered).

After I hung up, I called my bank (should have done this first) and found out that my check was cashed on February 13th! I am so irritated with this company - I will *never* place another order with them.
Negative Javabean
(3 reviews)
On Feb 25, 2003, Javabean Houston, TX (Zone 9a) wrote:

After reading their "starting over story" in the new Shumway catalog, I thought I would give this garden supplier a chance. I placed a seed order with Shumway by mail in January. The check cleared on February 3. I have not received merchandise or an update regarding the location and expected delivery time of my merchandise. Based on the other reviews and my own experience, I will not order from Shumway's again.

Negative chickenman
(19 reviews)
On Feb 25, 2003, chickenman Somerset, PA wrote:

This company is a joke. I ordered seeds last February (2002) and I did not recieve them until June. And this was after many phone calls wondering where my order was. Last summer I received an apology and a coupon. I ordered seeds last fall and did not have a problem. I figured they just had an off year and the problem was taken care of, well I was wrong. I ordered a 12' heating cable this year in January over the internet and still haven't received it. After I get this order taken care of, it will be the last one placed with this seed company. Having it take 4 weeks plus to receive an order placed on the internet is insane. Especially when other seed companies have your order in your mail box in less than two weeks.

Negative hangsix
(8 reviews)
On Feb 19, 2003, hangsix wrote:

Last year this company had a fire , so I was aware that they
had some 'NEGATIVE ' issues ! However I was Sincerely ,,,
willing to give the another chance this year ,,, due to the
fire and what looked to me like a sincere apolize for poor
serivce last year . NO MORE >>>> I order seeds over 3 weeks
ago emailed them and got a email back that said they were 3 weeks behind . Within that email they also said they would
research the issue no responance ,,, I have a small presonal
greenhouse and I don't think I 'll get these seeds in time for
the season here in Buffalo NY . I AM SO ANGERY ,,, PLEASE
BE WARNED !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

On March 20th, 2003, hangsix added the following:

Please note on March the 19 I did receive most .....
of my order two items were left off . I was told due to the fact that there had to mail them at a later date I owned them
postage .. of .80 cents I have writen to them and told them to
cancel any other products . I WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN
Negative enilniah
(7 reviews)
On Feb 18, 2003, enilniah Rockford, OH wrote:

i ordered from this company in January 2003 and still have not gotten my order as of February 18, or heard anything from the company. I will not order from this company again.

On February 19th, 2003, enilniah changed the rating from neutral to negative and added the following:

called Shumway this morning to ask about order from middle of Jan. was told most of order is on back order and rest is in process of being processed. Will never order from this company again.
Negative moosecop
(2 reviews)
On Jul 30, 2002, moosecop West Bend, WI wrote:

This company is a joke.And its moving to Wisconsin according to a representitive of Jungs.... Seems Shumways, Totally Tomatoes, Jungs, Vermont Bean and a bunch of others are all owned by a few stockholders who seem to have bought a bunch of companies and in turn are doing a half --- job at management. I ordered seeds in bulk quanities in Nov and Dec and some ( including lettuce) showed up in June. I called Jungs who is taking over this mess and I was assured it would not appear on my credit card and just to keep the seed... Guess what showed up on the credit card I just got. The Fire was at Jungs in Randolff WI near my home and distroyed the Catalogue Storage Area and Bulb area... I was told it did not affect the seed divison so who knows whos telling the truth. I tryed to call Shumways toll free number from March thru May and never got thru on apparently the only line they ever had... I even tryed other numbers which were also always busy. I ended up buying seed from other sources in the mean time like lettuce to get in the ground early.... ANd to top it off one of the varieties I ordered was an heirloom called chicken lettuce. They sent me a Lettuce mix with Black simpson and some other things and said ..." We cant supply you with the variety you ordered so we hope you will like this".... How do they know what ill like.??... ANyways I told the sales person at Jungs I would not order from Shumways or Jungs again ... Even if they are now only going to be 30 miles from my house.

Negative philr
(1 review)
On Jul 1, 2002, philr wrote:

Anyone who has good luck with this company must have caught them on an off day. Generally they are as bad as the worst reviews written for them. I had many problems with orders being promised by specific dates and not arriving. As I have a short growing season, seeds need to be planted indoors. Shumway sends everything as if it will be planted outdoors, based on some incorrect assumptions they have on what is a good planting time for my area. They had an herb mill advertised for a good price. However, it was CLEARLY pictured as all metal, but when it arrived it was some cheap Chinese made junk. Mostly plastic and wholly not as pictured. In many states that is considered fraud and should be reported to your state's Attorney General. I too, had problems connecting with their customer service and they should have an 800 #. Line was always busy, no answering machine. When I emailed them, they came up with the 'computer down' excuse again. They don't give a darn about customer's, just our money. I was so frustrated with them, I wanted them to refund everything, and take everything back, and to pay for the return postage, as it was their screwup. I never heard from them again, and I assume that is a part of their corporate policy!

Positive eyeguy
(1 review)
On May 10, 2002, eyeguy wrote:

I ordered seeds, equipment, and chemicals. The seeds didn't arrive until after I bought replacements. A letter with the seeds explained that they had a warehouse fire. They made arrangements with another company to send seeds they lost to the fire and sent me a coupon for $$ off next year's order. I see this as an attempt to carry on in the face of a company disaster. This was my first order from them, and I'll be back next year. I can't see kicking them when they're down as benefiting me or them.

Negative lbclisa
(2 reviews)
On May 2, 2002, lbclisa wrote:

I send in a order in Feburary and only recieved the potatoes. Only one plant grew from the eyes. I emailed the company and they sent a email stating they had a warehouse fire in March. If that is the case I feel that they should have informed me in March. I will have to go this weekend in May to find seeds to begin growing before it is too late.
I will not be using this company again.

On May 18th, 2002, lbclisa added the following:

I got some more of the ordered products the other day. They have changed their reason for the delay due to supply problems and not getting the seed package growing directions in. Oh ya, they gave me the $$$ coupon of 3 bucks towards the purchase of other seeds. They also sent the seeds for ordering so early. I was not pleased however because the Sweet potaotes plants that arrived were totally dried out including the peat moss covering them. I planted them and hope they will grow. The seeds I have planted from this company seem to have okay germination. I still have some seeds yet to come.

I had great hopes for this company since it had seeds that you can not get elsewhere but I will stick will companies I had good service with and try to find another source of seeds such as mangle seeds.

I have ordered a lot of seeds from other companies including ordering from Germany and Hawaii and did not have delay/ problems like I did from this company.
Neutral kennyliles
(1 review)
On May 1, 2002, kennyliles wrote:

I have ordered exclusively from this company for years. This is the first year I have ever had a problem. I ordered asparagus roots and they arrived on time, however I also ordered a variety of other plants and seeds in early March, and they still have not yet arrived. It is May, and I am still waiting. What is the deal with them???

Positive gbalog
(1 review)
On May 1, 2002, gbalog wrote:

Great Company. I purchased German Stiff-necked Garlic, got it early in Oct and planted it. This garlic is gigantic. I need their catalog so I can order more from them.

Negative jeffc
(1 review)
On Apr 16, 2002, jeffc wrote:

Order sent on 02/26/02. Check cashed and cleared. As of 04/16/02, nothing received. No responses to email inquiries. Telephone (toll call) has been busy consistently (~9 tries).

Negative mssuesan
(1 review)
On Apr 12, 2002, mssuesan Huntington, WV (Zone 6a) wrote:

I placed an order in Jan. 2002 and it has still not arrived. I phoned and they told me it was on the way 2 months ago. It wasn't. Nice catalog though. Too bad I won't get to see the seeds.

Negative jeffchamberlain
(3 reviews)
On Apr 1, 2002, jeffchamberlain Nassau, NY wrote:

Order placed 02/02; check cashed and cleared; nothing received as of 04/16/02. No responses to email inquiries. Telephone (toll call) consistently busy (~9 attempts). Unsatisfactory.

Negative annoliver
(1 review)
On Mar 29, 2002, annoliver wrote:

I have ordered small orders for a few years and was pleased. However, this year, things have drastically changed. My order, placed January 18, was received and the check cancelled January 28, 2002. It is now March 29, and I have received no seeds. I have made four telephone calls (none toll free). The first time I was told that the order was prepared for shipping and would be shipped at the end of the week. The next two times I was told that the order had been shipped. Today, I was told that the order had been shipped. I asked for the date it was shipped and was told that it was in the shipping department and would be shipped. I asked to speak to the manager. I was told that the supervisor was not in. I asked to speak to someone in the shipping department and was told that I could not have contact with them. I asked for my shipment to be cancelled and my money returned. I was informed that I would have to wait until the seeds arrived and that I could return them and then my money would be refunded. Needless to say, I will not be ordering any more seeds from this place.

Negative bobbyabernathy
(1 review)
On Mar 29, 2002, bobbyabernathy wrote:

I ordered early Feb. 2002 now late march cant get them on phone sent several emails and letters can't get any one will never never order from them would rather go hungry at least I know the outcome of going hungry with Shumway I don't know what's happening except I am not getting service. DO NOT ORDER FROM THEM!!!

Negative mitchandbarb
(1 review)
On Mar 27, 2002, mitchandbarb wrote:

I will never place another order with Shumway unless there is something I really, really want, and they are the only company that has it. I placed my order on January 3, 2002, and is now March 27. I still don't have my seeds and it is getting too late for me to start the tomatoes, eggplants and peppers. Maybe I will get my seeds, but I'm writing it off as a loss. I called them three times, and they are not cooperative. They simply say there is nothing they can do. If that's the case, I really feel sorry for them.

Negative nachamkin
(1 review)
On Mar 26, 2002, nachamkin Glen Mills, PA wrote:

After ordering in mid January, I still (3/26/02) have not received my very large order. After four phone calls and assurances each time that my order would be sent, "at the beginning of next week," I stopped calling. I missed the window for planting early vegetables on my half acre garden, had to buy emergency backups from a local Agway, and plant late. Many seeds that would arrive now will have to be put into cold sealed storage for next year. I definitely will not be ordering from them again.

Negative windy678
(1 review)
On Mar 10, 2002, windy678 wrote:

I ordered from their catalog on January 13th, 2002. My check cleared the bank on January 30th. Now it is March 10th and still no order. I have ordered and received several seed orders from different companies in the meantime. Now the customer service phone is always busy. Do these people really take orders on that line? I can't believe anyone would keep trying a bazillion times to reach these people to place an order. I have given up trying to get through to even check my order. I have learned one thing. If I ever try a new company again, I will try their customer service line first to see if there is anyone "home" before I even venture to use the company to throw my money away again.

Neutral me123
(1 review)
On Mar 1, 2002, me123 wrote:

I have had same experience with HR Shumway catalog order as reported by earlier customer. They had no trouble in cashing my check, but after 6 weeks, I still had not received any product or notification of reason for delay. The other seeds that I had ordered at the same time were already growing. It took me a week before I could get through on their constantly busy phone -- sometimes they just did not answer during business hours. Never got a response to my e-mail. Customer service was very abrupt and unfriendly; she did report that they were very busy with everyone canceling their orders because of lack of fulfillment. We even talked to a supervisor (when finally available) -- they could not guarantee delivery this season. Now, how long will it take for my refund to go through? Their catalog is cute and prices are low, but the information provided is minimal. And if they can't deliver, why bother ordering?

« Previous Page 1 | 2 | 3 Next »

Overwhelmed? There's a lot to see here. Try starting at our homepage.

[ Home | About | Advertise | Media Kit | Contact Us | Do Not Sell My Personal Information]

Back to the top